StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States' tells that in Qatar's government, the sovereign head of state had all the authority over everyone else, which is to say that his power was unlimited, until later in 2003 that it became a constitutional monarchy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States"

Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and United s In the government of Qatar, the sovereign head of had all the authority over everyone else, which is to say that his power was unlimited, until later in 2003 that it became a constitutional monarchy. Usually, the monarch is a hereditary seat or is appointed through a well-defined process from the family or group deemed fit to produce the monarch (Long, Reich and Gasiorowski 8). It has been ruled by the Al Thani family and the current Emir is Sheikh Tamam Ibn Hamad Al Thani. Sharia law is their main source of legislation and is a combination of civil law and Islamic law. The American government on the other hand is a federal government or a national government. Powers are distributed among different members of the government such as the judiciary, executive and legislative arm of government, and headed by a president whose powers are defined by the constitution. The president (head of state) is appointed through voting. The powers and duties of the government arms are defined by acts that are inferior to the Supreme Court. The government structure is based on the idea of federalism which holds that power must be shared. The constitution is the main source of legislation. There is not an independent legislature in Qatar and political parties are forbidden. The constitution adopted in 2003 provided room for election of 30-45 members of the council (advisory). The supreme executive authority in the country is the national council consisting of cabinet ministers and prime minister, and the Emir has powers to appoint and remove them from office. This council starts legislation, which is supposed to ensure successful realization of the goals set by any team assigned to evaluate affairs of the country (Long, Reich and Gasiorowski 8). The laws that they propose are passed to the advisory council which discusses them and passes them to the Emir to be ratified. He has the final say on all issues. The three arms of law in the American government each have their well-defined duties so that none of them is completely independent. The president vetoes legislative bills, is the commander in chief of the armed forces, and is responsible to appoint the members of cabinet who enforce laws (Long, Reich and Gasiorowski 8). The judiciary arm appointed by the president with the approval of the senate views laws and proposes those they find unconstitutional to be overturned. The Supreme Court has 9 members who serve for life. The court system is the governments’ way of judging against civil and criminal cases. There are no organizations forging for human rights in Qatar. Decisions concerning the public are not made transparently; the income and expenditure of the state are unknown, there is no information concerning the states investments or transactions, the national debt size is not known or published, the people hear of the deals the government makes with other states but they have no idea what that means and whether it would be of any benefit to them. There is no information about publicly owned assets such as land; they are basically passed along as gifts or tokens of appreciation. In the United States, human rights are greatly valued and embraced. Citizens are encouraged to know their rights so that they can recognize if these rights are denied, and be careful not to traverse other people’s rights. The United States, for most of its history, has had 2 political parties. Elections are carried out after every 5 years and the members of the political parties decide the viable candidate for presidency. The party that wins the elections controls the senate and the House of Representatives. Human Rights: Gender Issues Human rights concept has been one that has existed for a long time. It started when arguments were made to draw a basis for all the members of human kind. However, then not all members enjoyed the privilege as it often put women and slaves aside (Long, Reich and Gasiorowski 8). The rights were drawn from religious documents that argued these rights to be recognized as innate to all as they came from a higher deity. It was not until several years later that a commune of states set forth a declaration of a number of articles of these rights applicable to all humans. Although the set of rights were not binding to different states, they inspired many of them to adopt them. However, despite the numerous efforts to show the universality of these basic rights such that they are not limited by state, race, sex, place of origin or even culture, the rights have proven to be far from universal as in some states, issues such as culture prevent the adoption of these rights, and most often, the woman is denied these rights. As a result, organizations have been formed whose major focus is the rights of women and solve issues of gender based discrimination all over the globe as noted by Long, Reich and Gasiorowski (8). They enforce regulations and reach out to women who are being oppressed as well as helping those who seek them out. Also fights for gender equality have been launched and are being won in different states through the media and technology. Women are being made aware of their rights and given a voice so that they do not just helplessly watch as their rights are trampled. However, it is not everywhere that these uproars are listened to. In some states like the state of Qatar, women are considered inferior to men. This can be seen all through their systems, for example in the legal system whereby the woman’s testimony is considered an equivalent to half that of a man and in some cases, depending on the issues at hand, it is disregarded. The punishment for an immoral woman is way more than that of a similar male counterpart. They are not allowed to take positions of leadership as argued by Long, Reich and Gasiorowski (8). The government of Qatar has no women in the parliament whereas 16.6% of the members of parliament in America are women. In America, the fight for women rights has won more battles. They are considered part of the society and equal to men. It can be evidenced everywhere including in the government. Policies that were deemed oppressive to women are being revised with time and are becoming fairer by day. Women are becoming more and more aware of their rights and more willing to fight for them. Special gender publications are being made in America and seminars to empower women carried out. The efforts for women rights advocacy are proving to be very fruitful and meet minimal resistance from the government. In Qatar though, policies that are so rigid forbid such behavior accompanied by severe punishments for going against them. It is evident that the political state of a government influences the way in which members thereof live. Although recent developments have seen an improvement in terms of human rights and gender issues, they still face many various challenges in application of the set standards by the international body responsible, among them issues of jurisprudence, institutional issues and to the list, government laws (Long, Reich and Gasiorowski 8). Access to justice for these women continues to be hindered by those systems that have been put in place. How the human rights have been put to practice traditionally by the use of states, may have to be ignored when dealing with advocacy of rights of women in states such as Qatar. Work Cited Long, David E, Bernard Reich, and Mark J. Gasiorowski. The Government and Politics of the Middle East and North Africa. Boulder, Colo: Westview Press, 2011. Internet resource. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1860051-critical-analysis-paper
(Comparative Analysis Between the Government of Qatar and the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Comparative Analysis Between the Government of Qatar and the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1860051-critical-analysis-paper.
“Comparative Analysis Between the Government of Qatar and the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1860051-critical-analysis-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparative Analysis between the Government of Qatar and the United States

Qatar Airways Market Research

Owing to the deregulation in the united states, the airline business became more and more concentrated.... The main focus of this paper is Qatar Airways which is the countrywide air carrier for the State of qatar.... hellip; The average age of qatar Airway's aircraft is less than four years.... The image of qatar Airline that has been built by its initiatives is that of a progressive and premium airline that provides exclusive and outstanding customer service....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The impact of electricity deregulation on customers and employees in Qatar

The impact of electricity deregulation on customers and employees in qatar Abstract The following paper researches the culture sets of KAHRAMAA such that it endeavours to outline the effects of deregulation on the organisation in terms of both the employees and consumers.... Strategy fit with qatar vision 2030 56 5.... Summary 73 Chapter 6: analysis and discussion 74 6.... Summary 84 Bibliography 85 Appendices 91 Appendix 1: Survey / interview consent form 92 Appendix 2: Questionnaire 93 Appendix 3: Questionnaire analysis 96 Chapter 1: Introduction Introduction Electricity deregulation along with privatisation is referred to as ‘liberalisation....
80 Pages (20000 words) Dissertation

Qatars Sporting Legacy

Since the last two decades, the government of qatar has embarked on a unique policy to promote the local and international sports in Qatar.... nbsp;… The author states that the sports legacy of qatar is a unique mix of the new developments as well as the age old traditions.... This very fact speaks a lot about the sports legacy of qatar.... Actually, this potential of qatar has attracted the attention and appreciation of the world community and the international sports bodies and institutions....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Proposal

Mary Kay Cosmetics in Qatar

Strengthening relations between qatar and the united states help to set Pro-American climate, favorable for doing international business between these two countries (Wallace, n.... The legal environment of qatar provides relatively favorable climate for foreign investors.... Mary Kay Cosmetics in qatar Introduction The report aims to determine whether the Mary Kay's strategy to expand its business to the Middle East, qatar is a viable venture....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Qatar Sporting Legacy

68 Pages (17000 words) Dissertation

Implications of GCC Currency Union

Method of data analysis 30 Chapter 4 Data 31 4.... Prospects for a GCC common currency: Implications of GCC currency union Abstract The agreement to establish a GCC unified currency was forged early in the 1980s, and the deadline for the realization and implementation of such a currency was set thirty years in the future, in 2010....
48 Pages (12000 words) Dissertation

Money generated from illegal activities

This dissertation "Money generated from illegal activities" explores illegal sources of money.... Reportedly, according to the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, a total of 2% to 5% of the total Gross Domestic Product of nations around the world are laundered funds.... hellip; A significant percentage of all the money made around the world are not really what with think they are....
171 Pages (42750 words) Dissertation

Comprehension of Qatars Political Dynamics

The autocratic state of Qatar has been contributed by the consolidation of the Shiekh Hamad position within qatar and the royal family.... The following paper 'Comprehension of qatar's Political Dynamics' presents Arab Gulf monarchies stability which has been outstanding despite the high level of internal unsteadiness and regional conflict in the Middle East.... Forced abdication within the governing families has been identified as the cause of qatar's past leadership transitions of 1949, 1960, and 1995....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us