StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Implications of Non-Renewal for a Faculty Members Career Path - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In Roth, the Court refuses to find a protected liberty interest because the plaintiff was “simply not rehired.”  The paper "Implications of Non-Renewal for a Faculty Member’s Career Path" explores whether the Court means to suggest that the plaintiff was not injured by the non-renewal…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Implications of Non-Renewal for a Faculty Members Career Path
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Implications of Non-Renewal for a Faculty Members Career Path"

Paper Question In Roth, the Court refuses to find a protected liberty interest because the plaintiff was "simply not rehired." Does the Court mean to suggest that the plaintiff was not injured by the non-renewal What are the implications of non-renewal for a faculty member's career path P.242 In Board of Regents of State Colleges v. Roth, the Supreme Court held that a non tenured teacher does not have a property interest in his or her teaching position. Likewise, the Supreme Court also found that a public college professor dismissed from an office held under tenure provisions, and college professors and staff members dismissed during the terms of their contracts, have property interests in continued employment. Thus because the public college professors and staff members dismissed from an office held under tenure have a property interest in their jobs, the property interest is safeguarded by due process. Thus, the Court made it clear that due process is required when depriving an individual of his property right, including a public employee's earned tenure. Additionally, the court has also made it clear that the property interest must be a present one and not one perceived or one that a person might have in the future. Here, the court is not saying that Roth was not injured. Indeed the question is not actually answered because the court's examination ends once they conclude that that Roth's position is not one that is a vested property right and therefore not subject to constitution protection. As the court noted: "In these circumstances, the respondent surely had an abstract concern in being rehired, but he did not have a property interest sufficient to require the University authorities to give him a hearing when they declined to renew his contract of employment." Accordingly, the Court does not have jurisdiction to decide what if an injury was suffered by Roth, because his constitutional rights have not been affected. Once the federal court concludes that there is no jurisdiction, that is the end of the inquiry. As to" implications of non-renewal for a faculty member's career path" I think that the implications are rather clear. If one in applying for a position at a public school or university, they are best advised to learn first what the tenured track is, and further to understand that without tenure, there is not a property right thus no protectionsat least on a constitutional level. Question 2 - What institutional practices or policies may create a constitutionally -protected property interest in one's job May faculty members in private institutions have such a property interest in their jobs Board of Regents v Roth demonstrates the Federal Courts' definition of property for constitutional purposes and due process protection examination. Against that backdrop, I would say that a public facility such as a state hospital, public school or library that has the offering of a position which can be substantially likened to the tenure track of a public university is one that could create a constitutionally protected property right. A crucial point to remember though is that the Court concluded that Roth had no "liberty" interest in any specific teaching job, and that he had no "property" interest in his job because he lacked "a legitimate claim of entitlement" under state law to his job. Property interests, the Court stress, must be found in the statutory or common law of the jurisdiction. Thus if there is no statutory or common law authority regarding the position, there is no constitutional protection to be afforded. Without a legitimate claim of entitlement to his job, the Court reasoned, there is nothing to have a hearing about. Faculty members in the private sector do not have any constitutional protections in a privately held university. The United States Constitution does not apply to every form of employment in the United States. The first issue with any federal claim is that it had to have been committed by a state actor and under color of state law. The federal courts do not have constitutional jurisdiction therefore over the acts of a private college or university. Their jurisdiction is limited to the examination of state actors. Accordingly, faculty members in private institutions do not have a property interest in their jobs. Problem 6 Question 2 What factual information does the administration need before making the decision The administration must firstly decide whether professor Gemi is the only female professor available to the school at the salary that the school can pay. Secondly the administration should also be evaluating whom if any, faculty would be eligible for a merit raise next year. Additionally, the university should scale the pay progression of the proposed professor to their university as against that which the other university is offering because while they may be able to match the university pay for now, down the line, they may not be able to. Moreover, the question arises as to whether the professor would eventually be on the tenure track and if that does happen, will the university be able to afford it. What legal information does it need Although elite university is a private institution and not subject to constitutional confines, it must be noted that naturally, faculty members cannot be expected to sit back and not be entitled to merit pay because the administration had to satisfy a quota. The university needs to know what searches and the results therefrom of equally qualified applicants. They must also be able to demonstrate the diligent searches that have they endeavored in which to find appropriate female faculty members. I think that it will be crucial to demonstrate to the affirmative action committee that efforts have been made to find the scholarly equivalent to this female applicant and that ultimately the school is acting against its' interests in foregoing earned merit pay to professors in favor of satisfying a bald affirmative action requirement. Simply stated, if the diligent efforts have indeed been made to find a female faculty member without putting the university's other professors at risk, than there is no affirmative action violation. Problem 6 Question 5 Would the legal issues change if Dr. Gemini had not received an outside offer, but merely demanded a bigger salary and threatened to leave if the university didn't comply I think that the issues would still be very much the same. As I noted earlier, this is a private university so the issues are not so cut and dry as they would be if it was a public university. If Dr. Gemini wants to leave the university , she is certainly welcome to. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case studies Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Case studies Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516233-case-studies-case-study
(Case Studies Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Case Studies Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516233-case-studies-case-study.
“Case Studies Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516233-case-studies-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Implications of Non-Renewal for a Faculty Members Career Path

Avoiding Burn-out in Community College Technical Educators

The different challenges that impact the faculty's teaching effectiveness at community colleges include heavy and repetitive workloads for instructors due to a diverse student population, most of whom are academically underprepared.... The paper "Avoiding Burn-out in Community College Technical Educators" focuses on the critical analysis of the effective methods by which community college technical educators can avoid burnout related to their work....
33 Pages (8250 words) Term Paper

Rational Accommodations to Safeguard the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

The paper "Rational Accommodations to Safeguard the Rights of Persons with Disabilities" describes that the basic concept of disparate treatment can be defined as 'the employee is claiming that the employer treated her differently than other employees who were in a similar situation.... .... ... ...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Clinical Link Learning Activities

The essay "Clinical Link Learning Activities" focuses on the critical analysis of the major clinical link learning activities.... Provision of person-centered life care requires a comprehensive and well-coordinated assessment process that can support patients.... ... ... ... People at the end of life often experience wide-ranging and complex needs hence the need for effective holistic assessment....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Career Field Analysis: Top Executive

The manager can also help their career towards top executive positions by familiarizing themselves with management techniques in programs, which are sponsored by various trade associations and the industry.... The career of top executive positions have evolved because of changes in the management structure, age, and size of companies.... The executive consults with other executives, staff, and board members on issues that involve general operations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

The Admissions Committee at University School of Medicine

As a result of these experiences and owing to my inclination towards a medical career, I volunteered for the American Red Cross in San Francisco in 1992.... The writer of this essay " The Admissions Committee at University School of Medicine" discusses type a brief letter on a subject outside of medicine, which has been an area of great interest to him....
28 Pages (7000 words) Admission/Application Essay

Graduate Student Services - The Delivery of Services at Locations Where Students Matriculate

This paper 'Graduate Student Services - The Delivery of Services at Locations Where Students Matriculate" investigates and explores the best method for the delivery of graduate student services.... Essentially, there are two methods for the delivery of these services.... .... ... ... Centralized delivery of services refers to a system by which graduate student services are delivered from a remote location....
75 Pages (18750 words) Dissertation

The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act Court

This essay discusses the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act Court.... When a group of Americans who were protesting against the Vietnam War decided to blow up a local CIA recruiting office, information against their plan was collected through electronic surveillance.... .... ... ... When the matter was taken before the Supreme Court, the judges ruled that a court order was necessary before authorizing security agents to collect information....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

Career Field Analysis of Top Executive

The paper 'career Field Analysis of Top Executive ' is an actual example of a professional case study.... The paper 'career Field Analysis of Top Executive ' is an actual example of a professional case study.... ypical career PathMost positions for top executives are filled via promotion of lower level and experienced managers when openings occur with most promoted from the organization itself.... The manager can also help their career towards top executive positions by familiarizing themselves with management techniques in programs, which are sponsored by various trade associations and the industry....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us