StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Test Obsessed Education Wont Move Us Ahead - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article "Test Obsessed Education Won’t Move Us Ahead” argues the school education system in the US should be overhauled. This industrial model of education devised during the beginning of the 20th century has far outlived its utility. He is critical of the standardized testing system…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Test Obsessed Education Wont Move Us Ahead
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Test Obsessed Education Wont Move Us Ahead"

No Child Left Behind: Test Obsessed Education Won’t Move Us Ahead David Marshak, in his article, ‘No Child Left Behind: Test Obsessed Education Won’tMove Us Ahead” argues that the present school educational system in the United States should be overhauled. The educational system which is the product of the “industrial model of education devised during the first two decades of the twentieth century,” (Marshak, David, 2003) has far outlived its utility. He is very critical of the standardized testing system in general and in schools in particular. He believes that “it may take only a few years before parents become sufficiently enraged with standardized –test obsession to demand an end to it. Perhaps, a rebellion against this standardized will open the door to the reshaping of our schools and the implementation of much more sophisticated and effective accountability measures.” (Marshak, David, 2003). He further adds that we need to reinvent education by teaching students how to be creative, which requires long term relationship between students and teachers. So the present system of changing teachers every 50 minutes should be stopped and teachers be appointed for one to two year to develop personal relationship with students. Students should also have common learning goals and individuals learning goals. Moreover, he believes that in future curriculum should include synthesis, problem solving, creativity, and analysis promote inventive thinking. Though some of his ideas seem to be good, it may not be practical one. In order to understand the hollowness in his arguments against standardized testing system, one should know how it functions. A test which is conducted in a standard manner is called a standardized test. This testing system gauges candidates against one another and a standard is fixed to assess progress in a school, aptitude to attend institutions of higher education and to put candidates in programs suited to their aptitude. These tests are designed in a special way that rules for conducting, questions, interpretations, and scoring pattern are reliable and conducted and scored in a prearranged, standard manner. United States enacted elementary and secondary education act, 1965 which made it mandatory standardized testing in public schools. In 2001, United States passed US Public Law 107- 110, which is also called ‘No Child Left Behind Act of 2001’, which binds public school funding to standardized testing. It consists of true- false and multiple-choice questions. Generally, it is a computer adaptive test. Some standardized testing have essay writing and short answer components which are evaluated by impartial examiners who use sample answer papers to evaluate it. But a number of standardized tests are not scored by people. Critique argues that though tests are examined for clear bias, offensive terms and hidden biases can never be eliminated and there is little scope for demonstrating candidates skills in reasoning, critical thinking, deductive logic and creativity. Moreover “as a result of standardized tests and teacher decision making, high numbers of students of color are placed in low-ability and non college-bound tracks.” (Karen B. Mclean Donaldson, Praeger, 1996). But all these arguments need further proof to substantiate it. One of the main advantages of the standardized testing system is that the results can be practically documented. So the test scores have a high degree of reliability. Some other advantages of these tests are “the standardization of these tests ensures that test-takers are being measured objectively on the same material. The grading is standardized, so test scores are the same no matter who or what is scoring them. This removes any bias that might stem from the scorer. On the other hand, tests that use subjective grading might yield scores that vary widely depending on who is scoring them.” (Standardized Testing Advantages). In the absence of standardized testing system there is a possibility of disorder in the educational system due to different educational culture, curriculum, difference in teaching style and grading system. It makes standardized testing system unavoidable for admissions purposes in higher education where an institution has to evaluate students from across the nation. Another advantage is aggregation. It provides an assessment of students command over subjects. However some of educationists say that misuse of standardized testing system can have serious negative consequences, since standardized testing system is the most important factor in accountability, there may be tendency to use the testing system to define curriculum. But these are not valid reasons for abandoning the system rather it is a criticism of poorly designed testing regimes. Standardized Testing System is cheap, very fast to grade and allow decision makers to look at a wide sample of individuals. One of the fundamental ideas of standardized testing is to eradicate subjective factors from assessment. As a result, it makes the decisions of the admissions committee easier as they need to compare and evaluate hundreds of students who take these tests. Moreover, it is very helpful in predicting how well students perform in the institutions they applied. It will also forecast success more accurately than interview. One of the main purposes of this test is to compare the aptitude and skills of students from various schools. For example, the admission committee will have candidate’s grade point average, but there is a possibility that one school might give easier course material than the other one. So how can the admission committee compare the abilities and skills of different candidates? “By measuring students on the same skills and knowledge, standardized tests give admissions committees a more objective assessment of students’ potential performance at the schools to which they are applying. Some argue that standardized tests only reinforce cultural bias in education, but these tests nonetheless provide a valuable tool for admissions committees.” (Standardized Tests 101.com). One of the arguments of David Marshak is that public has become highly dissatisfied with standardized testing system. But Richard P Phelps writes “public support for widespread and consequential use of standardized testing is overwhelming, and has been since pollsters first posed questions about tests. Over several decades, the scale of the large magnitude of public support has barely budged. Indeed, the public would like to see standardized tests administered: more often (more than once a year), and for all the purposes for which they are now administered, as well as some for some others.” (Phelps, Richard P. 2004). Summary David Marshak strongly argues the need for overhauling the present school educational system in United States. He also wants this system to be abolished as these tests have little scope for demonstrating candidates skills in reasoning, critical thinking, deductive logic, and creativity, for reinventing education by making students creative. In order to do so, he advocates developing personal relationship between students and teachers. The ideas seem good, but may not be practical. Moreover, his criticism about standardized testing system has gone overboard, as abolition of the system may entail total chaos in the school educational system. It is the most feasible method to evaluate students who come from different educational culture, curriculum, difference in teaching style and grading system. Moreover, for selecting candidates for higher education, educational institutions need to evaluate candidates based on their aptitude. It is also cheap, very fast to grade, and allow decision makers to look at large number of candidates. Though no testing system is fool proof, and standardized testing has its limitations, among the existing circumstances, it is the best. Syllogism Reason A 1. Standardized testing system should be allowed to continue in United States. 2. Standardized tests are designed in a special way that rules for conducting, scoring pattern, questions and interpretations are reliable and carried out in a prearranged, standard manner. 3. Standardized testing system should not be abolished. Reason B 1. Standardized tests should continue in schools in United States. 2. It ensures that all students are examined objectively 3. Therefore standard testing system should continue. Conclusion From the above, it becomes obvious that David’s criticism of the standardized testing system is not based on sound logic and therefore cannot be agreed to. It is a time tested system which has been instrumental in assessing students and its abolition will only be detrimental to the education system. The best suggestion seems to be to find ways to make the system more effective if there are any defects in it. Works Cited Marshak, David. No Child Left Behind: Test Obsessed Education Won’t Move Us Ahead. 8 Feb. 2003. Seattle Times. Fine, Michelle., and Lois, Weis r. 1993. Beyond Silenced Voices: Class, Race, and Gender in United States Schools. NY: State University of New York Press: Albany. p. 45. Karen B. Mclean Donaldson, Praeger. (1996). Through Students Eyes: Combating Racism in United States Schools. Westport: CT. Publication. p.16 Standardized Testing Advantages. Standardized Tests 101.com. 2006. 21 Apr. 2007. . Standardized Tests 101.com. 21 Apr. 2007. . Phelps, Richard P. (2004). Defending Standardized Testing. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, NJ. Publication. p.21. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Argument-Deliberative (4 pages) DIRECTLY addressing a specific Essay”, n.d.)
Argument-Deliberative (4 pages) DIRECTLY addressing a specific Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540257-argument-deliberative-4-pages-directly-addressing-a-specific-audience-who-holds-a-proposition-with-which-you-disagree
(Argument-Deliberative (4 Pages) DIRECTLY Addressing a Specific Essay)
Argument-Deliberative (4 Pages) DIRECTLY Addressing a Specific Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540257-argument-deliberative-4-pages-directly-addressing-a-specific-audience-who-holds-a-proposition-with-which-you-disagree.
“Argument-Deliberative (4 Pages) DIRECTLY Addressing a Specific Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1540257-argument-deliberative-4-pages-directly-addressing-a-specific-audience-who-holds-a-proposition-with-which-you-disagree.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Test Obsessed Education Wont Move Us Ahead

Early Childhood Education in NZ

Growing up, I was exposed to adults spoon-feeding information to us, and we were expected to just accept the 'wisdom' that our elders passed on to us.... It is only now as an adult that I realize how much our learning was limited because it was just dictated to us.... In order to learn about their interests, they move around and play.... In the paper 'Early Childhood education in NZ' the author reflects regarding education system in New Zealand....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Child Education

his paper comes to the conclusion that the biggest issue facing the teachers is children's education.... This paper talks analyzes educaton for children.... Early childhood can be said to include a set of; principles, concepts as well as facts.... As such, they not only tend to explain and describe the process involved in the transformation of immaturity aspect to the maturity status and functioning but also account for them....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Education - Malcolm X

Which similar setting in school could possibly make us, in the same fashion, dream of wanting to be in 'education'?... The paper "education - Malcolm X" discusses that Malcolm X, after a drastic turn of fate from good to bad, had regained interest in education in prison through gradual observation of an inmate's life which motivated him to obtain knowledge by reading with an insatiable appetite.... ike Malcolm X, there comes a point when education means learning from people outside of the academe....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Discussion in special education

However, parents have the right to know if the school district is properly disbursing the funds earmarked for special education students.... In this case, teachers and other professionals give suggestions on how to prepare a child for an accurate assessment and ensure that a positive test-taking environment is provided....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sheffield City Council: Standardization of Recruitment Processes

This research study 'Sheffield City Council: Standardization of Recruitment Processes' is being taken to find out the reasons and solve the problems regarding the same.... The study will not only find the root of the problem but will also sincerely try to find few valid solutions.... ... ... ... The author states that one of the most important functions of any HR Department is 'Recruitment and Selection'....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Issues in Teacher Education

This essay "Issues in Teacher education" discusses early childhood teachers who had difficulty identifying specific print-to-speech concepts of the English language composition, basic skills related to beginning reading instruction.... It is clear that loss rates increased with the length of time and therefore much was lost by the youngest at the original test....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Functional Writing Skills and Grammar

Question 1 of the test demands that a student compose an 800-word essay discussing the importance of girl child education.... The first question will be answered based on candidates' skills in composition and understanding of the topic of discussion (girl child education).... anguage students at the 2nd stage of secondary education are expected to be able to create their own composition which must be standard and specific to certain guidelines....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Context of Culture and Context of Situation

As the paper "Context of Culture and Context of Situation" tells, the terms "context of culture" and "context of the situation" were coined by Bronislaw Malinowski.... Language can be fully understood when the two aspects are interpreted explicitly or implicitly by the interlocutors.... ... ... ... Language exists within a culture....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us