StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Playoffs - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Playoffs?" will examine the aspects of NCAA format organization. Specifically, the writer of the essay will argue whether or not the playoff system needs to be adopted and, moreover, how it will affect the assossiation.

 
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Playoffs
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Playoffs"

NCAA football has grown tremendously over the past few years, perhaps in large part due to the growth of the sport of football as a whole. Football has become America’s new pastime, which has caused for people to want to see the NFL stars of tomorrow on a regular basis. Despite this growth, the sport has not been able to truly evolve to the next level because there, often times, is not a true national champion. This is because since there are not any playoffs at the end of the season, the two teams who meet in the national championship come down to a vote. This almost always leaves a worthy contender out of the national championship game, making a team’s wonderful season seem like a waste. While there are reasons for this, such as the NCAA’s rich tradition of presenting prestigious bowls like the Rose, Orange, Fiesta and Sugar, the pros of having a playoff at the end of the season outweigh the cons, making an NCAA playoff something that should happen in the near future. There are some who believe that the Bowl Championship Series is a valid way of deciding a national champion. Since a ranking that is composed of the human elements “the Harris Interactive College Football Poll and the USA Today/ESPN Coachs Poll” (BCS Know How), and the BCS computers is applied to all of the teams, those who support the BCS system believe that it truly does choose the two best teams in the country to play for the national championship. This, however, is completely up for debate, as there have been some recent examples of teams who seemingly deserved to be in the national championship game being snubbed, and even a recent case where two national champions were crowned. In the 2003 season, there were three high profile one-loss teams in the nation at the end of the regular season, LSU, Oklahoma, and USC, with each of these teams believing that they should be playing for the national championship. Even though USC was ranked first in the AP poll, it was ranked third overall in the BCS standings, and even though Oklahoma lost in the Big Twelve Championship game, because of its placement in the other polls and was excluded from the BCS championship game. How is worked out was that USC ended up third despite “having finished the regular season #1 in both polls and averaged #2.67 on the computers. LSU was #2 in both polls and averaged #1.93 on the computers, and Oklahoma was #3 in both polls and averaged #1.17 on the computers“ (Callaghan et al. 892). Upon winning the Rose Bowl that season, USC remained first in the AP poll and, therefore, it shared the national title with LSU. This caused for the structure of the Bowl Championship Series to change, but problems remained intact after this. The very next season, “Southeastern Conference champion Auburn was undefeated in 2004 but was shut out of the BCS title game, which matched USC against Oklahoma. Utah also finished the season undefeated but could not play for the title“ (AP). Even as recently as the 2007 season, controversy has erupted, causing for discussions of a possible playoff system to emerge. The 2007 national championship game was played between Ohio State and LSU, even though teams like USC, Georgia, and Virginia Tech could have laid claim to playing in this game. The controversy will no doubt continue until a playoff system is implemented. Another reason why certain traditionalists do not wish to see a playoff system is because the bowls that are currently in place are so prestigious. For example, the Rose Bowl has been played for in every season since 1902, when “the Tournament of Roses decided to enhance the day’s festivities by adding a football game – the first post season college football game ever held” (Rose Bowl History) and the organizers do not wish to see it become less important. Currently, the Rose Bowl is played between the PAC-10 and the Big Ten champions, unless either of those teams is playing in the national championship game. If a playoff system were to be implemented, this game would hold less meaning because it would probably be awarded to a team that is not involved in the playoffs. Arguments like this, however, stand in the way of progress for NCAA football as a whole. Awarding a true national champion is much more important than the history of the Rose Bowl and the Rose Bowl would not have to be excluded from consideration. The winner of one of the semi-final games could be awarded the Rose Bowl, which is very similar to how this bowl is currently awarded. The winner of the Rose Bowl is never the national champion anymore, so awarding the Bowl for a semi-final win would be exactly the same, while still ensuring that an important game will be included along with the Rose Bowl festivities. This is once again a situation where the progression of the sport must be considered ahead of any nostalgia, as there is far too much controversy present to keep the same system in place. Those who support the BCS also believe that in most cases, that a true national champion is crowned at the end of the season. These same people also believe that the entire NCAA football season is like a playoff because one loss can eliminate a team from national championship consideration in any given season. While this is a somewhat valid argument, there are also seasons, such as this last season, where even two losses do not eliminate a team from consideration. In fact, Ohio State lost its final regular season game and still gained a spot in the national championship game because the Big Ten Conference does not play a championship game of its own. Kansas, on the other hand, lost its last regular season game as well, but its conference, the Big Twelve, holds a championship game. Kansas did not make this game because of their late regular season loss and, therefore, were not included in the conference championship game, essentially eliminating them from BCS Championship Game consideration. Ohio State, therefore, made it to the championship game because other teams lost, not because they won. This is something that the heads of the NCAA must work to eliminate because there must be a truly deserving national champion crowned every season. Even this last season’s national champions, the LSU Tigers, lost a late season game to Arkansas and made it to the national title game because of teams that were ranked ahead of them losing even later in the season, not because of who they beat. Politics and conference loyalties can often determine who plays in the big game every season and this is something that needs to end because it does not crown a true national champion every season. NCAA is in desperate need of a football playoff because of the tremendous amount of controversy that the current system brings about. The BCS system is very flawed and it will, often time, bring one or two undeserving teams to the national championship game. This leave other teams excluded from championship consideration, which can be frustrating because these teams could just as easily be playing for a championship. Those who do not support a playoff often cite reasons like the prestigious nature of the other bowls, the voting system’s complexity, and the regular season already being similar to a playoff as reasons why a playoff system is not needed, but these reasons all hold back the evolution of the sport. The BCS voting system is completely unreliable because it allows for personal preference to become a deciding factor, the other bowl games can still be played, even with a playoff, and the regular season is not like a playoff because it allows for teams who lose early in the season to recover more easily than teams who lose late in the season. Also, teams that do not have to play in a conference championship game are given an advantage, as it is one less competitive game that they have to play. By having the top sixteen teams in the country play a few extra games to decide a national championship, the NCAA could eliminate the controversy and the confusing by allowing the teams to decide on a true national champion on the field. Works Cited AP. "Congress to look into deeply flawed BCS system". ESPN.com. 2 December 2005. Viewed 16 April 2008. http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=2245440 BCS Know How. "The BCS Formula". Viewed 16 April 2008. http://bcsknowhow.com/# Callaghan, Thomas; Mucha, Peter J.; and Porter, Mason A. "The Bowl Championship Series: A Mathematical Review". Notices of the AMS. Vol. 51, No. 8. September 2004. PP. 887-893. Viewed 16 April 2008. http://www.ams.org/notices/200408/fea-mucha.pdf Rose Bowl History. Viewed 16 April 2008. http://www.rosebowlhistory.org/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1713424-should-ncaa-have-football-playoffs
(Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association Have Football Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association Have Football Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1713424-should-ncaa-have-football-playoffs.
“Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association Have Football Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1713424-should-ncaa-have-football-playoffs.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the National Collegiate Athletic Association have Football Playoffs

Case Studies and Readings in Sports

hellip; With the same vigor and passion with which he played football, Plank founded Under Armour that manufactured and sold high quality athletic apparels required by the sportsmen and women.... The products or the athletic apparels of Under Armour were of high quality containing highly elastic fabric which regulated body temperature and managed bodily perspiration that resulted in relatively light body weight that improved the sporting performance.... At that point of Nike was the market leader in the athletic apparel market with 21....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

Cartel Behavior and Amateurism in College Sports

His analysis at some point dwells on the role of national collegiate athletic association (NCAA) to curtail income for stakeholders in terms of payments for factors of production as proof of cartel behavior.... NCAA is cartel and members of such an association have to operate within the rules.... The football programs earn revenue from accounting profits.... This is the reason that informed the formation of College football Association (CFA)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A case Study of Football Association of Wales Strategic Plan

There are several professional players who compete at the national as well as the international level.... As the national football governing body in Wales, one of the duties of FAW is to run all the international teams which include the ‘A' team, Under 17, Under 19, Under 21, Women's Under 19, Women's Under 17, Women's and the Semi-Professional teams.... The game of football is inarguably the most popular form of sport in Wales; it is so popular that it is almost a part of the Welsh culture....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

National Collegiate Athletic Association

Facts: national collegiate athletic association (NCAA) is an unincorporated association consisting around 960 public and private universities and colleges.... rgued October 5, 1988 Decided December 12, 1988Parties: national collegiate athletic association (NCAA) and TarkanianPetitioner: national collegiate athletic association (NCAA)Respondent: TarkanianCourt: US Supreme Court Facts: national collegiate athletic association (NCAA) is an unincorporated association consisting around 960 public and private universities and colleges....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

NCAA Principles of Conduct and Divisional Philosophy

The paper describes principles of conduct and divisional philosophy of national collegiate of Athlete Association which was established with a motive to encourage both athletic and academic abilities of an athlete.... Donation Another NCAA requirement is that all staff members of the university are prohibited to donate any team memorabilia like T-shirts, autographed football or basketballs and other items to any organization, event or an individual.... The association wants its member institutions to give each and every individual equal opportunity without discriminating on the basis of race, ethnicity, religion, and gender....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Subsidies that Intercollegiate Athletic Programs

If the athletic departments develop a realistic budget, then they could easily have self-support.... This means that they have the capacity to become self-supporting and they need to become independent.... The broadcasting rights have affected intercollegiate athletics in several ways.... In relation to the economy, the forces of demand and supply of broadcasting rights make the intercollegiate athletics have a high demand due to the quality....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Intercollegiate Athletics Department

In the essay “Intercollegiate Athletics Department” the author discusses the University of Manchester's Economists Intercollegiate Athletics Department, which has proposed the given operating budget in alignment with mission and philosophy.... Institute has further recommended improved Mascot with IPAD....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Governance Structure of NCAA

The author of the paper examines the governance structure of the national collegiate athletic association, an organization that administers intercollegiate athletics.... They should emphasize making the athletes feel comfortable while working with them Governance Structure of NCAA the national collegiate athletic association is an organization that administers intercollegiate athletics.... Its first national championship event known as the national College Track and field championship took place in 1921 (Faghfouri, 2013)....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us