StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Double Jeopardy - Essay Example

Summary
Double jeopardy in its most simplest of definitions is a procedural defense that forbids a defendant from being tried twice for the same crime that has the same set of evidence and facts. This law is enforced in many different countries: including Australia, Canada and the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Double Jeopardy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Double Jeopardy"

Download file to see previous pages

It provides three types of constitutional protections: protection against a second criminal prosecution after acquittal for the same offense, protection against a subsequent prosecution for the same offense after conviction and protection against multiple punishments for the same offense. Thus, the Clause ensures that the prosecuted is protected under US law. This clause is said to be one of the least understood amendments made to the Bill of Rights. This is especially because the Supreme Court has done precious little to remove any of the confusions that might have occurred.

The simplicity of this clause is the root behind all the confusion and the clause’s application. As stated by Justice McKay the same offense clause creates the “the most vehement disagreement among the Justice” (1983) To do the Court justice this is also because there were rarely any jeopardy cases that occurred before 1969. However when Benton v Maryland took place, it was decided that this amendment would be incorporated onto the Fourteenth Amendment making the clause compulsory on state and federal governments.

(Holmes 1991). One of the recognized and remembered cases created by the Double Jeopardy Clause occurred in 1990 in the Grady v Corbin case. The case involved Corbin who was driving under influence on the New York Highway. This state caused him to crash into two oncoming vehicles. The woman in the second vehicle died in this accident while her husband was seriously injured. On the same day, Corbin pleaded guilty for driving under influence and was charged with this offence. The Supreme Court ruled that charging him for homicide now would just result in a contradiction of the double jeopardy clause.

Thus, it was ruled that a subsequent prosecution would be barred if the essential elements of the prosecution had already been charged and the defendant has already been prosecuted (US Supreme Court Center). The double jeopardy clause prevents state and federal authorities from

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Double Jeopardy

Criminal justice case

The research presents criminal justice case where the defendant adopts 'nolo contendere' or no contest by not testifying his defense, there is a high possibility of Double Jeopardy as the different states have different laws relating to the acceptance of nolo contendere.... The conclusion from this study states that in this particular case of assault and robbery where there was a lot of media attention and public opinion, there is no possibility of Double Jeopardy as far as the denial of the defendant to stand in his own defense is properly recorded....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Concept of Double Jeopardy

The paper "Concept of Double Jeopardy" analyzes Double Jeopardy as a provision of the US Constitution's Fifth Amendment that seeks to prohibit the double prosecution or the imposition of multiple punishments on offenders for a single offense (Dictionary, 2010).... Double Jeopardy aims to ensure individuals remain protected against negative social, emotional, and financial effects resulting from successive prosecutions.... Finally, Double Jeopardy seeks to deter governments from using their superior resources against innocent persons....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

American Judicial Structure

In order to illuminate how these courts are in fact harmonized, this essay will examine the role and the jurisdiction of the federal courts, the role and the jurisdiction of state courts, and some nagging problems such as Double Jeopardy. ... An exception is an issue referred to as Double Jeopardy. ... The Double Jeopardy Issue: A Lack of Harmony ... ost generally, Double Jeopardy is a legal principle incorporated into the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution which states that “nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Double Jeopardy by Bruce Beresford

The paper "Double Jeopardy by Bruce Beresford" discusses the movie directed by Bruce Beresford refers to a 1999 American thriller film.... One of Elizabeth's fellow inmates offers her a piece of legal advice concerning the 5th amendment of the US Constitution called the Double Jeopardy clause (Rudstein 14).... Due to the Double Jeopardy clause provided by the constitution, Elizabeth will not get convicted again for shooting and killing his husband in the film....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Review of Law and Economics: Double Jeopardy and Mandatory Sentencing

The writer of this paper states that Double Jeopardy is a defense strategy that prohibits multiple charges in the same criminal act following a legitimate conviction or acquittal.... A defendant is protected against being put 'twice in jeopardy' through the application of Double Jeopardy rule.... he Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution prohibits Double Jeopardy (Levmore & Porat, 2011).... Lesser-included crimes do not violate Double Jeopardy as it concerns different criminal violations that are tied to one another....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

5th Amendment Double Jeopardy

In the report '5th Amendment Double Jeopardy' the author analyses Double Jeopardy, which according to the Fifth Amendment states explicitly that one should not be subject for the same offense more than once putting in jeopardy life or limb.... 5th Amendment Double Jeopardy Double Jeopardy, according to the Fifth Amendment s explicitly that one should not be subject for the same offence more than once putting in jeopardy life or limb (Jahncke, 1991); it is provided for by the constitution as a guarantee and it encompasses several protections....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

The Rule of Double Jeopardy

This report "The Rule of Double Jeopardy" provides the exposition on the Double Jeopardy rule in which different legal perspectives of this rule have been elaborated.... Comparative analysis of Double Jeopardy and the Criminal Justice Act of 2003 and its part 10 has been evaluated.... The rule of Double Jeopardy has been misused by the defendants in fact has only provided benefit to the offenders and lawbreakers.... The introduction and implementation of part 10 of the Criminal Justice Act of 2003 have repealed the rule of Double Jeopardy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Rule Against Double Jeopardy

This report "Rule Against Double Jeopardy" focuses on is the act of subjecting someone to the court proceedings for a matter that has been concluded for a second time.... The rule against Double Jeopardy was effected after a series of considerations.... Rule against Double Jeopardy Introduction Double Jeopardy is the act of ing someone to the court proceedings for a matterthat has been concluded for a second time1.... The main objective of the law against Double Jeopardy is to prevent the state from dealing with accused persons the way they want, and also to strengthen investigations because once the accused has been acquitted, the law would not allow the same to be brought back....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us