StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Slavery and Wage Labor - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Slavery and Wage Labor" discusses that generally, slavery and wage labor were less the same due to the conditions of the workers. Where human rights were not put into consideration in both cases, making it an evil act to be avoided at all cost. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Slavery and Wage Labor
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Slavery and Wage Labor"

This essay compares and contrasts wage labor with slavery during the colonial period in relation to the formation and control of labor forces, gendered experiences, resistance movements, and attempts to create a just society. Slavery and wage labor had negative impacts on individuals well being in America during the colonial period and early 19th century.

Formation and control of labor forces

During the colonial period, labor forces were formed and controlled in different ways. Slavery and wage labor were the major forms of labor that were offered during this period. Slavery was based mainly on social stratification (Dizzo95 2:35-5:15). Classes existed in the American society; there was a class of bourgeoisies and proletariats. Proletariats came from low social class therefore they were forced to work on the plantations of the rich. This chain of poverty was maintained where children of the poor were automatically subjected to slavery. Another form of acquiring slaves was through the sentencing of debtors. Any individual who was not in a position of settling debts was automatically made a slave. His freedom would only be granted upon settling the debt. Unlike slave labor wage labor was voluntarily offered by the laborers. Their need for sustaining themselves forced them to look for jobs that could offer them a living. Wage laborers had all the freedom of choosing where to work but did not have a choice to decide the number of payments to be offered (Servant2All 1:00-3:55).

It can be noted that slave labor and wage labor was acquired from people of low social class. Due to a lack of means to sustain their families wage laborers were forced to work for the bourgeoisie. Both labor forces were controlled by certain laws that were put in place by the masters. Any individual that went against these laws faced harsh punishment. Tor instance in slave labor, any laborer going against master’s laws was thoroughly beaten and also denied basic rights. On the other hand wage laborer going against laws lost his or her job. In both wage labor and slave, labor workers were offered identity cards that were useful in identifying what master they worked for (Servant2All 4:00- 5:19).      

During this period of slavery in America, roles were assigned on gender lines in addition to that they were segregated. Women were mostly confined in the southern parts of America while men were in the northern parts. Wage labor, on the other hand, the laborers had the freedom of working together regardless of gender. The main aim was to provide for their family's upkeep. The laborers in wage labor had all the freedom in choosing the master they were to work for. Slaves did not have this freedom of choice, they were not in a position to choose what master they were to work for, therefore endured all the working conditions (JNoire 0:45-1: 45)

 In both slavery and wage labor roles were assigned on a gender basis. Women performed domestic chores for their masters like cooking and washing, while men focused on tasking jobs like plowing. The working conditions of both genders were bad for they were all subjected to hard tasks, and went for long hours without resting. As much as laborers in wage labor were offered wages, they could not be able to sustain their families (JNoire 2:13-5:00).

Resistance movements

The issue of slavery and wage labor was perceived differently by people all over the world. There are those that support slavery while others greatly oppose slavery. Among the individuals who opposed slavery were the missionaries, humanitarians and philanthropists. Missionaries hold on the view that every individual is equal before God, and therefore deserves to be treated well. These forces had an agenda of creating a just society, where everybody is free from prejudice. Humanitarians oppose the issue of people owning others and hold that people are not to be forced to work for others, but rather should work at their own will. There was the emergence of civil wars that saw two groups of people, the wage-labor opponents and abolitionists.  Abolitionists argued that slavery was worse than wage labor; this was due to the fact that wage laborers had all the freedom to choose where to work while the slaves did not (Trophones 1:25-8:39)

The main agenda of this civil war was to promote freedom for workers. They argued that people should be allowed to move freely and not be put into captivity due to their economic status. Laborers have a right to a good salary, and therefore people should work in a friendly environment. By this, no individual should be given less than he deserves. Labor organizations were also formed in America to view laborers grievances. These organizations mainly focused on the interests of the laborers, their working conditions and general wellbeing. Wage laborer according to humanitarians should be allowed to bargain on what payment is to be offered to them (Honesty 3:30-10:50)

Different forces in America saw a stop to this and encouraged a just society. Societies where the poor are not oppressed by the rich but rather practice fairness.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparisons and contrasts wage labor with slavery during the colonial Essay”, n.d.)
Comparisons and contrasts wage labor with slavery during the colonial Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1433185-comparisons-and-contrasts-wage-labor-with-slavery
(Comparisons and Contrasts Wage Labor With Slavery During the Colonial Essay)
Comparisons and Contrasts Wage Labor With Slavery During the Colonial Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1433185-comparisons-and-contrasts-wage-labor-with-slavery.
“Comparisons and Contrasts Wage Labor With Slavery During the Colonial Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1433185-comparisons-and-contrasts-wage-labor-with-slavery.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Slavery and Wage Labor

Prison is primarily a mechanism for the regulation of labour

Critics to this practice however point out that prison seems to have become a mechanism for controlling and regulating labour, and that in the process, the system has circumvented fair labour practices, including unionization and minimum wage requirements.... Prison is primarily a mechanism for the regulation of labour ...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Slavery and Religion

slavery and Religion.... Thus, the relationship between slavery and religion has been of major concern.... Slavery refers to the concept where people were bought and sold, and subjected to forced labor.... Slavery refers to the concept where people were bought and sold, and subjected to forced labor.... slavery is one of the major contentious issues that marred the history of humanity.... Conversely, the two aspects, religion and slavery were a salient feature in most societies....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

LEGAL IMPLICATIONS IN HUMAN RESOURCES CASE ASSIGNMENT 1 EMPLOYMENT LAW

Submitted by: XXXXXXX Student Number: XXXXXXX Subject: XXXXXX Subject Code: XXXXXX XXXXX XX – XX – 2011 University of XXXXXXXX Legal Implications In Human Resources Case Assignment To, Senior Management Subject: HR Development Plan: Recent Changes in the Employment and labor Law The main aim of this report is to develop a plan for the human resources department of the company.... It is the responsibility of the company to ensure that all human resources are managed and work in sync with the labor laws and employment laws....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Adam Smith's (positive economic) view of slavery

f the western European succession argued in support of the dominance of wage labor, the overturn seemed to have been the case transversely the ocean.... To present his thoughts he did not explicitly cite Franklin's essay, but he obviously had it in mind when he asserted that slave labor was more costly than free labor "even at Boston, New York, and Philadelphia where the wages of common labor are so high.... To present his thoughts he did not explicitly cite Franklin's essay, which had achieved considerable fame by the publication date of the Wealth of Nations, but he obviously had it in mind when he asserted that slave labor was more costly than free labor "even at Boston, New York, and Philadelphia where the wages of common labor are so high....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Commercial of Child Labour

the more households offer child labor), the less productive and remunerated this labor will tend to be.... the more uses for child labor are generated), the more productive and remunerated it will be.... arious studies point to several factors responsible for child labor.... The economic factor in the problem seems to take the most responsibility as statistics and literature on the subject have shown - child labor is prevalent in low-income countries....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A policy review: impact on labor

prediction of shortage of labor makes Canada's labor policy to emphasize on foreign recruitment and to neutralize foreign education so that the new immigrants or residents are able to work in Canada in the same field. ... avi Pendakur, in his Immigrations and the labor Force: icy, Regulation and Impact, says, “Lack of recognition of foreign-based skills and education is a major issue, with a subsequent waste of human resources and loss to the Canadian economy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Transnational Labor Slavery and Revolt

The "Transnational Labor slavery and Revolt" paper analyzes the movement associated with transnational labor slavery and revolt in different parts of the world during various period, what are the main reasons behind this revolt, how labors across the globe fight against different irregularities.... The increasing trans-nationalization of production and formalization of labor relations has undermined the traditional power resources of national labor movements....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Solution and Advantages of the Fair Labor Law

This paper "Solution and Advantages of the Fair labor Law" focuses on the fact that outsourcing labour to foreign countries where the employees have no labour unions or strict labour laws has been taking place since the 1880s and is still in practice.... .... ... ... The US-based multinational corporations have engaged in unethical practices after employing labours at cheap employment rates and taking no liability over the interest of the labours outsourced from foreign countries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us