StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Dilemma of Government in Controlling Violent Games - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "The Dilemma of Government in Controlling Violent Games" focuses on the culture of video gaming that is increasing than ever among US teens and younger children. Currently, more children are playing video games more than they concentrate on their academics. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
The Dilemma of Government in Controlling Violent Games
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Dilemma of Government in Controlling Violent Games"

Government’s Dilemma in Controlling Violent Games The culture of video gaming is increasing than ever among the US teens and younger children. Currently, more children are plying video games more than they concentrate in their academics. The video gaming trend is resulting in increased antisocial behaviors and violence among children. For example, in 1999 two students at Columbine High School, Colorado shot and killed 134 pupils and finally killed themselves (International Debate Education Association IDEA, 2012). The students were reported to have played the video game “Doom,” and were inspired by it. This led to heated debates between two opposing sides. While advocates argued in favor of a restriction in sales of violent video games, groups of opponents led by the game developers argued against such move. They explained that correlation between the violent video games and the acts of the two students were incidental and could not be used as a justification (IDEA, 2012). While proponents argued about a link between violence and increased watching of violent games, the opponents denied any link between violent behaviors and watching of violent videos. Therefore despite the efforts the government has undertaken to restrict violent video games, the government is not able to regulate them as required due to legal implications and high demand of such games in the market. In 2011, the Supreme Court struck down a ban on selling violent games to minors. The Supreme Court found the Californian law that sought to restrict the sale of violent games to minors to be in contradiction with the free speech rights and was overturned. The judgment was overwhelming in a 7 to 2 decision and declared that the Californian statute against the sale of violent games was in serious violation of the rights protection under the First Amendment (Richey, 2011). The Californian State as the judges agreed had the right to protect children against harm by such violent games. However, the judges noted that such powers cannot be free floating to restrict all ideas to which children have possibilities of being exposed to (Richey, 2011). This was the first ruling on violent materials restriction, which was a huge setback to the California state in its bid to protect children against harm caused by such violent games. It implies that the government is not able to restrict or control such video games as required. The government has weak laws and statutes aimed at limiting such sale of violent games to minors. In 1968 the Supreme Court upheld a New York statute that sought to restrict and ban any sale of nude and obscene materials to underage children. The court found that the government indeed had the right and the power to regulate and restrict sale of such sexual materials to children without violating the protection of free speech as stated under the First Amendment (Mcmahan 2013). However, the Supreme Court on the Californian case rejected any application of the same principles by arguing speech of violence is not obscene; thus the 1968 ruling could not be applied in the ban of violent materials. This revealed a serious anomaly under the First Amendment. As one of the 2 dissenting judges, Stephen Breyer noted, there was no sense of preventing a child from accessing a nude picture of a woman, while in the same violent games children are allowed to view such women and even go further to strangle them to death virtually (Mcmahan 2013) . The law in this case is contradictory and needs a more elaborate evaluation of the First Amendment to include violent materials under the same category with obscene materials to facilitate the government to use the, law in protecting children against such violent materials. Psychiatrists and research suggest that offering blanket blame to violent games would e missing the point behind violence in children, which would hugely impact on efforts by the government to restrict such games. Kathy Royer a clinical nurse specialist at 4Kid Help Center for Child Adolescent Psychiatry, Ohio explained that research has indeed indicated that children playing violent games may lead to aggressive behavior (Mcmahan, 2013). More in depth evidence based research on the effects of violent games are rare, though a study by Ohio State University indicated that continued playing of violent games could actually make people more aggressive with time, though no research has been able to link such violent games to violent and criminal trends among the youth (Mcmahan, 2013). The lack of a clear line between the two was observed as President Barack Obama requested a $ 10milion budget to allow for Centers for Diseases Control an Prevention, and other related agencies is to carry out detailed research on causes of gun violence, particularly finding a relation between the increasing gun violence trends among the youth and violent video games (Macmahan, 2013). This move suggested the government is still not convinced on relation between violent games and increased juvenile violence, which implies it cannot restrict such violence games yet. However, there are strong feelings that the government can indeed control and restrict the sale of violent games. The government through its legal and administrative structures has succeeded significantly in restricting the sale of alcohol and obscene materials to children. This implies that the government has the mechanisms administratively and legally to effect bans that would not contravene the First Amendment, but that would restrict such violent games. This wedel include labeling such games and restricting them to adults only. This will however require legal mechanisms to facilitate such laws sand statutes. Moreover, the government has the right and obligation to protect the minority by ensuring healthy development and controlling anything that would affect such development. Evidence based research as indicated has shown that violence games increase the aggression in children, which may be a precursor to violence though not directly correlated. Such research would be enough indication for the government to act in restricting the sale of violent games to children due to already indemnified harm. Parents defaulting on their obligations to look after children and offer their children solid and moral up bringing have been explained as one major contributor in children’s antisocial behaviors such as increased violence (IDEA, 2012). The government through its local authorities can involve parents in restricting children’s’ access to such materials. This would include the government carrying out massive sensitization campaigns in all areas where parents and policy holders are involved in discussion on the effects of violent games in children. Parents would then be required to play their roles and duties. They have the largest responsibilities in ensuring their children do not access materials that pervade their judgment such as the violent materials. Increased public sensitization would have parents and other community members take charge of educating their children against the dangers of such games and ensuring children are more involved in constructive and positive recreation activities such as physical games. Parents in most cases are the ones who buy such games for children. When the community is aware of the benefits that children and the family as a whole would derive from physical gaming compared to passive gaming, it would be more effective in putting in place mechanisms to ensure children have enough time for physical games within the community by providing the necessary infrastructure. Though there are proved serious effects of increasing violence video gaming among children, the government is not able to completely restrict and ban the sale of the video games to children due to legal implications. The Supreme Court on a Californian statute that sought to restrict such materials made a ruling that such restriction would be illegal and against the First Amendment. However, the government having the right and obligation to protect children may involve other methods that would be legal and effective. Such would include passing laws against such sale of violent materials, involving the community and parents in more proactive ways, or even classifying such materials in the same class with obscene materials , which are restricted by law against sale to children,. Therefore, unless the government involves such methods, it is not able to restrict or ban the sale of violence games to children. Work Cited International Debate Education Association, This house would restrict violent video games, IDEA, 2012 http://idebate.org/debatabase/debates/house-would-restrict-violent-video-games (Accessed 15th April, 2013) Mcmahan Kim Do violent video games lead to real violence? The Columbian , March 1, 2013, http://www.columbian.com/news/2013/mar/01/do-violent-video-gameslead-to-real-violence/(Accessed 15th April, 2013) Richey Warren, Supreme Court strikes down ban on selling violent video games to minors, the Christian Science Monitor, June 27, 2011http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2011/0627/Supreme-Court-strikes-down-ban-on-selling-violent-video-games-to-minors (Accessed 15th April, 2013) Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“As a policy matter, should the government be able to restrict the sale Essay”, n.d.)
As a policy matter, should the government be able to restrict the sale Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1472713-as-a-policy-matter-should-the-government-be-able
(As a Policy Matter, Should the Government Be Able to Restrict the Sale Essay)
As a Policy Matter, Should the Government Be Able to Restrict the Sale Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1472713-as-a-policy-matter-should-the-government-be-able.
“As a Policy Matter, Should the Government Be Able to Restrict the Sale Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1472713-as-a-policy-matter-should-the-government-be-able.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Dilemma of Government in Controlling Violent Games

Gun control

To manage with this essay presents initial laws of gun control; a political dilemma of gun control; California statehouse incident and the second amendment; president Obama's stand on the issue: a shock for the advocates.... He grafted out a figure that showed the average number of violent crimes before the adoption of law and what was seen was a drastic rise in the level of crime after the implementation of strong gun control laws.... The government has drafted out several laws to suppress guns but the question Do gun- control laws work cannot be answered....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Corruption in Police Services

It is a dilemma that has and will prolong to influence everyone, whether one is a civilian or law enforcement officials.... This paper will begin with the statement that police corruption is a difficult observable fact, which does not willingly offer to easy analysis.... ... ... ...
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Crime and Criminal Justice

36)Three different aspects can examine the dilemma of female crime; first, all the specific offenses which are historically associated with female offenders.... The essay "Crime and Criminal Justice" discusses violent crimes, infanticide, assault, and family violence.... (Chesney, 1970) Women could be violent.... rostitution, which is considered to be a common societal dilemma today, was not, always, a criminal offense in England....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Spirit of 1968 Politicised Everyday Life

People were simply out there in the streets, in From the streets of First World cities like Memphis, London and Paris to Communist ones like Belgrade and Warsaw, protests, many of them violent, marked the year that was 1968.... The US was struggling with a war that it had trouble controlling and winning, the former USSR.... Students became a power to be reckoned with, rattling and changing government policies and perspectives.... The Vietnam War that the US government was waging had previously already earned mounting protests at home and overseas because Americans felt it was not their war to fight and people abroad...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Key Features of a Sports Development Strategy

ports management is the set of skills relating to planning organizing, Leading, controlling, and budgeting for an organization whose main responsibility is to cater the services in the sports.... This paper ''Key Features of a Sports Development Strategy'' tells us that the dictionary defines it as the bustle of an individual or group for the trail of exercise or recreation which could involve bodily capabilities and it could also take the form of a competition game which could be either hockey badminton....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Literature Analysis

The understanding of human development is one of the most debated aspects of modern scholarship and this is mainly because of the differences related to the manner through which human beings have been able to attain their status.... In “Aesthetics and Anaesthetics”, Susan.... ... ... orssattempts to show the destructive manner through which human beings have developed and this to such an extent that they are often willing to become spectators in their own destruction (Buck-Morss 30)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Is Multimedia Too Cool For School

This paper acknowledges that multimedia technology may benefit children in their education and development, however, it ascribes to a more human-centered method of education.... It is more interested in the development of upright people with integrity, strong character and concern for all of humanity ....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Male Perceptions of Domestic Violence and Its Relationships with Cultural Background

In the paper "Male Perceptions of Domestic Violence and Its Relationships with Cultural Background", the three groups of participants were all in agreement in their definition of domestic violence as a form of violent behavior occurring within a household commonly between husbands and wives....
11 Pages (2750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us