StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Does Google make us stupid or smarter - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A fact that is currently without argument is that technology has drastically impacted upon the way in which society integrates with one another and the way individual members of the society understand the world in which they live. Perhaps more so than any other single determinants, the Internet has provided a means by which massive amounts of information can be delivered to people via something as simple as a few keystrokes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Does Google make us stupid or smarter
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Does Google make us stupid or smarter"

A fact that is currently without argument is that technology has drastically impacted upon the way in which society integrates with one another and the way individual members of the society understand the world in which they live. Perhaps more so than any other single determinants, the Internet has provided a means by which massive amounts of information can be delivered to people via something as simple as a few keystrokes. Whereas before it would require an individual taking the time to seek out the subject matter expert or make a trip to the library in order to determine a specific answer to a given question, a few seconds in front of a computer screen, a few brief keystrokes, and millions of results are available to the user via such search engines as Google.

However, there are those within society that are of the belief that the newfound reliance upon this quick and convenient tool has caused society as a whole to calm lazy and, to put it bluntly, stupid. However, the opposing viewpoint to this is that Google represents merely another means by which individuals within society can readily place their hands on a wealth of information; thereby not making them stupid, but in fact making them smarter as they are now able to integrate with a further level of knowledge that was never before possible.

Although it is true that this knowledge is oftentimes not saved indefinitely within the human memory, the mere fact that the individual is able to integrate with such a massive amount of data necessarily demands such an outcome. Two particular authors that have written upon these issues are those of Nicholas Carr and Carl Zimmer. After a careful analysis of the positions and evidence put forward by these respective authors, it is the understanding of this particular analyst that reliance independence upon such search engines and readily available information, as is provided by Google, does not in fact make society more stupid; rather, it merely provides yet another tool by which information can be shared and the global consciousness can be elevated.

The reasons for such an approach are as follows: readily available information provides more individuals with access to knowledge, ease of acquisition has not been proven to increase the overall level of “stupidity” within society, the mere existence of a tool in and of itself cannot and should not be understood to promote laziness, and the human mind naturally forgets it must be referred – Google, and search engines like it, merely provide a means by which such a natural process can take place more easily (Carr 1).

Within such an understanding, it is the first of these arguments, regarding the ease of acquisition, which must be understood. Zimmer, in his article “How Google Is Making Us Smarter” notes the following: “The Internet and iPhones seem to be crashing the gate of the mind, taking over its natural work and leaving it to wither away to a mental stump. As plausible as this picture may seem, it does a bad job of explaining a lot of recent scientific research” (Zimmer 1). Although Carr fundamentally disagrees with Zimmer, the fact of the matter is that his method of argument is not solid as it relies on unsubstantiated evidence and hearsay to determine that Google and the likes are in fact making us “stupid”.

In such a way, it is the belief of this author that the framework and rubric put forward by Zimmer is far superior and represents a more reasonable and actionable means of defining the relationship between technology and human development. Similarly, it must be understood that the mere existence of the tool itself is a rather weak argument for the fact that laziness and stupidity result. Such an argument falls apart when one considers the fact that the same could be applied to building a new library in a part of town had previously not had one.

When one stops to consider the fact that individuals will now be able to readily access information more efficiently and without traveling the distance, one could just as well assume that it would have the same negative impacts as the argument against search engines, the Internet, and Google specifically. Finally, Zimmer notes within his article that the human mind is continually in a process of realization and loss of memory. This can occur at each and every age and is not bound by senility or diseases such as Alzheimer’s.

Within such a context, Google, and the Internet in general, provide ready access to information that has been integrated with before and perhaps forgotten. In such a way, these tools are not providing and loss; they are merely integrating with extent human needs as they are exhibited within the environment. Works Cited Carr, Nicholas. "Is Google Making Us Stupid? - Nicholas Carr." The Atlantic. N. p., 1 July 2008. Web. 2 July 2013. Zimmer, Carl. "How Google Is Making Us Smarter.” Discover Magazine. N. p., 15 Jan. 2009. Web. 2 July 2013.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Does Google make us stupid or smarter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/english/1481835-does-google-make-us-stupid-or-smarter
(Does Google Make Us Stupid or Smarter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1481835-does-google-make-us-stupid-or-smarter.
“Does Google Make Us Stupid or Smarter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1481835-does-google-make-us-stupid-or-smarter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does Google make us stupid or smarter

Does the Internet make us smarter

This has brought people to debate about the topic whether or not the internet actually makes an individual smarter, which has been further discussed within the scope of this paper.... According to a news report, it was stated that ‘amid the silly videos and spam, the internet has been able to create a new reading and writing culture', thus leading to making a person smarter....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Issues Concerning Modern Technology

This is further explained by use of avatars to make money by use of online games.... It is argued that websites promote ignorance and narcissism.... Technology on the other hand promotes writing and reading acts.... Technology is believed to be changing the mo0de of daily living at a… Several visions have been developed by different proponents such as Ray Karzwell who ascertains that Peggy Orenstein acknowledges that vitro fertilization is growing very fast especially for Americans who would like to have children....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

One full page response paper for each article__total up to 11 articles

Today we live in a world where reality television and the cyber lives we lead on social media are making us more critical of others, not more empathetic.... First and foremost, the most interesting thing that immediately catches the attention is the title.... It has a hint that something profound is being said....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

E-business and value chain

The cases are chosen on the basis of the innovative business modes and their business models are discussed with the help of The Business Model Canvas, where there are… First case is a very famous innovative company google Inc.... google is considered to be the truly innovative company which has bring many The biggest innovation is the AdWords based revenue generation model which is giving much profits to the company....
12 Pages (3000 words) Book Report/Review

Technological Advancements: Impact on Human Intellectual Development

In other words, there is clear, experiment based evidence that people are becoming smarter because they engage technology into their lives.... With more children operating various devices from their young age, one might ask a legitimate question: in what manner does the technology affect out brain?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Is Google Making People Stupid

does google make people stupid?... Weir goes ahead to answer the article by Nicholas Carr that quotes: “Is Google making us stupid?... While the internet makes people dumber, it also makes them smarter and there is not much for them to do about it but accept the bitter-sweet truth.... It makes people smarter and also enables them in making better choices.... That comes as a result of unlimited access to more information that makes people smarter and improves their decision-making....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Does the Internet Make Humans Smarter - Opportunities Given by Modern Information Technologies

The author is of the The paper "Does the Internet make us Smarter by Clay Shirky" is a great example of an article on information technology.... With the developments from the use of the press, to the internet, the users today have indeed been made smarter.... The use of the internet has indeed made its users smarter as opposed to the days when there was no use of the internet.... With the developments from the use of the press, to the internet, the users today have indeed been made smarter....
3 Pages (750 words) Literature review

Reading and thought

"Is Google Making us stupid?... It is a tool that can be used either to foster stupidity as Johnson have described that would make us dumb, or it could also be a source of empowerment for the user by being a tool to make the needed information readily available.... Unlike before, the choice to become smarter is not readily available.... On the contrary, I think it makes us smarter and more critical.... According to MacDonald, the "printed matter that inundates us daily" has been reduced to being reduced to being flimsy and overwhelming and the reading materials available in today's modern society purports “shallow thinking” (MacDonald)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us