StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Article by Gordon Fee - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Read the article by Gordon Fee and answer the following questions: How convincing is Fee in his contentions that (a) this passage is a non-Pauline interpolation and that (b) therefore it is not binding on Christians
Fee provides a convincing argument that this is a non-Pauline interpolation rather than a genuine…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Article by Gordon Fee
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Article by Gordon Fee"

Download file to see previous pages

Thus on the basis of its rarity and illogicality it seems as though the words were not originally written by Paul but were in a fact a subsequent interpolation. The second major argument that seems convincing is that "one can make much better sense of the structure of Paul's argument without these intruding sentences." This is based upon the idea that Paul's argument should be logical and coherent rather than apparently more impressionistic and illogical. In and of itself the idea that Paul's argument should be logical does not necessarily imply that it is logical in this case.

But Fee provides an exhaustive, detailed explanation of how the passage (without the interpolation) is a traditionally Pauline piece in terms of substance and structure. This includes the rhetorical, argumentative question of "or did the word of God originate with you" . Fee is convincing because he is apparently balanced in his argument. Thus he does allow that "if one were to conclude that vv.34-35 are authentic, they would appear to be best understood as something of an afterthought to the present argument.

" While Fee does not consider such an "afterthought" very likely, he at least places it within the realms of possibility. Rhetorically, this is an effective device that allows the reader to take on board the main thrust of Fee's argument without believing that he has something of an axe to grind. More proof is provided by Fee through the pointing out of the fact that "these verses stand in contradiction to II:2-16 where it is assumed without reproof that women pray and prophesy in the assembly.

" Other possible explanations, such as the idea that Paul is in fact quoting from someone else here, is effectively dismissed by his suggestion that "it presupposes the unlikely scenario that some in the church were forbidding women to speak - and especially that the quotation would come from the same Corinthian letter that is otherwise quite pro-women." Thus even if Paul is quoting, it seems unlikely that he would want to quote from those who are supposedly "anti-women" when his argument actually stems from the opposite point of view.

Here Fee implies that Fee is simply too good a writer, with too broad a knowledge of his subject and too great an arsenal of persuasive skills to fall into such a trap. Thus Fee succeeds in effectively making it both unlikely that Paul actually wrote these verses in the context of other interpolations as well as the fact that the verses would simply not make sense within the context of the writing that surrounds them. Paul is not attempting to limit the role of women in the rest of this Letter, so it seems unlikely that he would suddenly start to do so here. b)The idea that the verses are not binding on Christians, because they are, as Fee convincingly suggests, non-Pauline in nature is a perhaps more complex matter.

This assumes that Paul's actual writing is the inspired Word of God whereas that of the unidentified, later interpolator is not. If this is the case then these verses need not be binding on Christians. Fee's argument is based upon the perhaps more sophisticated idea that Bengel's first principle should be adhered to. Thus "the form of the text is more likely the original which best explains the emergence of the others". The verses that in question here clearly do not best explain the emergence of

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee
(Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee.
“Article by Gordon Fee Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1499373-article-by-gordon-fee.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Article by Gordon Fee

Materialism in Amy Rosenbergs Work

1.... Amy Rosenberg's article.... Victoria Frances is materialism personified.... She is a Manhattan editor obsessed in buying, out of a psychological need to escape her childhood's poverty.... A turning point came when she received the gift of an expensive Jeep Cerokee handbag.... hellip; It revealed her distorted materialism....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Egyptian Celebrities: Scientists, Writers, Politicians, and Actors

In this article, we'll try to have a look on the major personalities of Egypt in the field of Science, Showbiz, Literature, and the Politics and we'll try to discuss their views about the revolution in the Egypt and what's their opinion regarding the former President Mubarik.... hellip; He was born in Cairo, the capital of Egypt....
16 Pages (4000 words) Article

A Coherent Planning Strategy to Unitary Development Plans

Since the abolition of the Greater London Council (GLC) in April 1986, London has been without an elected strategic planning authority.... Individual London boroughs are now expected to prepare strategic policies for their own areas, incorporating them into their new Unitary Development Plans (UDPs)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Article

Marketing Mix: Apple iPhone

The paper "Apple iPhone" tells us about the marvel of modern technology.... Equipped with a high-resolution in-built camera and a mini media player, the Apple iPhone is blessed with perfect picture quality and the ability to shoot, store, record, and send data from one location to another.... hellip; Apple is a new player in the cellular phone market; nonetheless, it has successfully managed to do introduce a product that is not only attractive but also efficient in terms of technological enhancements and durability....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Word of Mouth Helps Them Fly Off the Shelves by Schneider, K

The article Word of Mouth Helps Them Fly Off the Shelves proves the idea that modern businesses cannot survive without effective online interaction.... The most interesting fact is that word-of-mouth advertising penetrates into the online environment becoming one of the advertising tools on the Internet....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Leadership and Management: Solution of Conflict Resolution

The author states that organizations are composed of various people with different beliefs, ideas, and norms working collectively.... In an ideal setting, they work together uniformly to achieve the desired end result.... However, conflict is a part of life and adverse situations will occur.... nbsp; … In an ideal situation, coworkers would work together harmoniously to achieve desired end results....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Top Female Leaders Around the World

According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that gordon Ramsay is one of the strictest yet swanky leaders on earth.... This research will begin with the statement that Tarja Halonen is a superb example of leadership quality.... She was a lawyer and due to her exceptional leadership qualities, she climbed the ladder of political hierarchy and got to the top, became the president of Finland....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Wall Street Journal

The WSJ article on NYC building workers strike basically touches on the importance of implementing effective business strategies to achieve… Hence, this paper summarizes the article by relating it to chapter thirteen of the book: Business Policy and Strategy, The Art of Competition. According to Babson, Van Deusen and Williamson (19), Wall Street Journal: NYC building workers vote to ize strike In today's rapid fire, global economy, insightful business policy and on-target strategy are essential for a corporation's survival....
1 Pages (250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us