StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Pick a stance on the rights of animals based on Peter Singer's article Famine - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Peter Singer and the Morality of Animal Rights This paper will look at Peter Singer’s moral equivalence argument in support of animal rights and draws from his article entitled “Famine, Affluence and Morality1” – demonstrating how the moral prescription underlined in his seminal work also make the case for the inescapability of human rights…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Pick a stance on the rights of animals based on Peter Singers article Famine
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Pick a stance on the rights of animals based on Peter Singer's article Famine"

Download file to see previous pages

The concept that we try to use to extract an argument for animal rights is the concept introduced by Singer that proximity does not matter. Whilst in this particular case, the proximity spoken of was geographic, .i.e., small child in neighbor’s house vis a vis a Bengali child, the proximity could also be in terms of species. In the logic of Peter Singer, animals cannot be denied rights given humans even if they are proximally different from the latter. Animal rights can find justification in theories of right that are embedded in time.

It is interesting to begin this exposition by looking at the fairly recent debate between Singer and Judge Richard Posner of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. At the heart of the debate was a statement made by Posner, that “human beings prefer their own. . The statement that “human beings prefer their own” should in itself be subjected to critical scrutiny. Indeed, the phrase “preferring one’s own” denotes a value choice in favour of an entity or a construct that hews closely to how one perceives him or herself and possesses many of the same characteristics that he or she has.

Indeed, the very same moral intuition that drives the argument of Posner is the same so-called moral intuition that has been the basis for the discrimination on the basis of gender (e.g., the discrimination against lesbians, gays, bisexuals and transgenders), of race (e.g., the discrimination against blacks) and of religion (e.g., the discrimination against Islam.) History has amply demonstrated the folly of taking that statement, “human beings prefer their own”, as justified and benign. The moral equality theorists argue that there must be an equal consideration of the interests of human beings and animals.

Peter Singer is perhaps one of the leading lights of animal ethics. He states the principle of moral equality as follows: The essence of the Principle of Equal Consideration of Interests is that we give equal weight in our moral deliberations to the like interests of all those affected by our actions.3 The main defense for this theory is that the properties that we ascribe to humans that distinguish them from animals are not properties that all human beings have, and thus, the logic deployed by those who distinguish humans from animals as a means to justify unequal treatment of humans and animals may give rise to a case of discrimination.

For example, not all human beings are capable of rational thought – an example would be infants. Some humans have dementia or schizophrenia. Does the argument then

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Pick a stance on the rights of animals based on Peter Singer's article Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464726-pick-a-stance-on-the-rights-of-animals-based-on
(Pick a Stance on the Rights of Animals Based on Peter Singer'S Article Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464726-pick-a-stance-on-the-rights-of-animals-based-on.
“Pick a Stance on the Rights of Animals Based on Peter Singer'S Article Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464726-pick-a-stance-on-the-rights-of-animals-based-on.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Pick a stance on the rights of animals based on Peter Singer's article Famine

Irish News Article within the Perspective of Animal Welfare

In the paper “Irish News article within the Perspective of Animal Welfare,” the author analyzes the topic of the different types of blood sports which are still currently legal in Ireland.... hellip; The author states that Phyllis Daugherty, the author of the newspaper article that discusses this practice proffers to the reader that the government of Ireland is currently considering legislation that would ban the practice of the “bigot” itself; however, such legislation would have no effect on the continued prevalence of fox hunting....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Misplace for Affections for Sexual Harassment

These policies are created as state model and they are wider enough to cover issues beyond behavior based on characteristics.... Evaluate the conduct of peter Fenning against the EEOC's definition of Sexual Harassment.... 16 directly deals with the sexual harassment cases and that is very well referable to the case of peter Fenning.... As per the definition of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Conduct of peter Fenning is generally offensive since he did not make any unpleasant or demark able sexual advancements and thus does not contain enough material to be concluded as a sexually offensive act or a sexually harassing deal....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Scientific Inventions and Discoveries

According to Schulmiller's article, technological inventions form the backbone of scientific pragmatism as demonstrated by the 1,500 pairs of Marty McFly Air Mag… Additionally, hysteria about the future is heightened by tweets and photoshop technologies that attempt to provide humanity with an illusion of good times ahead (Schulmiller 2).... Alternatively, the atomic-age architecture that defined the ‘50s and Science News article article I Scientific inventions and discoveries have resulted to numerous improvements and developments unlike in the past....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

The Relationship of Human Animals versus Other Animals

The entire novel is thus based on these issues.... The author also participated in the chimposeum, which took place in Chimpanzee and Human Communication Institute that is based in Washington, so as to study the chimps that reside there (World Fantansy Convention 207).... In the research paper “The Relationship of Human animals versus Other animals” the author analyzes the book We Are All Completely Besides Ourselves, which is influenced through the real life experiment that was conducted during the 1930s....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Aggression in Animals: A Tool For Survival

The paper “Aggression in animals: A Tool For Survival” looks at aggression in animals, which is one of the major behavior traits.... To understand why and how the animal's aggress, it is necessary to understand what behavior is and what role does aggressive behavior play in the life of the animals.... As 'aggression' is one of the behavior traits displayed by animals, it is also a result of the information processing that takes place in their brain....
12 Pages (3000 words) Article

Ensuring Children Rights to Education

he article speaks about the rights of a child to a bright future, and in assessing the subject of the article, the author has invariably answered several questions.... We seldom consider the rights of the children; we impose our decisions on them.... The rights discussed are not based on the subject of education only but they are based on variant practices of the social system.... n the first part of the article, the author Joel Feinberg has discussed the basic rights of the children....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Who Are the Animals in Animal Experiments

This also aims to point out the general ineffectiveness of the Animal Welfare Act when it comes to protecting the rights of animals.... ) The general ineffectiveness of the system to protect the rights of animals and the loopholes in the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) discriminates not only in the categorization of animals but those violating the code facing minimal charges for the infraction.... The ill management on the part of the government to protect the rights of living creatures other than humans and negligence in following established policies on the part of scientists....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

An Animals Place by Michael Pollan

hellip; Significantly, the growing and increasingly influential movement of philosophers, ethicists, law professors, and activists recognize the rights of animals as the great moral struggle of our time and this article offers an essential overview of the topic in general.... A growing and increasingly influential movement of philosophers, ethicists, law professors, and activists are convinced that the great moral struggle of our time will be for the rights of animals....
1 Pages (250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us