StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Summary of Karen Musalos Article When Rights and Culture Collide - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper presents a summary of Karen Musalo article When Rights and Culture Collide which she wrote in a reflection in a case she had handled that concerned human rights. She begins by relating the story of Fauziya Kasinga who faced a challenge brought about by culture colliding with the rights.   …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Summary of Karen Musalos Article When Rights and Culture Collide
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Summary of Karen Musalos Article When Rights and Culture Collide"

Summary of Karen Musalo’s Article When Rights and Culture CollideKaren Musalo is the author of a compelling article titled When Rights and Culture Collide which she wrote in a reflection in a case she had handled that concerned human rights. She begins by relating the story of Fauziya Kasinga a girl from Togo who faced a challenge brought about by culture colliding with the rights. After presenting details of the story, Musalo then advances to offer a critical analysis of the application of human rights and the views exhibited by proponents of cultural relativism, ethnocentrism and cultural universalism.

She develops her argument backing them up with examples and eventually takes her stand in support of cultural universalism. In a bid to refute cultural relativism, she offers a strong argument against their beliefs. This paper will present a summary of her article. Karen Musalo was the attorney Fauziya Kasinga who was under the compulsion of undergoing female genital mutilation after she has been betrothed to an old man for marriage. These events occurred after the death of her father and the fact that her aunt exiled her mother and proceeded to betroth her to the old man.

However, Fauziya was rescued by her mother and sister and decided to seek help. This is where Musalo intervened, serving as her attorney in her request for an asylum in the United States. Musalo relates this story in her article and highlights how she was constantly questioned on her stand concerning the relevance of culture and her decision to defend Fauziya, who was defying the cultural norms and practices. She then develops her argument, introducing cultural relativism, cultural universals and ethnocentrism (Musalo n. pag). Cultural relativism denotes the belief that the international convention of human rights should not surpass a nation’s culture.

Proponents of this belief have the conviction that there is no moral principle that can apply evenly to all nations and cultures. In their view, the human right convention only seeks to impose western ideals on weaker states. On the other hand, cultural universalism is the belief that the human right convention should be applied to all nations irrespective of their culture and religion. Ethnocentrism denoted the view that one’s culture is superior and that he or she should judge other cultures based on the definitions of his or her own culture.

In the case of Fauziya Kasinga, cultural universalism and cultural relativism were at loggerheads. Musalo and other proponents of universalism had the conviction that Fauziya was entitled to human rights which prevented her from any form of violence irrespective of her gender or culture (n.pag). However, cultural relativists held the view that, cultural practices were still fundamental aspects of the society and that no moral principle established internationally should apply to all nations evenly.

Musalo explores the foundation of the United Nation and the factors that facilitated its formation. She presents multiple examples of diverse cultures across the globe that does not conform to the international human rights convention. Her examples are not limited to gender based violence, but also to an emerging violence committed against men. Without doubt, Musalo is of the opinion that cultural universalism is a more rational argument which should mean that the human rights of all individuals should be protected.

I totally agree with Musalo’s argument that the human rights convention should have a universal application because it seeks to protect all the individuals from any form of violence. In the case of Fauziya, I have the conviction that Musalo did the right thing in ensuring that she got an asylum and was saved from cultural practices that brutally violated her rights as an individual (n. pag). Work CitedMusalo, Karen. When Rights and Cultures Collide. Web.14th June, 2014.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 171”, n.d.)
Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 171. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1649918-essay
(Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 171)
Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 171. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1649918-essay.
“Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 171”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1649918-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Summary of Karen Musalos Article When Rights and Culture Collide

What is culture

The article entitled "What is the concept of culture?... written by Langley (2010) presented the thesis that probed on the ultimate concept of culture by defining it and delving into the categories of subculture and popular culture.... nitially,Langley proffered a definition of culture by citing that “the concept of culture has a clear definition of ‘the sum total of ways of living built up by a group of human beings and transmitted from one generation to another',but the depth of any single culture reflects that of its participants” ....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

The Truth About Mass Shootings and Gun Controls

The Secret History of Guns Supporters of gun rights argue that the second amendment gives right to gun ownership but portrays no regulation.... According to newton the civil rights movement caused more violence.... Once Newton was stopped by Oakland police to show his gun but he vehemently refused grounding his rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Karen Armstrong's Does God Have a Future

God becomes more compassionate when we can take responsibility for our own actions.... In the paper “karen Armstrong's Does God Have a Future” the author analyzes karen Armstrong's essay where the author questions whether the concept of God is still valid in today's world....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Bridging the Cultural Divide

They may be doing the same job under one organization, but they totally differ in culture and assumptions.... when the employees openly and willingly disclose about their values and behaviors, the other can understand and learn to receive them the way they are.... For instance, there should be an agreed way of harmonizing cultural divide when it comes to decision making process (Chinitz 123)....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Culture and Business

culture in business affects the operation, focus and the hierarchy of leadership.... The role of culture in business has been massive because they determine the mode of… culture defines the development of relationships between suppliers and customers as well the development of a marketing plan and objectives.... The culture of the countries differs significantly Opinion article From the article, it is evident that the impact of culture on business is massive especially in negotiations....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Jewish Legacy Inscribed On Genes by Karen Kaplan

However, the shared genetic legacy may be a significant factor in the identification of Jews such as the culture that originates from group membership and shared religious beliefs.... when the average IQ of a group is 100, this implies that persons with an IQ above 140 are 0.... %, while when the average is 110, the genius rate is 2.... This paper 'Jewish Legacy Inscribed On Genes by karen Kaplan" focuses on the fact that the Ashkenazi Jews are also known as “Jews of Germany” are a Jewish ethnic division that emerged from the Holy Roman Empire approximately in the first millennium (Silberstein 11)....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Haitian Culture and Citizens of Haiti

The essay "Haitian culture" describes in this case, the young man is homosexual, moreover, he is sick and HIV.... Haitian culture In the given case a young man is homosexual, moreover he is sick and has HIV.... “Human rights campaigners in the Caribbean nation say they know of 47 assaults in just one week (17 to 24 July), though attacks have slowed in recent days following government intervention....
2 Pages (500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us