Exclusionary Rule – Assignment Example
The paper "Exclusionary Rule" is an outstanding example of a law assignment. I think Kelsey Boylan you are spot on the exclusionary rule. This is because it is an outdated part of judicial that needs to be remedied so that proper justice is provided. In some cases, though the police officers might have obtained the evidence through unconstitutional means, that does not make the suspect innocent and getting rid of that evidence will only free a criminal back to society (Maclin, 2013). The suppression rule seems to be the only solution to the exclusion rule. The evidence is privately disclosed in a court of law, though not made public and the suspect is judged appropriately and fairly. At the same time, the police who are involved in getting the evidence is sanctioned by their departments and exposed to proper avenues to use while acquiring evidence (Dripps, 2002). A Biblical reference that asserts this is Leviticus 19:15, which states, “do not pervert justice; do not show partiality to the poor or favoritism to the great, but judge your neighbor fairly”. The suppression rule also advocates for justice no matter the consequence.
Deborah Bradley, you seem to be a critic of Donald Dripps’ theory of contingent suppression. I believe that Dripps makes a reasonable approach to remedy constitutional violations through his methodology restricts truth and justice to some extent (Tashev & Wiley Inter-Science Online service, 2009). Restorative justice is cumbersome compared to the suppression rule. In restorative justice, victims, offenders, and the whole involved community must take part in ensuring that the harm done is repaired. This is contrary to just satisfying the abstract legal principles (Strickland, 2004). Isaiah 1:17 states that, “we should learn to do right and always seek justice.”