StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Employment- at-will Doctrine and Employee Discrimination - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author examines the employment-at-will doctrine, the grounds of employee discrimination. The author also examines discrimination in cases of recruitment and at the time of advertising job vacancies and analyzes the case EEOC v. Pacific Press Publ’g.   …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Employment- at-will Doctrine and Employee Discrimination
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Employment- at-will Doctrine and Employee Discrimination"

41. The employment-at-will doctrine allows that when an employee does not have a written employment contract and the term of employment duration is infinite, the employer can terminate the employee for reasonable cause, wrongful cause, without any cause at all. Thus, the employment-at-will doctrine reflected the belief that people should be free to enter into employment contracts of a specified duration, but that no obligations attached to either employer or employee if a person was hired without such a contract.

Because employees were able to resign from positions they no longer cared to occupy, employers also were permitted to discharge employees at their own will. The Industrial Revolution planted the seeds for the erosion of the employment-at-will doctrine. When employees began forming unions, the collective bargaining agreements were formed and the unions had to negotiate with employers frequently because the agreement had provisions in them that required just cause for adverse employment actions, as well as procedures for arbitrating employee grievances.

The 1960s marked the beginning of Federal legislative protections (including Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act) from wrongful discharge based on race, religion, sex, age, and national origin. These protections reflected the changing view of the relationship between employer and employee. Rather than seeing the relationship as being on equal footing, courts and legislatures slowly began to recognize that employers frequently had economic advantages when negotiating with potential or current employees.  42. An employer may be held guilty of breach of statutory requirements if they indulge in discriminating employees on the grounds of: sex or marital status gender reassignment race religion or belief sexual orientation trade union membership part-time work fixed-term work disability Employers should use gender-neutral terms when advertising for staff.

For example, adverts for a postman, waitress, salesgirl, which use a job description with a sexual implication, are likely to violate the Sex Discrimination Act. Occasionally, however, an employer may be able to lawfully discriminate on grounds of sex or race, for example, a department store could legitimately advertise for male applicants to play Father Christmas. When interviewing applicants for a job, an ideal approach for an employer should be to ask the same questions from each of the applicants.

On the basis of above facts, it is quite clear that Muhammad pursues a claim for discrimination against Joes Bakery since the discrimination has been made on the grounds of racial discrimination by refusing him the job right away which also calls for a prima facie case. 43. The basic difference between a bona fide occupational qualification and a legitimate business necessity is essentially the quantum or degree of necessity. Proving a bona fide occupational qualification requires to prove that the business cannot exist without discrimination.

Proving a legitimate business necessity requires to prove that the business would be seriously impacted with a different policy. The only defense to a facially discriminatory policy is a bona fide occupational qualification. The defense to a facially neutral policy is to prove a legitimate business necessity. If the employer can prove that the policy reflects a legitimate business necessity, they can overcome the presumption of discrimination. 44. Yes, they will have a reason for concern with respect to racial discrimination as the plaintiff has a valid reason to sue them on the grounds of racial discrimination.

This is maintainable under Title VII of the Civil rights Act, 1964 which contains a provision relating to prohibition of discrimination by covered employers on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin. They have discriminated him by not suggesting him to improve his performance on the basis of his color which is one of the prohibitions contained under the aforesaid Act. 45. Refer case EEOC v. Pacific Press Publ’g. Ass’n, 676 F.2d 1272, 1276; EEOC Notice,N-915, September 23, 1987.

In some cases, an employer may claim that a discharge has a valid discriminatory reason based on religion under the Title VII exemption, while the employee claims the discharge is based on some other Title VII prohibition and therefore improper. For example, in several cases, employees of religious organizations, particularly private religious schools, are discharged after becoming pregnant. The employer claims that the termination was based on a violation of an organization policy against extra-marital sex, stemming from the religion’s teachings.

The employee claims that the action is unlawful sex discrimination based on her pregnancy. If the court determines that the employer’s action was taken in response to the resulting pregnancy, rather than because of a violation of the faith-based policy, the organization may be held in violation of Title VII’s prohibition on sex discrimination. If the court determines the discharge was based on religious teachings, the organization can claim Title VII exemption. In this case, also the reasoning of the aforesaid case would apply and the action would be maintainable only if the termination was on the grounds of the extra-marital affair which resulted into pregnancy without violating the faith-based policy, the religious bookstore may be held in violation of Title VII’s prohibition against sex discrimination.

However, if the discharge was based on religious teachings, the organization can claim the Title VII exemption.  

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Questions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 999 words, n.d.)
Questions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 999 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1549236-questions
(Questions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 999 Words)
Questions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 999 Words. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1549236-questions.
“Questions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 999 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1549236-questions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Employment- at-will Doctrine and Employee Discrimination

Employment-At-Will Doctrine

She also says she took a business law class in undergrad that taught her “everything she needs to know about exceptions to the employment-at-will doctrine and wrongful discharge in violation of public policy”.... There are only few categories in the exemptions of the employment of will that can be invoked which are discrimination, public policy exemptions, implied contractual relationship and Sabarnes Oxley Act (Radin and Werhane, 2003).... Firing her might be construed as a discrimination against her religion and an exemption for “employment at will” (Sennel, 2008)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Employment-At-Will Doctrine

The Employment-at-will doctrine Name: Institution: The employment at will doctrine implies that an employer is free to dismiss an employee for any legal reason without giving him or her notice.... Employment-at-will doctrine also allows the employer to change the terms of the employment contract without incurring any legal liability.... According to the employment-at-will doctrine, the employer can just fire the employee without notice and thus, firing John without notifying him will not bring any legal liability on the company....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Employment-At-Will Doctrine

Employment-at-will doctrine Grade Course (17th, Oct.... 2013) Employment-at-will doctrine Summary of the employment-at-will doctrine The doctrine of Employment-At-Will is a principle guiding the employment relationships between the employee and the employer, which provides that an employer has the right to terminate the contract of his/her employees for any reason (Stone, 2007).... hellip; The Employment-at-will doctrine is a controversial one, since it allows an employer to dismiss employees at will, even without establishing a just cause for termination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Religious-Discrimination Claims on the Rise

College Data Increase in Religious discrimination Cases Litigation cases involving religious discrimination across US organizations have increased in the past 15 years.... This explains the doubling of religious discrimination cases in the last 15 years, as reported by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.... However, considering that most religious discrimination cases are brought by immigrants, the reported cases are way below other discriminations based on age and sex....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Employment law

Promissory Estoppel is an exception to the employment-at-will doctrine if the employee can show that he/she relied on the employer's promise to his/her detriment.... An employer can successfully defend a charge of disparate treatment discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act offering a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for the action taken regarding the charging party.... The following defenses are available to employers in discrimination claims:Answer: All the choices are collect 10....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Employment-At-Will Doctrine

Public policy exception to the employment-at-will doctrine protects employees against employment actions that contravene public interest.... This is the second major exception to the employment-at-will doctrine.... At-will means that an employer is entitled to terminate an employee at any time, for any reason, or for no reason without incurring any legal consequences.... It is, therefore, possible to legally fire an employee....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Limits of Employment-At-Will Doctrine

From the paper "Limits of Employment-at-will doctrine" it is clear that the employment at will doctrine has its own limits.... A discharged employee who claims he partied have contractually agreed to the rights of the employers to terminate has the liability to prove the written representation on that note (New York joins the states overturning the employment-at-will doctrine: Employee handbooks are the key, 1983).... Terminations that are initiated by employers must not be connected to discrimination or violation of certain state or federal laws....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Employment-At-Will Doctrine

This paper presents a summary of the employment-at-will doctrine.... Additionally, the employment-at-will doctrine shall not apply is the agreement and contract offers that a worker cannot be dismissed unless the employer has a good cause.... nbsp;Terminations that are initiated by employers must not be connected to discrimination or violation of the state or federal laws.... hellip; In situations of at-will, either the employee or the employer terminates the relationship in the employment, without or with cause, without or with a warning, unless the agreement is present with express conditions and terms that cover the termination....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us