StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Foundation of Business Law - Case Study Example

Summary
The "Foundation of Business Law" paper contains advice for Jane regarding her claims against Dan for revoking the offer before the stipulated time and states that Jane is not liable for any claims from Disco John concerning her cancellation of services.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Foundation of Business Law"

FOUNDATIONS OF BUSINESS LAW I QUESTION ONE A Dan For advising Jane regarding her claims against Dan for revoking the offer before the stipulated time, the following issues have to be considered. 1 Issue The issue to be addressed is whether revocation of offer before the stipulated time amounts to a breach of contract? 2 Law The tests to be followed are those for revocation of offer. The revocation of an offer amounts to a breach of contract only when there is consideration for keeping the promise open for a specific period. 3 Authority Revocation of offer: Goldsbrough Mort v Quinn.1 Knowledge of Revocation of offer through a third party: Dickinson v Dodds.2 4 Application In this problem, the tests for revocation of offer had been applied and were satisfied. Dan revoked the offer within the stipulated time. Since there was no consideration, the offer need not be kept open for any period. In Dickinson v Dodds, one of the parties had agreed to sell a property to the other party. This was open for a specified number of days. As such, this was an offer. Subsequently, the other party obtained information that the vendor was about to sell the property to some other individual. This caused the other party to give a notice of the acceptance to the first party.3 The court held the offer of the seller as revoked, as the buyer had been aware of the intention of the seller to negotiate a sale with some other party. Moreover, there was no necessity for the seller to inform the prospective buyer about the proposed sale.4 In the absence of consideration, the promise to keep an offer open for a specific period is not valid. Strictly speaking, an option is a guaranteed option to act, and this guarantee assumes a contractual form. An instance of this is the option to purchase at the end of a lease or within specified time. Such options are to be found to a greater extent in transactions relating to land. 5 Options provide a convenient method for retaining offers in an open position. In such instances, the offer, by itself, establishes a contract and this makes it necessary for the offer to be kept open for a specific period. The exercise of such option brings another contract into existence. 6 In Goldsbrough Mort v Quinn, the defendant had provided the plaintiff with an option with respect to the purchase and lease of land. This option was to remain in effect for a week. However, the defendant declared the option closed, within the week, and stated that the option had been furnished as a consequence of a mistake. The Plaintiff had accepted the offer, prior to the expiry of the week.7 The Court held that in the absence of consideration, a promise to keep an offer open for a specific period was unenforceable. 5 Conclusion In this problem, the tests for revocation of offer were applied and satisfied. Dan is not liable for breach of contract, as he need not keep his offer open until Jane repays the security bond, as required by him; since there was no consideration in this regard. Although, Dan revoked the offer without any communication to Jane; as per the above discussion, she cannot claim against Dan for revoking the offer prior to her return with the security fund. B Disco John For advising Jane with respect to Disco John’s claims against her, the following issues need to be taken up for discussion. 1 Issue Whether Jane’s refusal to use Disco Johns services amounts to breach of contract. Whether Jane can rely on the doctrine of frustration in her defence. 2 Law The tests to be applied in this situation are with respect to the doctrine of frustration. The contract will be terminated automatically due to frustration. 3 Authority Contract annulled due to frustration: Krell v Henry.8 4 Application In this problem, the test for doctrine of frustration was applied. Jane booked the services of Disco John for her party at the venue. However, the venue was unavailable to her due to Dan’s contract with some other party. In Krell v Henry, a contract was formed, whereby a room overlooking the coronation route of King Edward VII was to be provided on hire. The sudden illness of the King resulted in the cancellation of the coronation, and the court held that the contract was cancelled due to frustration.9 The contemporary Australian legal position with regard to such situations is provided in the ruling in Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales.10 In this case, the plaintiff was forced to incur additional expenditure due to a court injunction. The Supreme Court of New South Wales, ruled that the contract was frustrated by the injunction.11 5 Conclusion As per the above discussion, Jane is not liable for any claims from Disco John with respect to her cancellation of services. This is because; doctrine of frustration annulled the contract between Jane and Disco John. II QUESTION TWO For advising Jane with respect claims for the harm caused, due to issues like sanitation, against Max the following discussion needs to be conducted. 1 Issue The issue to be discussed are whether claims can be made against Max for the harm caused by the unsatisfactory sanitation and substandard production of the beer that had been consumed at Jane’s party. 2 Law In Donoghue v Stevenson, it was held that any person had to take reasonable care to circumvent acts or omissions that could reasonably be expected to cause injury to others.12 3 Authority Duty of care in negligence: Donoghue v Stevenson. Duty of care with respect to manufacturing defects: Grant v Australian Knitting Mills.13 4 Application With regard to a product liability claim in negligence, there are four elements. These are; first, the defendant should be an individual who owes a duty of care to a class of individuals that comprises of the plaintiff. Second, the defendant should have breached that duty of care. Such infringement could be due to the supply of a product involving a manufacturing, design, or informational defect. Third, foreseeable damage should have been undergone by the plaintiff. Finally, the loss or damage to the plaintiff should be attributable to the breach of duty of care by the defendant.14 Lord Atkin, in his ruling in Donoghue v Stevenson, held that any person had to take reasonable care to circumvent acts or omissions that could be reasonably expected to cause injury to another. This was reiterated in Tame v New South Wales,15 by Gummow J and Kirby J, who stressed that the tort of negligence did not demand anything more than reasonable care to avoid risks that were reasonably predictable. The benchmark for liability is rationality of behaviour.16 As per the opinion of Lord MacMillan in Donoghue v Stevenson, the reasonableness of the defendant’s conduct had to be evaluated on the basis of the changing community values and circumstances. During the daily interactions of business and social life, individuals tend to be exposed to a vast array of relations with other individuals. Thus, the law has to be limited to a reference to the norms of the reasonable man, whilst establishing whether some specific association resulted in a duty to exercise care, with regard to the entities involved in that association.17 In Grant v Australian Knitting Mills, the plaintiff developed a rash after donning contaminated underwear manufactured by the defendant.18 The plaintiff sued both the retailer and the manufacturer. The court ruled that the manufacturer was liable for having breached a duty of care and for the defective products.19 The manufacture and supply of a product that leads to damage or loss, on account of defective manufacturing, constitutes a breach of the duty of care. An instance of this is the supply of a contaminated product, a product that fails prematurely, or in a manner that is inconsistent with normal wear and tear on account of defective manufacturing.20 Theoretically, in such instances, the duty of care could be satisfied if the defendant were to implement a manufacturing system that was safe, along with a mechanism to ensure the exercise of care by employees, during the course of effecting that system. The duty of care would also be satisfied if the defendant were to establish a system aimed at checking the products for imperfections. If the manufacturing defect in a product is the result of an act or omission of some other party, such as the entity that manufactures the component parts of the product, then the defendant supplying the flawed product will not be deemed to be in breach of the duty of care.21 5 Conclusion In this problem the tests for duty of care in negligence were applied. According to the above discussion, Jane can claim damages from Max for the harm caused to her close friends, who lost an opportunity of procuring jobs, due to the illness caused by the beer supplier Max. BIBLIOGRAPHY A Articles/Books/Reports Gillies, P, Business Law (Federation Press, 2004) Halsbury's Laws of Australia, 338 – Product Liability: (B) Elements – Negligence in Product Liability (LexisNexis, 2008) Maggi, M, Review of the Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) 2002-2003 (Kluwer Law International, 2004) Maxwell, C, ‘Too Much Law? Risk, Reasonableness and the Judge as Regulator’ (2009) 14(2) Deakin Law Review 143 Moles, RN, Networked Knowledge – Contract Law Casenotes Moles, RN, Networked Knowledge - Law Lectures B Cases Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337 Dickinson v Dodds (1876) 2 Ch D 463 Donoghue v Stevenson (1932) AC 562 Goldsbrough Mort v Quinn (1910) 10 CLR 674 Grant v Australian Knitting Mills Ltd (1936) AC 85 Krell v Henry (1903) 2 KB 740 Tame v New South Wales (2002) 211 CLR 317 Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Foundation of Business Law

Marketing planning of Roddick Foundation

According to the research findings a charity, in the UK, is a body established under the law of England and Wales for exclusively charitable purposes.... In order to analyze the business environments, various business analysis tools such as SWOT analysis, gap analysis and strategic recommendation, possible competitor reactions etc will be included in the paper.... The focus in this paper is on the Roddick foundation as one of the recognized charities in the UK....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Life of John D. Rockefeller and his legacy

he patriarch was “twenty-three years old and already a success in his profitable commission business when he decided to risk $4,000 in a speculative oil refinery operation in Cleveland” (Armentano, 1981, p.... Rockefeller began his business, both the Petroleum industry and the Standard Oil Company were “inchoate” (Montague, 1904, p.... Rockefeller deployed his “complete and undivided attention” to the petroleum business (Armentano, 1981, p....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Foundations of Business Law

FOUNDATIONS of business law QUESTION 1 To effectively ascertain whether or not Lumieres Sound and Lighting System has a valid claim and cause of action against Roxanne, in lieu of Sting, under the law, an analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding the case is proper.... The claim is contingent on whether or not who possesses legal ownership of the business enterprise in question under the law, and therefore liable for the obligations derived there for....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Foundations of Business Law

George's business has been quite profitable this year and George asks Gerry where he should put his money in order to obtain a good yield and reduce his tax payment.... Back at work George has a discussion with his business partner Kosmo about the state of finance of the business and mentions Gerry's suggestion about the Facebook Shares....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Foundations of Business Law

The paper "Foundations of business law" tries to find out whether there is any legally binding agreement on the issue observed here.... law - for a valid contract there must be an intention or willingness to be bound, a firm promise; and communication of the offer.... Being the owner of Cozinha Do Pilao, a restaurant in Adelaide, my sisters Bethany and Princesa had just opened a fishmonger next to my business.... Traditionally, social, family and voluntary associations were presumed to have no contractual intentions while commercial or business intentions were presumed to have valid and lawful contractual intentions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Companys Business Foundation and Deliberate Threats to Information Systems

In this case, two primary threats associated with the foundations of business models include Espionage or trespass and Information Extortion.... In this case, two primary threats associated with the foundations of business models include Espionage or trespass and Information Extortion.... Although companies do not have social enemies, they have financial rivals who thrive to push as many of their competitors out of business.... The business foundation of any for profit-company is comprised of information vital to the company as it includes the strategies and products the company deploys to secure competitive advantage....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

National Family Legal Foundation: To Be or not to Be

"National Family Legal foundation: To Be or Not to Be" paper analyzes the possible strategic plan needed to save the foundation; and attempts to measure the potential success of the plan developed.... Early in 1995, a successful real estate developer in Arizona by the name of Charles Dunlap was invited to join a local nonprofit organization known as the National Family Legal foundation.... Specifically, the National Family Legal foundation fought against the purveyors of child pornography....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Structural Foundation and Various Types of Foundations

The paper "Structural foundation and Various Types of Foundations" examines the structural foundation that is used to distribute the weight to be carried over a sufficient surface to prevent the subsoil from spreading.... The structural foundation avoids an unequal settlement of the structure.... Strip foundation would be suitable for continuous loads.... This is due to the fact that trees will decrease the moisture content in the soil, thus, making the clays contract and the foundation settle as the soil shrinks....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us