StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the right thing - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Socrates sacrificed his life as a way of standing by the principles he endorsed to others. Despite his tragic death in this fashion, the event has acquired him a martyr status among subsequent generation of intellectuals and philosophers. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the right thing
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the right thing"

What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the right thing? According to Socrates, a commitment to moral reasoning is an essential condition of a well-lived life. An individual should base his actions upon the outcomes of such internal dialogues. The exercise of self-examination and introspection as a way of arriving at moral truths is of paramount importance to Socrates. So much so that he unequivocally declared that “an unexamined life is not worth living” (Vlastos, p.121). This commitment to truth by way of rational, critical enquiry would eventually cost Socrates his life.

But, even when in sight of his impending death, Socrates calmly reasoned with his friends and supporters that accepting the judgment of the state is to follow the moral course of action and he refused to escape into exile. Socrates’ view of morality was espoused by his chief disciple Plato as well, who documented most of his master’s orations. We can deduce Socrates and Plato’s views on proper human conduct from the reasons the former gives in the face of impending death. For example in the Apology, at section 49c-d, “Socrates elaborates his leading premise to 'one should not wrong any person', adding to this 'not even if one has been wronged by him'.

At 49e5-7 he states a further premise 'one should do what one has agreed to do, provided that it is not wrong'. He then proposes that it follows from these premises that it would be wrong for him to escape (49e9-50a3)”. (Bostock, 1990, p.2) By reasoning in this fashion, Socrates puts principles ahead of self-interest. Moreover, his concern for law and order among Athenian civilians made him put public interest ahead of his own. For example, “if Socrates tries to escape, he will be attempting, for his part, to destroy the Laws, and (thereby) the whole city; for a city could not survive if the verdicts reached by the courts were set aside and rendered powerless by individuals. (50a8-b8).

” (Bostock, 1990, p.2) Socrates reasons that one should do nothing wrong, further adding that his own life till that point was lived in accord with this premise. Since disobeying Athenian laws would amount to doing wrong, he argues against his own bodily interest and surrenders to the court. He thus accepts the death penalty imposed on him as a matter of righteous conduct and lawful behavior. It is easy to extend this logic and come to the conclusion that Socrates thought that it would always be wrong for any citizen of Athens to disobey any law of the city.

But a detailed analysis of all of Socrates’ sayings shows that this is not the case. (Vlastos, p.128) Hence, Socrates sacrificed his life as a way of standing by the principles he endorsed to others. Despite his tragic death in this fashion, the event has acquired him a martyr status among subsequent generation of intellectuals and philosophers. And despite the official ‘guilty’ verdict, he stands acquitted of moral wrongdoing in its true spirit. Starting with Plato - his most illustrious pupil - intellectuals have taken inspiration and strength from Socrates' choice and have contributed to positive social change.

Works Cited: David Bostock, The Interpretation of Plato's "Crito", Phronesis, Vol. 35, No. 1 (1990), pp. 1-20, Published by: BRILL, Stable URL: , Accessed: 06/01/2010 19:31 Vlastos, Gregory (1991). Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424543-what-do-plato-and-socrates-believe-is-the-reason
(What Do Plato and Socrates Believe Is the Reason for Humans to Do the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424543-what-do-plato-and-socrates-believe-is-the-reason.
“What Do Plato and Socrates Believe Is the Reason for Humans to Do the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1424543-what-do-plato-and-socrates-believe-is-the-reason.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What do Plato and Socrates believe is the reason for humans to do the right thing

Platos Apology

The paper “Plato's Apology” looks at socrates statement about him fulfilling a divine mission, which can be understood in light of the Oracle of Delphi.... It should be noted that one of the charges on socrates was that he was a busybody, a humbug who inquires about the earth and sky.... hellip; The author states that socrates also inquires the politicians, the poets, and craftsmen to see if they were truly wise.... socrates wanted to find out and to prove that an ignorant man could be the wisest one in town, thus the questionings of the politicians, poets, and craftsmen....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Platos Republic and Political Nature

This is the reason for the interdependence of the inner structure of the man and the state, the interdependence of human types and types of state.... As a result, it would be right to say in this case that as no one thinks to challenge the diagnosis of the doctor, it would be absurd to resist the orders of a well-informed leader.... nbsp; It is a political work not in the conventional sense, but in the sense as socrates makes it understandable....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Socrates Political View

Additionally, the approach posits that people do not commit evil intentionally and that they can explain the different accounts that have transformed their lives.... The following essay is focused on the political views of socrates.... Admittedly, socrates philosophical approach concerns human nature and human reality.... … The author of the text provides the ideas expressed by socrates concerning politics.... socrates is considered as the most revolutionary political theorist in the history of politics....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

What Is The Nature Of Happiness

These consequences would mean that when the right thing is done, it will constitute to the person and to other person's happiness.... Philosophers like Plato, Aristotle and socrates have laid out ideas towards the true nature of happiness though none has been stated as true and the… Scholars through the ages are still in search for the nature and what happiness is all about. A question remains as centuries come and go and this is question is about what happiness is and its nature....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethics for Everyday Life

I believe that doing the right thing is the most important part in the discipline of ethics.... Ethics particularly focus on normative language as the individual is supposed to do the task based on the beliefs and not just accept the facts (Robin 1-9).... Finally, the ancient… what do they mean when they talk about the goal of our lives as eudaimonia?... what do you find most engaging in the discipline of ethics at this point in your life?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Socrates on Unexamined Life

Socrates was right to make this claim (Plato, 2015).... nbsp; Socrates insistence on this claim portrays that human beings are born or called to reflect upon their beliefs, speak to seek out, account for what they do not know and know, live accordance to their views and defend those beliefs that make a meaningful and well-lived life.... In case there is no value, it is upon the people to pursue the things that they believe are truly valuable....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Personal Thoughts on Plato: His Writing and Influence

Plato, indeed, is an inspiration that will forever make the human race realize that it is not enough that you believe.... This paper "Personal Thoughts on plato: His Writing and Influence" discusses plato as a firm believer in injustice and inequality.... hellip; plato did his best to stand for what he believed in, the same way that I fight for what I think is morally correct.... In two well-known dialogues, Timaeus and Critias, plato introduced one of the most remarkable of all geographical fables, that of the lost continent of Atlantis somewhere in the Western Ocean....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Four Doctrines of Socrates on Life

irtue is “the ability to do what is right and resist what is wrong.... This report "The Four Doctrines of socrates on Life" presents socrates who was, it seems, a rebel – someone who went against the grain of Athenian culture and dared to think his own thoughts and be his own person.... rdquo;… The philosopher socrates (469-399 B.... In almost every respect, socrates was very different from the ideal Greek citizen....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us