StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Experience and Other Evidence - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The researcher of this essay studied his personal experience with a larger political event and would like to voice his assessment of universal human concern, such as 'contentment' and try to refine his theory through the responses, that will be elicit from the audience. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Experience and Other Evidence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Experience and Other Evidence"

? Experience and Other Evidence: An element of my personal philosophy of life is regarding the dynamics of 'contentment'. Since the whole canon of Western Philosophy is centered on the causes, states and conditions of contentment, it is fair to say that my contribution through this narrative is a minuscule one. Yet, I would like to voice my assessment of this universal human concern and try to refine my theory through the responses it will elicit from the audience. I have synthesized my personal experience with a larger political event and have studied them both in a philosophical framework. I am hoping that the audience will eventually agree with me as they see the logic and weight of my arguments given below. I would describe my personal philosophy of life as closely allied to Epicureanism. Although this school of thought is grouped under Hedonism, it is markedly more moderate in the principles it espouses. As opposed to Hedonism, which is living life for the sole purpose of sensory enjoyment, 'restraint', 'control' and 'moderation' are the keywords describing Epicureanism. One of the sayings of Epicurus which had touched me and later influenced me was this: “A blessed and indestructible being has no trouble himself and brings no trouble upon any other being; so he is free from anger and partiality, for all such things imply weakness.” (The Principle Doctrines of Epicurus, 2011) There are unmistakable Buddhist undertones to this tenet – perhaps not a coincidence considering the blooming of Buddhism in Asia during the time of Epicurus. When I first came across this tenet a few years back, it immediately struck me as valid and relevant to the personal and political domains. That it was intended as an instruction to conducting personal life is obvious, but its political application is not straightforward. On careful reflection, though, the tenet's relevance to contemporary politics comes to light. Thomas E. Ricks' 2006 book titled Fiasco, The American Military Adventure In Iraq, helps us connect Epicurean thought to a major political event. For instance, Ricks notes in his book how the United States invaded sovereign Iraq for the sake of oil and not for the stated reasons. He also documents the human and material costs incurred by both sides, with costs being disproportionately high on the Iraqi side. (Ricks, 2006) Placing Ricks' findings and observations in Epicurean terms, I was able to synthesize the following argument: One could interpret America's continued occupation of Iraq as a manifestation of 'partiality', in this case toward so called national interest, which in turn translates into the interests of military contractors and oil corporations based in the country. The destruction of lives and resources on both sides is as a result of America 'troubling' itself and 'troubling' its distant and weak enemy in the form of Iraq. Further, consistent with the tenet, the invasion implies 'weakness' on part of the aggressor, more specifically a 'weakness' for material wealth (in this case fossil fuel). It is interesting to note that the wisdom of Epicurus, set out two millenniums ago, finds application in contemporary political actions as well as in an individual's personal life. In the case of the latter, I myself have been found falling short of being a 'blessed and indestructible being', for my occasional imprudent anger and partiality has gotten me into hot water a few times. One lingering memory in this respect is when I got into a verbal scuffle with a member of the audience during a college football game. I was slightly inebriated when my team was way behind in the game and the chance of winning was slim. At that point I over-reacted to a snide remark from a fan of the opposing team and got into a heated exchange. In retrospect I realized that though his remark was offensive it was not a defeat to my team and it did not mean anything significant. At that point I got the insight that my reaction is comparable to the way our government has conducted itself in the ongoing War on Terror operations. Just as I over-estimated the stakes involved in the defeat of my favorite team, the American government over-estimated the threat posed by Saddam Hussein and his illusory Weapons of Mass Destruction. There is a difference though, in that my adverse reaction was based on an over-spill of emotion (anger) whereas the government's estimated threats were construed and deliberate. (Burnham, et., al., 2007) Research team of Gilbert Burnham et. al., have elaborated on the misinformation campaign organized by the government (in collusion with the media) in their supplement to the second Lancet study. In the study they identify how American diplomats underplay Iraqi fatalities and hype-up Iraqi insurgencies. When I place this in the Epicurean framework, it is an obvious example of 'partiality'. My cheering for my football team (none of whose members I know personally) is similar to the cheering from jingoistic American citizens when the decision to invade Iraq was announced. (Ricks, 2006) Just a little bit of reflection made me realize that players of the opposing team are as hard-working, as meritorious and as deserving of their spurs as my own team is. Hence I questioned my allegiance to my team, when the real allegiance should be to broader aspects of the game like sportsmanship, fair-play, execution of skills, etc. Did all Americans similarly express solidarity with human beings in general, including innocent Iraqi civilians? I believe that, in order for civilization to progress, parochialism and narrow-mindedness will have to be overcome by embracing principles of solidarity and compassion toward fellow humans. Bringing about this transformation at the level of nations is a highly challenging project, given the power and efficiency of propaganda systems in place. But transformation at the individual level is more plausible. I personally have endeavored to mould myself in the Epicurean fashion with reasonable success and I implore members of the audience to consider this path. By embracing this philosophy, one can acquire a high degree of sophistication and refinement as a person. It will also enable an individual to navigate challenging phases in life with equipoise, stoicism and mental tranquility. More importantly, it will induce a state of contentment in the mind, which will make redundant conflicts and envy with fellow humans. Works Cited: Epicurean Philosophy, Principle Doctrines of Epicurus, retrieved from http://www.epicurus.net/en/principal.html on 30th January, 2011 Gilbert Burnham, Shannon Doocy, Elizabeth Dzeng, Riyadh Lafta, and Les Roberts., (2007), The Human Cost of the War in Iraq: A Mortality Study, 2002–2006, A supplement to the second Lancet study. Thomas E. Ricks (2006) Fiasco, The American Military Adventure In Iraq. Published by Penguin Books. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Experience and Other Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1406704-experience-and-other-evidence
(Experience and Other Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1406704-experience-and-other-evidence.
“Experience and Other Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1406704-experience-and-other-evidence.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Experience and Other Evidence

An Article Critique on Poverty and Culture of Daily Life

The evidence used by the author was varied as he used both secondary sources of information through the works and studies of different scholars; as well as through his own observation and immersion.... Therefore, all evidence was factual and was appropriately cited and referenced.... In addition, the author also presented three distinct cases or scenarios where some innovative poor individuals were able to get out of poverty and have enabled them to successfully improve their social standing and be focused on other pursuits, instead of being immersed in the culture of daily life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Evaluation and Judgment using Internal and External Evidences

Evaluation and Judgment using Internal and External Evidences The patients' examination and judgment is an evidence based evaluation that leads to viable decision making process in provision of medical services to the involved patient.... … Evaluation and Judgment using Internal and External Evidences The patients' examination and judgment is an evidence based evaluation that leads to viable decision making process in provision of medical services to the involved patient....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Nursing Evidence Based Practice

In the early 70's, the proponents of evidence based nursing practice noted the importance of research-based assessments in contrast to traditional methods of health care delivery.... Underlying the promotion of evidence based nursing practice is the need to improve health care delivery.... hellip; However, the use of the term "evidence based" had confused many practitioners.... Aside from misconceptions and misinterpretations, evidence based nursing practice is also plagued with debates and issues that need to be resolved....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Evidence-Based Practice and Empirically Supported Treatment in Future Practice

For example, if I documented efficacies of treatments and made such materials available through the internet and other medical information platforms, it will be a big boost in discovering new concepts which will help improve healthcare services.... evidence based practice in psychology is the medical process that entails the intentional and explicit use of currently available secondary sources of data and medical research journals as evidence towards a conclusive decision making....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

Evidence-Based Practice in Mental Health

According to O'Brien (2008 p 27) evidence based practice can be defined as the union of quality research evidence with clinical expertise and patient values.... In addition, evidence based practice can also be referred to as the application of quality research guidelines,… In this definition, several factors are important if put into consideration.... The three important pillars of evidence based practice should include clinical guidelines contained in the researches, Evident research should never refer to situations whereby there is whole sale imposition of research without attending to the patient....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Evidence-Based Practice

evidence-based practices in health care are understood to be those that use the most recent evidences to make enriched contributions that fit in with situational circumstances of each patient, to assist in establishing effective treatments and diagnosis to clinical problems.... This study attempts to develop a study that informs how evidence-based practice evidence-Based Practice in Nursing & Healthcare Introduction evidence-based practices in health care are understood to be those that use the most recent evidences to make enriched contributions that fit in with situational circumstances of each patient, to assist in establishing effective treatments and diagnosis to clinical problems....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Religion in Bloomington

The religious nature of Americans is spread across the states and other countries.... nbsp; There are many pieces of evidence that indicate that Bloomington is a religious center.... In this paper, I will analyze the evidence of religion in Bloomington, Indiana using pictures, descriptions, statistics, and interviews quotations.... Therefore, there is enough evidence from these statistics to believe that religion is present in Bloomington, Indiana....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Evidence based design-healthcare

evidence based design refers to the process of applying the best and most recent available scientific research to make designs decisions with respect to healthcare buildings that has positive impact on the outcome of healthcare activities.... As stated by Carr et al (28), evidence… ased design principles applied to deal with various building challenges include a combination of scientific research, advanced building technologies and software.... evidence based design also plays a very important role in improving the safety of patients in hospitals particularly Some of the factors considered in evidenced based design include the impact of getting connected to the natural environment on human biology and use of daylight, improving movement of people within a healthcare facility to improve safety, ergonomics, efficiency and hygienic issues which are very important for a healthcare facility....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us