StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Paramedic Law and Ethics - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The goal of this review "Paramedic Law and Ethics" is to present several articles about paramedic law. The Code of Conduct specifies about managing conflicts of interests. The code emphasizes that duties must be performed fairly and must not be driven by personal gain…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Paramedic Law and Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Paramedic Law and Ethics"

Running head: Paramedic Law and Ethics Paramedic Law and Ethics (school) Paramedic Law and Ethics Reading Report Berglund, C. (2007) Ethics for Healthcare (3rd edition). New York: Oxford University Press In the first chapter of Berglund’s book, she discusses ethics in healthcare and the element of caring which is already innate in the health care professional’s initial expedition into a career in healthcare. The author pointed out that the health care practice is not just about the technical application of skills, but it is also about the care displayed by the health professional to the patients (Berglund, 2007). Ethics essentially goes beyond the rules set forth by a regulating body or organization; instead, it starts with a person’s “internal conviction to behave…” (Kerridge, Lowe & McPhee, 2009, p. 2). In the course of a health professional’s learning, his ethical and moral decision-making processes are also enhanced and enriched. Based on the principles of beneficence, autonomy, non-malfeasance, and justice, ethics guides health care professionals in their practice. It also provides solutions to issues, dilemmas or situations which require choices between “what seem to be two equally desirable alternatives that may arise in health care settings” (Sneesby, 2008, p. 21). The principles of ethics, as mentioned above, are principles which help resolve ethical dilemmas. Berglund (2007) also emphasizes the importance of individual reflection for each professional; a professional in this case is skilled and trained in the proper techniques in order to meet the expectation of expertise in the service to society. The professional code of ethics which are essential to the medical, nursing, and paramedic practice are very much based on the four basic ethical principles. In one way or another, they are covered under beneficence, in terms of the overall “good” that one’s actions can bring; they are covered under justice, in terms of giving a patient and a person his due; under non-malfeasance, in terms of not doing any harm to the patient; and finally under the principle of autonomy, in terms of respecting a person’s right to self-determination (Berglund, 2007). In effect, for doubts which practitioners feel in their practice, mastering these four basic principles may secure balance in the ethical healthcare practice. Kant’s deontological theory also discusses about morality and ethics. According to Kant, freedom is needed in order to allow individuals to develop their own opinions and moral laws (Berglund, 2007). In order to uphold such theory, one must respect himself and others – to benefit others and not to harm them. Consequently, an individual has the autonomy to make his own judgment while also respecting other people’s right to be respected (Berglund, 2007). In this case, the principles of justice and beneficence must be prioritized over and above individual interests. Beauchamp’s theory on ethics is largely based on the above utilitarian ideas laid out by John Stuart Mills and Immanuel Kant. For Childress however, his views are more deontological. In applying this to the practice, a utilitarian would focus more on the result of the behaviour for the most number of people; he would also aim for the happiness of the majority (Berglund, 2007). On the other hand, the deontologist assesses the fundamental rule which should be applied in all scenarios in order to ensure ethical practices (Berglund, 2007). These different theories sometimes apply to patients depending on their circumstances. How each situation is judged is still largely based on the principles of ethics. Reading Report 2: Berglund, C. (2007) Ethics for Healthcare (3rd edition). New York: Oxford University Press In the second chapter of Berglund’s ‘Ethics for Healthcare,’ she discusses about the principle of justice and its application in the healthcare practice. The distribution of resources is one of the crucial issues in the application of the justice principle. For health care providers, the fair distribution of claims is often dependent on the appropriate application of this principle (Berglund, 2007). In many instances, the principle of justice has not always been given much importance, especially when financial considerations have been taken into account. For most people, the point of having a career and of working is to earn money; and when this goal comes into conflict with the concept of justice, the professional is prompted to make a choice between social justice and financial gain (Wuthnow, 1998). In the unequal distribution of resources, a health care professional, as pointed out by Berglund (2007), must try to ‘do good’ at all times. ‘Doing good,’ is the very essence of caring and in ‘doing good,’ the health care professional must apply the principle of beneficence. As a result, the different principles of ethics coordinate with each other. In instances when these different principles come in conflict with each other, the least selfish principle must be chosen by the practitioner. In instances where conflict between patient autonomy and beneficence is seen, beneficence seems to be more important to uphold (Berglund, 2007). Where justice itself conflicts with other people’s entitlement to justice, the concept of comparative need has to be considered (Berglund, 2007). This practice often creates the most controversy for different patients who feel like their need should be given more priority than others. For the practitioner, the burden of considering who among the patients should be prioritized and making such crucial decisions may not always yield the desired outcome (Berglund, 2007). Wuthnow (1993, p. 251). says it best when he points out that justice “focuses less on the happy merging and blending of two individuals, and more on each jealously standing up for the dignity and autonomy of the other”. In any case, regardless of its potentially unpopular effects, hard decisions in relation to justice have to be made, if not for the benefit of all, then for the benefit of those who need it the most. Reading Report 3: Steer, B. (2007) Paramedics, consent and refusal – are we competent? Journal of Primary Emergency Health Care, volume 5, number 1 Paramedics face a major dilemma while caring for their patients. They are in a highly pressured and tense situation with a possibly unconscious or in-pain patient and with relatives who may be too distraught to make the right decisions for their loved ones. The issue of consent is especially crucial and controversial in these cases. More often than not, in the practice, paramedics encounter patients who would refuse care (Steer, 2007). When time is of the essence, the burden of making the right decision for the patient is on the paramedic. However, the paramedic must also consider the fact that the patient indeed has the right to refuse treatment. Even as the purpose of the paramedic is in accordance with his duty to render care to the patient, the ethics of the paramedic practice still dictates that a mentally fit patient is free to make his decision about his care (Steer, 2007). When in doubt, it is also important for paramedics to note that making decisions that are ethically appropriate can sometimes be passed on to the ER doctors and personnel. As medical professionals responding via Ambulance Services, it is still possible to attend to the patient and not violate his autonomy (Steer, 2007). Transporting the patient to the hospital with the patient’s consent may be as far as the ethical coverage may go. The ER doctors can then consult with the patient and try to convince the latter that he needs medical attention (Steer, 2007). In considering the ethical rules, although administering medical care to the patient may indeed be for his benefit and may be in accordance with the principle of justice, paramedics are not in the right position to violate the patient’s autonomy (Steer, 2007). Theirs is a duty of rendering ambulance services – not to force it on patients. Even as patients refuse treatment, it is still possible for ambulance services to assess the patient’s decision-making ability. Through this assessment, a more medical evaluation of the patient’s mental capacity can be used to justify the delivery of care. For coherent and mentally sound patients, their right to autonomy cannot be violated – even if it is justified and beneficial to them. However, for mentally unsound patients, it would be for their benefit and it would be justified to overlook their right to refuse medical attention. In essence, therefore, the delivery of medical care depends largely on sound judgment on the part of the paramedic and on the reliable application of the different ethical principles. Reflective Analysis: Ambulance Services of New South Wales Code of Conduct (Managing Conflicts of Interests In the Code of Conduct, particularly Part 1.2.0, the code specifies about managing conflicts of interests. The code emphasizes that duties must be performed fairly and must not be driven by personal gain (Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct, 2007). Fairness here is very much related to the principle of justice. The principle of justice, as discussed by Beauchamp & Childress (as cited by Masters, 2005) is primarily about distributive justice in the management of scarce resources. In this case, where resources are few, duties must be performed fairly and must rise above self-interest and personal gain. Managing conflicts of interests is also related to the principle of beneficence. The principle of beneficence highlights a person’s duty to do good by others and to maintain the balance between benefits and harms (Daniels, 2004). Once again, by doing good, one’s personal interest and gain cannot be allowed to dominate one’s life. Moreover, situations which give rise to conflicts of interest should also be avoided by the health care practitioner. The principle of non-malfeasance is very much relevant and related to the management of conflicts. Managing conflicts speaks about being unselfish and about setting aside personal gain. Non-malfeasance speaks about avoiding harm or doing no harm to one’s patient (Monagle & Thomasma, 2004). In doing no harm to a patient, the management of conflicts must, at all times, be for the benefit and of the patient. In doing no harm, actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest must always be reported to immediate supervisors. The principle of non-malfeasance protects the client from not only current and obvious harm, but also from potential harm (Monagle & Thomasma, 2004). By reporting potential areas of conflict to supervisors, these conflicts can be prevented or resolved immediately as they arise in the healthcare process (Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct, 2007). The code also points out that in case there is a real or potential conflict of interest with another staff member, then such conflict must be reported immediately to the supervisor. In this case, conflicts have to be prevented as much as possible because in the end, the actions and the quality of care of staff members may be affected or compromised by the conflict. Consequently, ‘harm’ may be suffered by the patient as a result of compromised quality of healthcare services (Daniels, 2004). The code also presents details about discrimination, harassment, bullying, and violence (Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct, 2007). The code emphasizes that paramedics should not harass, discriminate, or bully other staff, patients, or members of the public, nor should they encourage staff to harass other people (Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct, 2007). In the basic ethical principle of non-malfeasance, the act of ‘doing no harm,’ supports this portion of the code. Non-malfeasance is about not causing a patient harm and avoiding the risk of harming one’s patient (Heppner, Wampold, & Kivligan, 2007). On further assessing the provisions in relation to harassment and bullying, the beneficence principle also comes out as a supporting principle. Beneficence, as previously mentioned, is about doing good for others and basing one’s actions on what would benefit one’s patient. In this case, harassment and bullying does not benefit one’s patient and the other staff members. It can cause the patient to mistrust the paramedic and the healthcare professionals. It can also cause trauma and can make the patient’s condition worse. In the end, no good or benefit is brought to the patient at all. The principle of justice can also be used to support the code’s prohibition on bullying, harassment, and violence. Justice is about giving people their due (Elkin, 1999). Each person – patients, staff members, and the general public – deserves to be treated with respect, honesty, and care. Bullying and harassing people is not part of justifiable and acceptable behaviour towards patients and the general public; hence is unjustifiable behaviour. Works Cited Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct (2007) Barnes, A. & American Law Institute-American Bar Association Committee on Continuing Profession. (2001) Health care law: desk reference. California: ALI-ABA Berglund, C. (2007) Ethics for Health Care (3rd edition). New York: Oxford University Press. Daniels, R. (2004) Nursing fundamentals: caring & clinical decision making. California: Cengage Learning Elkin, D. (1999) Introduction to clinical psychiatry. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing Heppner, P., Wampold, B. & Kivligan, D. (2007) Research design in counseling. California: Cengage Learning Kerridge I., Lowe, M., Stewart, C.,(2009) Ethics and law for the health professions. New York: The Federation Press Masters, K. (2005) Role development in professional nursing practice. Pennsylvania: Jones & Bartlett Pennsylvania Monagle, J. & Thomasma, D. (2004) Health Care Ethics: Critical Issues for the 21st Century. Pennsylvania: Jones & Bartlett Sneesby, L. (2008) An Ethical Dilemma: Mine, Yours, or Ours? HNE Handover for Nurses and Midwives. Retrieved 30 August 2010 from http://weblearn.newcastle.edu.au/Resources/Schools/Nursing%20and%20Midwifery/HNE%20Handover/Handover-11-08.pdf#page=23 Steer, B. (2007) Paramedics, consent and refusal – are we competent? Journal of Primary Emergency Health Care, volume 5, number 1 Wuthnow, R. (1998). Poor Richards principle: Recovering the American dream through the moral dimension of work, business, and money. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. Wuthnow, R. (1993). Acts of compassion: Caring for others and helping ourselves. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Paramedic Law and Ethics Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
Paramedic Law and Ethics Literature review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740708-paramedic-law-and-ethics
(Paramedic Law and Ethics Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Paramedic Law and Ethics Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740708-paramedic-law-and-ethics.
“Paramedic Law and Ethics Literature Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740708-paramedic-law-and-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Paramedic Law and Ethics

Ethics around Business Law

There are sixteen different commercial laws out of which corporate law, employment law, labor law and tax law are the most important laws.... Business law must be generally governed under the law and the justice should be equally distributed.... Since business law does not come under the criminal law and any deviation is considered under the civil law and hence these deviations are not taken seriously.... Hence ethics should be the primary authority governing the business law....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethics as Unwritten Rules for Society

Some unethical behavior may amount to a crime in some areas or may be a subject of legal action but by and large, ethics goes beyond the contemplation of the law… Thus, author Marianne Jennings state that although line cutters, or people who squeeze themselves to the front of queues bypassing others who have waited in lines, may not be liable legally but they nevertheless, breached ethical conduct (2008 1-4).... In business, hics are important too, and in recent years the close connection between ethics and the law have began to surface with cases like the Enron, a company that was financially at the top of the corporate world but whose financial records and documents were in fact manipulated and fabricated to make it appear that it was making huge profits when it fact, it was swimming in debt....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Business Law and Ethics

rdquo;  Business Law/ ethics ethics is twofold; to start with, it refers to the well founded benchmarks or standards of good or bad, right or wrong which prescribes what people ought to do.... Secondly, ethics is the timely and systematic development of an individual's ethical standard.... Over time, ethics do not change as one develops in life or as one move from one region to another.... Foundations of personal ethics are built when a parent tells the child that it is wrong to steal and the behavior of the parent has a strong impact alike....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Applied paramedic practice

Also, I want to be able to identify ECG and all of the paramedic drugs.... The applied paramedic practice topic is a comprehensive approach to everything that we have learned over the last three years.... One of my strengths is that I have almost been able to use a physical examination to determine the correct diagnosis of chest pain....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Research Methods & Analysis in Psychology

They tested the diastolic blood pressure, measured in millimetres of mercury (mmhg), of a group of people who suffered from hypertension before they took part in the therapy and again… The table below shows the blood pressures of the patients. After thorough screening of the data we realized that it met the requirements of independent t-test which was used to compare the means of the blood pressure levels of patients before treatment and after Researchers compared two groups of 15 children on the time taken, in weeks, to learn how to ride a bicycle....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Social Media Trends

Within health care, this reaches an unprecedented level since people depend Blogs The role of ethics, law and social responsibility within any society of the world is of immense significance.... From a public relations perspective, the same takes on a definitive role which cannot be denied under any situation or circumstance whatsoever....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

The community paramedic

A structured form or tool of communication THE COMMUNITY paramedic Identify some communication strategies or tools that can assist in communication between the health careteam and the patient.... How could a community paramedic improve or strengthen the care coordination of a person with a chronic disease in the community.... n order to improve the care coordination, there should be a close working relationship between the community paramedic and the patients and a well as their family members....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Paramedic Laws and Ethics

In the paper “Paramedic Laws and ethics” the author discusses the challenges to autonomy and informed decision-making which is often seen among young, old, or incapacitated patients.... The principles of ethics, especially on autonomy and beneficence are considered on a case to case basis at this point – after fully considering the merits of each case, from the patient's level of understanding, maturity, and level of consciousness to a patient's understanding of his medical condition (Kerridge, Lowe & McPhee, 2005)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us