StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The status of the right to sell human organs is a collision of multiple social factors, cultural norms, religious beliefs, and human morality that conflict, contradict, and clash into a result where everyone is right, yet the practice is still deemed illegal. The prohibition…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS"

Download file to see previous pages

The risk benefit factor seems contradictory, but the ethical considerations are every bit as conflicting. There is a legal precedent for the right to privacy and the right to self-determination for our own body. There is likewise a legal precedent that allows intrusive government intervention when it involves a human body and a medical procedure. Ethical considerations work to protect the poor, uneducated, and disadvantaged from being exploited, but still prohibit the act when viewed as goodwill in the attempt to save a life.

Sorting out the rationale and status of selling a kidney in todays marketplace is like trying to solve the riddle that is wrapped in an enigma and cloaked in a mystery. The more we make sense of it, the less sense it begins to make. The traditional carte blanch prohibition on the sale of kidneys needs to be re-evaluated in light of todays greater social awareness, improved medical procedures, and misplaced moral considerations. The prohibition on the sale of human organs has evolved as the technology necessary to accomplish the transplants became more widespread in the 1960s.

Initially, a person or the family could make deceased donor organs available for transplant, though it was often unclear whether the permission needed to be granted by the donor before death, or by the family after death. In 1968, the Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA) authorized the prior permission of the deceased or permission from the family if no prior permission had been granted. However, the UAGA did not address the sale of organs, and left it to the states to settle the question of financial remuneration.

At that time, the chair of the UAGA drafting committee warned that "It is possible, of course, that abuses may occur if payment could customarily be demanded, but every payment is not necessarily unethical" (Childress & Liverman 2006, p.230). This

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS Essay”, n.d.)
Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552166-q-should-indivduals-be-permitted-to-sell-their-kidneys
(Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS Essay)
Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552166-q-should-indivduals-be-permitted-to-sell-their-kidneys.
“Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552166-q-should-indivduals-be-permitted-to-sell-their-kidneys.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Q/ SHOULD INDIVDUALS BE PERMITTED TO SELL THEIR KIDNEYS

Ethics of the Sale of Body Parts

Generally, it is the poor who sell their organ to the rich and not the other way round.... Such kidneys were being obtained from living individuals in exchange for a fee, with most of those kidneys being acquired from poor members in the society (Browning, 2001).... In section 10, the revised version states that, individuals should not intentionally for valuable reasons, sell or purchase human organs for therapy or transplantation, if the removal of such organ is meant to be carried out after the demise of the decedent....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

PERSUASIVE ANALYSIS

He retains this attention on human rights by stating that "if the law recognizes our right to give away an organ, it should also recognize our right to sell an organ.... While continuing his negation of opposing views, Holcberg dismisses their concern for the possibility of people committing "murder to sell organs," as scaremongering and uses evocative words such as "financial lure" and "difficult-to-execute criminal action" to suggest that organ trade would decrease the number of murders....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Relative Contributions of Dietary Sodium

The ingested sodium is first filtered in the renal glomerulus and approximately 70% is reabsorbed in the proximal tubule.... Further reabsorption of sodium occurs in the… About 65-70% of the total body sodium is present in an exchangeable form.... The exchangeable sodium is made up of extra cellular and intracellular sodium....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Why the sale of human organs should be legalized

According… They can decide to sell it, give it away, or dispose it off through other convenient ways (such as burying it).... Studies show that the number of people on the queue to get life-saving organs (often the kidneys, eyes parts) have been growing steadily over the last two decades, whereas the number of potential organ donors has stayed constant (Woodcock 1-3).... In the US, just like in many parts of the world, sale of organs is permitted....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

There Should Be Development of a Market for Human Organs

The paper "There Should Be Development of a Market for Human Organs " states that in present times of critical shortage of human organs like kidneys, this governmental strategy to discourage the development of a market for human organs has more negative implications.... The following discussion will help to prove this argument by providing evidence about the shrinking number of donors of organs like kidneys in the light of reputable research.... nbsp;… According to Crane and Matten Consumer Sovereignty model, consumers should be able to decide which products get sold and which should not be produced....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Radicals and organ donations

According to a research, it has been noted that the deceased donors tend to provide kidneys, liver and lungs that have saved many lives globally.... These entail of catering for the individual basic needs to ensure that they survive and creating equal opportunities by giving the individuals a right to… The Radical Economic Perspective (RAD) is usually attributed to the U....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Article Kidneys for Sale

Just the legislature or a particular charitable organization would be permitted to buy the kidneys, and they would apportion them on the premise of need as opposed to riches, in a similar manner that the posthumous kidneys are being distributed.... It is noteworthy that the decision to sell one's body parts should be the sole decision of the seller.... If a person chooses to sell his kidney, it should be an individual choice.... Nonetheless, the proponents fail to figure out the likely numerous other conceivable impacts of permitting people to sell such organs (Taylor, 2005)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Antibiotic Doripenem

The paper "Antibiotic Doripenem" presents that pyelonephritis is a kind of UTI (urinary tract infection) that impacts one or all the kidneys.... Pyelonephritis condition makes the kidneys to enlarge and can lastingly damage them.... hellip; Doripenem is above all assisting to preserve unaffected kidneys.... From the bladder, the microorganisms propagate up through the urethras to the kidneys.... But any severe infectivity in the bloodstream can extend to the kidneys and lead to acute pyelonephritis (Madara and Pomarico-Denino 2008)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us