The paper "The Relations of the US and Canada at Through the One-Way Mirror by Margaret Atwood" is a delightful example of an article on social science. In the essay, Atwood illustrates that the United States demonstrates self-centeredness and arrogance in the way it relates to other states, in this case, Canada. Atwood shows that there are many differences between the two countries on many issues thus proving her point. According to her argument, the US and Canada demonstrate some unique features concerning their diplomatic relations. She demonstrates that there are notable diplomatic relations between the United States and Canada as she argues that most Americans do not know much about Canada.
Atwood claims that the Americans do not recognize the Canadians although it is situated at its north but notices it when there is an unpatriotic thing done. More so, the Americans push the Canadians to the belief that they are part of the US accusing them of being paranoid when they raise any issue (Atwood 1986). The author adds that the Canadians are fearful of the American's nature since they can convert them to be arrogant as they (Canadians) believe the Americans are.
Additionally, the two states have differences based on their education system as shown by the author. The writer further describes that the Americans perceive themselves as self-worth since they learn their history first followed by that of the world. On the contrary, Canadians are taught world history with that of their nation. It has also been shown that Canada and the US bear some differences regarding their foreign policy thus approving the belief by Atwood.
Atwood illustrates that Canada is keen on making good relations with others or assisting others when responding to a calamity. On the other hand, she claims that the U. S is not concerned with what befall others as long as they are not affected (Atwood 1986). Thesis Statement The author is demonstrating the conflicting perception between the U. S and Canada. Therefore, the thesis of the essay is, “ The identity crisis existing between the U. S and Canada. ” Tone The overall tone of Atwood’ s essay is sarcastic. By drawing several examples, the author is generally sarcastic in illustrating and describing the existing differences between the two nations.
She is referring to the U. S with an attitude filled with contempt since she concludes that they see themselves as the best compared to others, in this case, Canada. For instance, in her second paragraph, she says, “ The Americans, bless their innocent little hearts, ..” Atwood was concluding that the Americans are not aware that they are being watched by the whole world referring to their innocence. Also, she shows that the U. S sees themselves on top of others and they even mock others using this notion.
“ The Americans sometimes imply that Canada is part of the U. S, and when Canada objects we are told we are paranoid and accused of having an identity crisis. ” In this line, Atwood shows that it is not the Canadians who have an identity crisis but the Americans although they are not aware. Therefore, a sarcastic mood is displayed all through Atwood’ s essay (Atwood 1986). Personal Reflection When the author argues that the Americans have ‘ innocent little hearts, ’ it could mean that they are not aware of their status hence proving their arrogance.
This statement could bear some sense because, at some part of the essay, Atwood argues that the Americans at times call Canada their backyard although it is not. Additionally, they value themselves more than others as demonstrated by their education. Calling Canada their backyard makes me confused because Canada is a nation on its own located in the north of the U. S. I like the part where the Canadians are shown to be paranoid on the claims made by the Americans. This reminds me of Atwood’ s sarcastic statement that “ The Canadians can’ t exactly call the police – they suspect the Americans are the police-… ” It shows that the Americans invite themselves anywhere even when not invited demonstrating their self-centeredness.
In my view based on Atwood’ s essays, the Americans are the ones faced by an Identity crisis and not others like Canada (Atwood 1986).