StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Scientific Management: Experiments and Findings - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Scientific Management: Experiments and Findings" focuses on the critical analysis of the major experiments and findings in the field of scientific management. It is a science-based system of organizing the operational areas of the organization…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Scientific Management: Experiments and Findings
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Scientific Management: Experiments and Findings"

Scientific Management Experimentation and Findings Developed by Frederick W Taylor in the early 20th century, Scientific Management is a science based system of organizing the operational areas of the organization so as to ensure the existence of and implement the following elements: (Wrege, 1995) Placement of the right man at the right place, at the right time. A study of the motions and material handling practices within the organization, so as to find the fastest and easiest way of carrying out an activity. The implementation of cost accounting in all areas of operation activities. De centralization of responsibility and authority so as to place a group of men under the supervision of one man. To create room for four to eight functional foremen who will take care of various aspects of the overall task, so as to ensure that each sub task is carried out as regards minimum motion and cost per worker. (Taylor, 1947) These were the broad underlying principles upon which F W Taylor fashioned scientific management. This school of management thought followed experimentation and scientific rigor to demonstrate various findings. One of these, as will be tested below, adheres to the fact that through mediums like assembly line, it is possible for a group of people doing a few tasks, to out produce those doing all the tasks. Experiment Anukul Designs is a company that has been in the business of manufacturing exclusive patchwork linen, for the last 20 years. The assembly line followed in this company will be tested during this experiment. This experiment has been carried out to prove the following conclusion: "A team of people working together, each tending expertly to one or a few tasks, can out produce the same number of people each performing all of the tasks." The experiment will be carried out through the following phases: Recruitment Selection Placement Functionality Study In the Recruitment stage, the applications are invited for positions like tailors, cutting experts, tacking experts, finishing experts and finally, supervisors. There is a need for 24 tailors, 8 cutting experts, 12 tacking and quilting experts, 12 finishing experts, and 4 supervisors to oversee these four activities. In the Selection stage, there are interviews and practical tests to find which applicant is best suited for which job in the operational activities. Also, they are questioned regarding their leadership abilities so as to find four supervisors who also know enough about the job. In the Placement stage the following structure is defined along with role play of each person: The basic job of the supervisors in this assembly line is to do the following: Find the shortest time to do an activity and reduce movement between departments. Motivate each individual appropriately. Get maximum cost economy from each group. Restrict material handling quantum by dividing the amount of material to be handled among various individuals. Find ways to break monotony in repetitive activities. This brings us to the final phase known as Functional Study. By working in a group, the supervisors held meetings with each other at the end of the day. This brought about better communication and synchronization of activities. Also, they got a chance to discuss any strengths and weaknesses so as to garner second and third opinions on tacking and taking advantage of the same. This led to standardization of activities along the lines of a set formula. This formula involved the following: The work culture has to be one where there is constant reinvention and innovation. This can be brought about by allotting responsibility to a new man every day. Detailed reporting helps in the psychological molding of the men. This was an important area which the supervisors focused upon. The best use of men came from keeping them at the machines for the longest time. There was an increased use of ramps and pulleys for the transportation of material. Also, there was a consensus among the supervisors that the material handling capacity must be divided for better accountability. (Taylor, 1947) By implementing these rules, the following was the motion and time study at the end of the second month: Old Method New Method The number of yards workers covered per day was reduced 500 120 Average number of tons per man per day 34 68 Average earnings per man per day $2.20 $2.90 Average cost of handling a ton of 1500 lbs $0.055 $0.025 Togetherness V/s Individuality In the modern day organization, the group effort is everything. In the case of Anukul Designs that we have taken in the previous section, there were no departments or groups. The charge of cutting, joining and completing one bedspread/ linen accessory was given to one tailor alone. There was a group of 34 tailors working this way. Needless to say, the productivity level was low and accountability was also in the same state. The above experiment based on Anukul Designs will show that with a coordinated effort between the supervisors, in passing and handling material, there was a 38% decrease in the movements that were carried out between departments. This in turn led to more production on the part of the workers who were able to focus on the task at hand rather than movement between departments. The supervisors kept one person of each of their groups at half the distance between the departments to collect the material and deliver it. This cut movement by distance as well as time. Also, it helped imbibe a certain amount of freshness into the monotony of repeating the same activity everyday. Further, there was interaction between workers from various departments which helped them gain a new quality in the operational sphere through the laying of strong informal lines of communication. The supervisors deployed a new person everyday. Further, there was decentralization within the group with the deployment of a group leader. (Clegg et al, 2005) These measures led to higher productivity and the workers were able to handle 50% more work load in terms of material conversion and material handling. This led to a 7% increase in the earning capacity of each worker. Further, there was new sense of competition and initiative within the workers in order to earn incentives and bonuses. With the help of all these measures, there was an overall decrease in the cost of material handling by close to 75%. This led to increased savings for the company. This experiment shows that working a group in close coordination, yields higher results than working individually. Once a person's niche area of expertise is known, he or she must be deployed in that particular area so as to maintain focus. This also helps in building team spirit as each department or person is interdependent on the other. The communication lines grow stronger and there is a greater feeling of responsibility and accountability. (Stinchcombe, 2001) The decentralization of accountability, authority and responsibility help in making better use of the human capital. It gives the workers the scope to bond with each other and know more about each other's strengths and weaknesses. In this way, there is a strong support system within them and this helps integrate the personal aspirations with the organizational goals in a more effective manner. Therefore, it is imperative for group activities and groupism to thrive along more formal lines in the organization so as to avoid the pitfalls of individuality where it becomes difficult for one person to undertake all tasks effectively. (Taylor, 1895) Factors that discourage improved productivity in group activities The following are the factors that can work against the fact that a group generally out produces individuals working on the same job: Lack of clear cut demarcation of job responsibilities. This can lead to the existence of confusion regarding one's actual job. Paucity of men and material. This a factor that can lead to over loading the workers with tasks. Also, in the absence of adequate material, there will be an overall wastage of time and money. Lack of motivation. If the employee or worker is not well motivated, he or she may not want to give his or her best to the activity or task at hand. This will greatly impede productivity. Lack of proper communication channels. The laying of communication channels - both formal and informal - is a major pre requisite for coordination. The lack of proper communication between people in the group will lead to disharmony. Lack of coordination. It is important for the people in the group to understand each other for the purpose of proper coordination of plans and the integration of personal goals with those of the organization. Monotony in activities. If a task is repetitive in nature, chances are that the workers may not take adequate amount of interest. Thus, they will fail to produce enough. Placement of the wrong man in the wrong job. This is a crucial factor. At the recruitment and selection stage itself, it is important for the organization to get a feel of the individual's skills. This will help in appropriate placement according to the skill sets of the individual, which in turn will help in proper production quantum, as well as non wastage of money, time and material. Lack of training and developmental activities. In today's organization, the role of training and development is an important one. This helps understand the individual and motivate him to multi task more than anything else. By learning something new, the individual gains the confidence to grow, which in turn will help the organization grow. (Clegg et al, 2005) Examples of Methods to encourage better productivity Assembly lines, as the experiment in this paper will depict, are a good way of organizing the resources of an organization to garner maximum productivity in terms of set lines of movement and material handling. Other examples of methods that can be used to improve productivity include human reason as well as job design. The first method, i.e., human reason is one that involves a logical thought process which will ultimately lead to complete understanding of every element in the operational process. This will help the worker better envision his or her role in the process. The second method, i.e., job design is one that deals with a focus on the job description and its elements so as to ensure that the worker realizes the importance of his or her role or job. Both methods help integrate the personal goals of the workers with those of the organization. (Stinchcombe, 2001) References 1. Clegg, S., Kornberger, M. & Pitsis, T. (2005). Managing and Organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. 2. Stinchcombe, A. (2001). When Formality Works. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. 3. Taylor, F. (1895). A Piece Rate System. NY: McGraw Hill. 4. Taylor, F. (1947). Scientific Management. NY: Harper & Row. (originally published 1911). 5. Wrege, D. (1995). "F.W. Taylor's Lecture on Management, 4th June 1907." Journal of Management History 1:1:4-7. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Scientific Management Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words - 1”, n.d.)
Scientific Management Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1521001-scientific-management
(Scientific Management Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1)
Scientific Management Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1521001-scientific-management.
“Scientific Management Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1521001-scientific-management.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Scientific Management: Experiments and Findings

Ethical Problems in the Field of Positive Psychology

According to the research findings modern society has come a long way therefore, most of the philosophical discoveries have no real practical application to the present day society that continues to evolve with the passage of each minute.... Psychological researches have an ethical code that contributes in enhancing or diminishing the validity and reliability of its findings.... Informed consent, legality, honesty, integrity and protection of human subjects are some of the ethics that a study needs to incorporate to validate the findings....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Animals are Friends, not Scientific Experiments

This research paper "Animals are Friends, not Scientific experiments" seeks to quickly review animals as friends of man, and not scientific experiments.... ainful experiments on animals can make most people uncomfortable.... Those involved in primate testing, however, argue that these experiments are necessary in order to establish cures for diseases, and the fact that primates have more in common anatomically with humans, makes them the best candidate for experimentation (Guerrini, 2003)....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Incorporating Experimental Research Designs in Business Communication Research

Experimental research methods could also help solve the problem of the realism of the environment and will open a new door for another set of problems because of the associated replications of findings (Babbie, 2010, p.... This reveals that field experiments can be used in business management and decision-making.... So let us explore some actual applications of field experiments in the business context.... Field experiments engaged actual real-life setting of experimental manipulations within a natural environment in which business, economics and management research usually has considerable engagement because of its external validity to identify causation (Elsevier, 2009)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Are Laboratory Experiments the Best Way to Carry out Research

The "Are Laboratory experiments the Best Way to Carry out Research?... focuses on the critical analysis of whether laboratory experiments are the best way to research in social psychology.... What is important is that it is now possible to do these experiments so that they effectively add to our understanding of the dynamics of the behavior of groups in real-life situations.... Thinking through the answers to these questions on a specific problem makes it clear that before we can begin to use the powerful technique of laboratory experimentation effectively, we must already have gained much understanding employing other techniques, such as observation of uncontrolled situations and field experiments under less strictly controlled conditions....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Research Methods in Business and Management

Qualitative stance can be defined as follows: "Any kind of research that produces findings not arrived at by means of statistical procedures or other means of quantification" (Strauss and Corbin, 1990: 17).... ualitative research reveals findings observed in the real world context where the phenomena being studied unfold naturally (Patton, 2002).... Instead, credibility, transferability, and precision play very important roles in determining the validity of qualitative findings (Hoepfl, 1997)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Hawthorne Studies Experiments

The author of the "Hawthorne Studies experiments" paper explains to what extent he/she agrees with the appraisal that despite their fame, the Hawthorne Studies experiments were too poorly designed to demonstrate anything but the need for careful controls in scientific research.... We cannot correlate the field of science and research with the 'Hawthorne experiments' as there is nothing in terms of production it is the patience and endurance that pays....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Hawthorne Studies Issues

The early part of the 20th century was dominated by American Business enterprises that were swept by a surge in terms of scientific management, which has its roots largely from the works of Frederik Taylor.... Two important findings emerged out of the studies which are popularly referred to as the effect of the experimenter and the Social effect.... In fact, Taylor utilized the elements of time as well as motion studies in order to break down management into simple and manageable chunks, thereby providing a better way for the manager or worker to execute these chunks....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Effects of Water and Heat Variation on the Volume of Long-Grained and Short-Grained Rice

here are several types of designs of experiments that can be adopted in such situations.... However, going deeper into the natures of individual situations, it is apparent that individual, specialized designs of experiments suit different experimental situations.... The paper "The Effects of Water and Heat Variation on the Volume of Long-Grained and Short-Grained Rice" is a perfect example of a management research paper.... The paper "The Effects of Water and Heat Variation on the Volume of Long-Grained and Short-Grained Rice" is a perfect example of a management research paper....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us