StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Although aesthetics is a major part of literature, it is not all that there is to literature. When one reads a literary piece, one also gets a chance to have a glimpse into what happened at a time in history, particularly the time the literary piece was composed. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Achilles in Homers Iliad or Socrates in Platos Apology
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology"

of Lecturer 8th of May, Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology Although aesthetics is a major part of literature, it is not all that there is to literature. When one reads a literary piece, one also gets a chance to have a glimpse into what happened at a time in history, particularly the time the literary piece was composed. In essence, Homer's Iliad or Plato's Apology are literary works which reveal to the contemporary reader some of things that happened during the classic age.

This is particularly so as this texts have realism strongly embedded in them. By writing about people that existed in their age, the authors of these two works – Homer and Plato respectively – reveal that they know the significance and markers of the age during which they lived. One of the most important keys to making headway in life is in knowing oneself. Achilles in Homer's Iliad and Socrates in Plato's Apology have one feature in common: they knew themselves. Socrates knew who he was, and Achilles also understood who he was.

Their characters show that once one knows oneself, the other aspects of life are a minority. When one understands oneself, other matters of the world would be minor. The manner in which each of the characters attains self-knowledge varies. While Socrates’ method puts himself in the position of one that knows nothing, Achilles is in a position that places him at great advantage as a warrior. While in the case of Socrates, ignorance is important to the attainment of knowledge; in the case of Achilles, betrayal and breaching of protocol are important to the attainment of self-knowledge.

One must however note that the attainment of self-knowledge by each of them appears to be useful for different reasons. While Socrates’ attainment of self knowledge seems to be more to his personal advantage, Achilles’ attainment of knowledge is obviously not for his personal good alone but for the good of all. Knowing oneself seems to mean that there is a point one gets where all that counts is one’s own conviction. This can be seen in the lives of the two characters—Socrates and Achilles.

Probably because of his association with some enemies of the state, Socrates is picked up and falsely accused. He is found guilty and sentenced to death. That is a sacrifice he pays for being different from the lot. Socrates can also be said to know himself because he even jokes with those that found him guilty, saying that he deserves a meal for the service he had rendered to the state (Fagles 23). His earlier rejection of his death sentence can also be linked to knowing himself. What this tells one is that if one really knows oneself, one will be able to withstand every onslaught that comes.

Knowing oneself also amounts to standing up against constituted authority when what they do is illegal. The final decision of Socrates to stoically accept his death sentence may as well be attributed to knowing himself. Socrates may have been of the opinion that even if he is killed for an offence he knows nothing about, even in death, his innocence would still call out. Even though his acceptance of the death sentence has its good sides, it may also be interpreted to be victory for elements of the state that want to silence critics at all cost.

However, on the other hand, one may want to think of Socrates as a tragic hero. Committing himself to the pangs of death, besides indicating that he knows himself, it also indicates that he knows that even in death, he would live on. And that already seems to be the case already because though Socrates did not have lots of works he did himself; the works that have been written about him are innumerable. This truly shows that Socrates knows himself. Similarly, one can easily posit that Achilles knows himself, but maybe not in the same way Socrates knows himself.

This is because from the look of things, one is likely to easily interpret Socrates as a positive character and Achilles as a negative character, in spite of the fact that both of them rebel against constituted authority. The actions of Achilles seem not to have only sprung from knowing himself but also from pride. Achilles knows himself to be someone that has a strong sense of order, so he works towards bringing order to the Achaean camp even though it is not in his place to intervene where he did.

Nonetheless, what he does is the needful. However, all the good sides that he seems to have further emphasizes his immense flaws—pride and petulance. In this regard, one can simply conclude that Achilles’ life does not fall in line with one of the mottoes of the Delphic Oracle - “Know Thyself” – as much as Socrates’ does. The lives of Socrates and Achilles strongly indicate that for one to get to any desired point of self-knowledge, one must be willing to pay sacrifices. Even though Socrates is already in the know about some issues, he acts as though he knows nothing, just to attain self-knowledge.

One may also interpret his death as the ultimate sacrifice he pays for what he stands for. (Perhaps Socrates feigns ignorance of death to also know what death truly is). In the same light, Achilles sacrifices his loyalty to the state and her officials to attain self-knowledge. He assumes the status of a rebel in order to discover the truth. Even though at some points, he is cautioned by the gods, he eventually runs afoul of the ordinances of the gods. Another sacrifice made by Achilles is that, at the end of it all, he surrenders to the gods.

Works Cited Fagles, Robert. Trans. The Iliad. New York: Penguin Books. 1990. Print

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1420677-achilles-in-homers-iliad-or-socrates-in-platos-apology
(Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato'S Apology Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1420677-achilles-in-homers-iliad-or-socrates-in-platos-apology.
“Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato'S Apology Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1420677-achilles-in-homers-iliad-or-socrates-in-platos-apology.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology

Interpretation of Speech by Socrates: The Apology of Plato

Subject: 15 November 2013 The apology of Plato apology by Plato is an interpretation of speech by Socrates which he presented in his defense before the Athenian council.... As the title suggests it does not mean that it is a kind of apology and it derives from a Greek word “apologia” which means a speech made in defense (Plato 2013).... This means that in The apology Socrates try to defend himself.... It is certain with the dialogues that Socrates was very much idealized by his students and the whole account of apology suggests that Plato was kind of loyal to his teacher....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Classical Resemblance of Achilles

homer's iliad has its first two lines describes Achilles' great anger which propelled him to wreck destruction upon his enemies.... homer's Achilles was a great hero....     I would choose Sophocles' Philoctetes to be the tragic hero who best resembles homer's Achilles.... Thetis held achilles by his heel and forgot to wet this heel and this became his weak spot.... hellip; achilles was invulnerable except for his unprotected heel....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Apology of Socrates

Socrates' defense of his life and work as recounted in plato's apology is an ideal work for moving young people to consider their moral responsibilities to themselves and others.... hellip; If we want to flourish as individuals and to develop the habits and moral outlook that will make our lives a blessing to ourselves and to those around us, Grube's translation of apology provides the beacon light. In this paper I will discuss the "True Origin of the Slander" from Socrates early accusers, how does Socrates argument against his latter accuser Meletus show that Meletus isn't concerned with education and lastly how does Socrates argument against Meletus is an example of the true origin of "The Early Slander....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Platos Apology

The paper “plato's apology” looks at Socrates statement about him fulfilling a divine mission, which can be understood in light of the Oracle of Delphi.... It should be noted that one of the charges on socrates was that he was a busybody, a humbug who inquires about the earth and sky.... hellip; The author states that socrates also inquires the politicians, the poets, and craftsmen to see if they were truly wise.... socrates wanted to find out and to prove that an ignorant man could be the wisest one in town, thus the questionings of the politicians, poets, and craftsmen....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Socrates Account of Wisdom in Apology

This essay discusses that socrates both challenges and confirms when he says that he is wise through the virtue of knowing nothing of importance.... hellip; This essay demonstrates that socrates thinks it is important to pursue wisdom, as it will help realize the human ignorance on the perception of wisdom.... socrates further thinks and claims that only the God can be wise.... According to socrates, human wisdom is limited and by realizing that he knows nothing he can achieve a lot....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Socrates in Platos Apology

nbsp;… According to the findings, it can, therefore, be said that in apology, Plato records the defense presented by Socrates himself at the trial for his life.... This paper tells that a great deal of what we know about socrates the man, in fact, all of what we know of him, is what is written about him by others who may or may not have heard him speak.... This is because socrates chose not to write anything down in his pursuit of wisdom....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Plato's Apology through Socrates

The paper "plato's apology through Socrates" makes it clear Plato indicates that the unexamined life is not worth living.... plato's apology considers Socrates' trial in front of the Greek lawmakers who have accused him of undermining the Athenian youth through teaching them his wisdom.... The apology then represents the entirety of Socrates' argument to the court to prove his innocence and demonstrate the absurdity of Meletus' claims against him....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

The Story and Analysis of Plato's Apology

The author of this paper "The Story and Analysis of plato's apology" discusses the concepts of philology such as Axiology, Epistemology, and Ontology.... The paper analyses philosophical areas linked with the teachings of socrates in Apology, a particular dialogue in Ancient Greece penned by Plato....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us