StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

On Miracles by David Hume - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper gives information about David Hume’s essay On Miracles which is a strong refutation of supernatural phenomena, often linked to divine intervention. Even if a claimed miracle is attested by numerous witnesses, its veracity becomes dubious if a greater number testify the opposite…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
On Miracles by David Hume
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "On Miracles by David Hume"

On Miracles by David Hume David Hume’s essay On Miracles is a strong refutation of supernatural phenomena, often linked to divine intervention. Hume states boldly that even religious events such as miracles should be judged on the basis of empirical evidence. He thus makes evidence the chief determinant of credibility. The credibility of a claimed miracle will increase in proportion to the reliability, method and number of witnesses. Hence Hume dismisses outright any kind of revelatory recounting of miracles.

Take say, the example of the resurrection of Christ three days after his death. Though it is an important miracle in Christian theology, it fails the rigorous standards of empiricism that Hume mandates. We only have references to the event in the scriptures, the writing of which happened much later than the event – sometimes centuries later. On top of this, those who witnessed Christ’s resurrection were invariably the faithful, who wished that it were so. Moreover, even if a claimed miracle is attested by numerous witnesses, its veracity becomes dubious if a greater number testify the opposite.

A major thrust of Hume’s thesis is that the burden of proof lies heavily upon those claiming miracles. Hume defines a miracle as that event which has defined laws of nature. As a consequence witnesses of miracles are required to bring high credibility to their evidence. But this is easier said than done, as there are inherent mitigating factors. Firstly, since an overwhelming majority of people are religiously inclined and have accepted miracles as acts of God, their psyche would lack the requisite scepticism and objectivity in evaluating a claimed miracle.

Second, individuals do not merely perceive events through their senses but through the lens of their cognitive faculties. Our cognitive faculties are trained and cultivated through our education and exposure to various life experiences. Since there is a great deal of variability among humans in this regard, no two individuals would perceive an event in the same way. Hume also articulates the ‘argument from miracles’. Since every religion claims its own set of miracles, the devotee to a religion believes in one set to the exclusion of the rest.

The same is done by the practitioner of another religion. So, for a neutral observer, every miracle has more disbelievers than believers. This begs the question if there is an element of fanaticism behind these beliefs.In my view, if I have to pick one flaw in the essay, it would be the element of circularity in one of the arguments. Hume recognizes miracles as those events that are exceptions to the natural order. By requiring testimony of huge numbers of people separated in time and place, Hume somewhat pre-empts any potential claims of miracles.

This is so because, historically, no miracle had ever been evidenced in such scale, and nor are they likely to happen in the future. Hence Hume’s imposition of enough satisfactory evidence to compensate for the highly exceptional of the miraculous event is a circular argument. On Miracles was published circa 1748. It was a key period in European history, as the hold of religious superstition was giving way to scientific understanding. Hume’s essay is an important contribution to the literature of the Enlightenment.

Although there is deficit of terminology in some of Hume’s arguments, they largely remain meritorious. In the two and half centuries since Hume’s essay, philosophical vocabulary is considerably enhanced and can rearticulate Hume’s thesis with greater cogency. Interestingly, while belief in miracles is not as rampant today as it was in the early 18th century, a great portion of humanity still holds such views. Exposure to Hume’s rigorous tour of logic will help move them toward rationality.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assignment #5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Assignment #5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1647751-assignment-5
(Assignment #5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Assignment #5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1647751-assignment-5.
“Assignment #5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1647751-assignment-5.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF On Miracles by David Hume

Book Review on The Gift of Health by Dominguez

david C.... This book is written from a Christian perspective about, as the name suggests, how and when faith helps in healing as well as when the “miracles” of… The writer is a medical doctor and a Christian, who explains the reasons behind sickness as well as healing and what it means in the larger scheme of things.... This book is written from a Christian perspective about, as the name suggests, how and when faith helps in healing as well as when the “miracles” of healing can be attributed to one's faith in God....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Hume-Faith and Reason

In his book “An enquiry concerning human understanding,” david hume observes, “Our most holy religion is founded on faith not on reason; and it is a sure method of exposing it to put to such a trial as it is, by no means fitted to endure.... To sum up, david hume makes his readers believe that faith and reason are alternative beats of the same heart; but the discerning one can clearly see that Hume's scale tilts in favor of reason!... ****************** Works Cited:david hume on the Miracle of Faith An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (LaSalle, III....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

August: Osage County:

david Singer.... david Singer.... david Schweizer.... Tracy Letts' August: Osage County, is an indispensable literary production that is set on natural modern day depicting the daily life of families in Oklahoma.... In essence, the Weston family members are the starring characters in this production, and are described as… As the play advances, it becomes imperative that the vanishing of the patriarch sets in a unique platform where the Weston family can considerably launch attacks against each Part I: The theme of Mother and Daughters in Tracy Letts' August: Osage County Tracy Letts' August: Osage County, is an indispensable literary production that is set on natural modern day depicting the daily life of families in Oklahoma....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

How Is Jesus Characterized in the Book of the New Testament in the Bible

From the genealogy given it is very deliberate that Jesus fits into Israel, and His story began a long… By highlighting persons like Abraham and david, Matthew draws attention to the promises of God, promises that faithful Jews were yearning to see fulfilled, hence Mathew's frequent use In Matthew Jesus asks his hearers to outdo the Pharisees at righteousness, that is, at faithful obedience to Torah....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Healing Fire in Londonderry by Bennhold

david Best took up the mission Unit and The Healing Fire Everywhere, people tend to hold conflicting beliefs on religion and other aspects of worship and divinity.... david Best took up the mission to try and unite the two parties with fire.... david Latimer talked of a light set on a hill, the burning of the temple could not be hidden.... david Latimer initially was skeptic of the tactics david Best employed to burn a temple....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Jesuss Birth by a Virgin Woman

Mary, the mother of Jesus was pledged to have been married to Joseph5, a descendant of david, but before they could come together she became heavy with a child conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit6.... This is because, before Mary and Joseph became a couple, Mary was pregnant with the child of the Holy Ghost (Mathew 1:18)2....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business

He rejects the miracles and acts of heroic asceticism performed by the saints to be precisely the same kinds of cheats as card tricks, but in this case, perpetrated by the devil for the stakes of human souls.... This is very much in line with one modern understanding of magic as a term of competition between rival groups: 'what we have is religion we do miracles: what our enemies have is magic and they do magic tricks' (Aune; Gager).... Even before her miracles, Mary Dempster was Dunstan's introduction to another kind of religious life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rise of Televangelism Rise and its Influence

Yet another factor that drew people to participate as audiences to televangelists was their ability to perform miracles and preternatural acts.... … The paper "Rise of Televangelism Rise and its Influence" is a brilliant example of an essay on religion and theology.... Spiritual leaders have explored several different options in trying to reach out to the world and spread the gospel to people spread across geographical, social and political boundaries....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us