StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan” four issues will be tackled regarding the article Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan: gender ideology, just parenting, good fathering, and Christian families as disciples who may be called to be “countercultural.”…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan"

Gender Ideology, Just Parenting, Good Fathering, and Living Counterculturally: A Summary of Points in Pulling Punches andAdvice for the Author Here, four issues will be tackled regarding the article Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan: gender ideology, just parenting, good fathering, and Christian families as disciples who may be called to be "countercultural." Finally, advice will be given to Mr. Duncan as to what he should do, according to moral sources. In this reflective piece, Mr. Duncan struggles with gender ideology. He "wonders whether [he] should" teach his son to fight (Duncan 2009, 1). Why Because it is the manly thing to do, and learning how to fight somehow denotes learning how to be a man. Duncan thinks that perhaps knowing how to fight will help his son survive as a man in a man's world, just as he thinks this skill helped himself and his brothers cope with life: "Over time, physical combat begot intellectual combat, and our competitiveness and discipline allowed us to be fairly successful in the world" (Duncan 2009, 1). Mr. Duncan wants to be a just parent, as he worries about "failing [his] children" (Duncan 2009, 1). What he means to be the implications of failing his children, one is not exactly sure. Would his children become effeminate if they didn't learn how to fight Would they not have material success in the world if they didn't learn how to fight Duncan says the conflict between pacifism and fighting "creates a kind of parental dissonance, a discomfort that [he feels] slightly embarrassed to talk about in polite company" (Duncan 2009, 1). Duncan wonders if he is being a good father by not teaching his son to fight-just as his own father seemed to have been an effective father by teaching his sons how to fight, and also carry on the legacy of his grandfather. Duncan seems to be indebted to his father but conflicted by the social message of the Catholic teaching he grew up with: "My father would tell me that my son should learn to fight. My church tells me he should learn to love. Am I a bad father for teaching him one, and not the other I hope not" (Duncan 2009, 1). In some ways, Duncan feels a call to lead a "countercultural" sort of lifestyle. He says he is "a Catholic who takes the call to be a peacemaker much more seriously than [his] own parents did. Though [he] is not a pacifist[he has] great admiration and respect for the kind fo courage pacifism entails[my own] paradox" (Duncan 2009, 1). Some advice for Mr. Duncan is in order. First of all, Mr. Duncan must realize that there are certain unwritten codes which we all follow according to the gender roles which society dictates. In a study of ads, "Goffman's models seem to follow one body of tacit social rules about gender, not two or three, or some mix[a sort of] code" (Hochschild 2003, 46). Mr. Duncan's child is young. It is normal for a child to question at that age who he is. "So, at this point [in a boy's life], [he's] asking [himself], Who and what am I Is this my identity" (Cahill 2006, 146) A good relationship with his father is guaranteed to help his son have success in life, not learning how to fight necessarily. Gathered from the "clinical experience of many psychiatrists and therapists doesstemfrom problematic relationships with parents. The basic idea is that each individual in some sense has to 'achieve' his gender identity by going through a developmental process" (Cahill 2006, 153). This solves the issue of gender roles. Now, Duncan is worried if he is being a just parent. "[W]here the ordinary relationships with parents are disrupted [in this process of achieving gender identity]this process is short-circuited" (Cahill 2006, 153). Clearly Duncan does not have problems here. He may perceive he is being a bad parent if he does not clearly define gender roles-ultra-masculinity being demonstrated by the fact that his son would know how to fight. "Ultra-femininity, like ultra-masculinity, may mask the underlying social principle of 'balancing' [gender codes between the two polar opposite choices of a female choice and a male choice]" (Hochschild 2003, 51). Duncan has fears about whether he is doing his son a service as a father. According to the research by Stephen Post, [t]he National Commission of Children's 1991 reportstates that "families formed by marriage-where two caring adults are committed to one another and to their children-provide the best environment for bringing children into the world" (Rubio 2003, 15). This was a lesser denigration to single-parent and gay families, which are less like minister James Dobson's orthodox Christian approach to what constitutes the Christian family (Rubio 2003, 15). Whereas Stephen Post claims "no definition of family," James Dobson assumes that traditional gender roles in the family are correct (Rubio 2003, 15). In these respects, Duncan does not mention if he is a single or gay parent. If Duncan does belong to an alternative parenting style, he should strongly consider whether his committed relationship (if one exists) is loving. If not, it is seriously recommended that he amend that problem. The gender roles need not necessarily be strictly defined, as James Dobson would argue. Duncan should not worry about teaching his son how to fight, necessarily. Either way, if he fights or not, his son will have to carry the burden of Christ. "For a Christian, moreover, there is that dimension of suffering not available to unbelievers: it is a share in the Cross of Christ" (Cahill 2006, 160). If the son fights, he must fight in a manner according to his faith (fairly), and if he does not fight, he will also have to defend his pacifistic actions through citing why a good Catholic is against violence. Christopher Duncan has moral scruples about gender ideology, just parenting, his role as a father, and the idea of living a "countercultural" life from a Christian worldview. Advice was given to him based on various sources of moral authority-based on what is known about Mr. Duncan. It is hoped that his life, and the life of his son, would be enhanced knowing how to navigate some thorny philosophically difficult issues surrounding whether or not Mr. Duncan should teach his son to fight. REFERENCES M. L. Cahill, et. al., 2006. Sexuality and the catholic church. NY: Crossroad. C. Duncan, 2009. Pulling punches. [Online Article] http://www.commonwealmagazine.org/article.php3id_article=2529&var_recherche=fight. Retrieved 6 May 2009. A. R. Hochschild, 2003. The commercialization of intimate life: notes from home and work. USA: University of California Press. J. Hanlon Rubio, 2003. A christian theology of marriage and family. USA: Paulist Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words, n.d.)
Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1520313-theology-marriage-in-the-20th-century
(Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1520313-theology-marriage-in-the-20th-century.
“Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1520313-theology-marriage-in-the-20th-century.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan

Isadora Duncan harmony with dance

Isadora duncan: Harmony with Dance Isadora duncan: The Dancing Legend An Introduction Isadora duncan, the Goddess of Dance was born in San Francisco in the year 1877 (Lomask, 1997).... Worldwide popular as the “Mother of Modern Dance”, duncan has also been considered to be a Romanticist (Uminski, 2007).... However, duncan was overtly criticized by the narrow minded section of the society according to which she was far too advance than the era in which she was living (Uminski, 2007)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Isadora Duncan Research Paper

It is believed that modern dance in the United States originates from its founders, who were contemporaries of Isadora duncan, Ruth St.... It was not said about her, but once a bright spark of divine fire illuminated her way in art, making famous American Isadora duncan from a beginning ballerina.... On that day in May, when Isadora Angela duncan was born, the mother of the future European star suffered two disappointments: the first sounds she heard recovering from childbirth were vehement cries of depositors of her husband' bank....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Shakespear's Play Macbeth: Who killed Duncan

This paper also seeks to present more clearly the idea of duncan's death, drawing evidence from the play's main themes as the unique characterization.... The essay "Shakespear's Play Macbeth: Who killed duncan?... seeks to present more clearly the idea of duncan's death, drawing evidence from the play's main themes as the unique characterization.... The setting of the play is in Scotland, whereby during that time duncan was the ultimate king....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Duncan v. Kahanamoku

In the case of duncan v.... As in the duncan's case, the civilian must never be seen to be threatened by the security that should actually protect them....   Analysis of the Case of duncan v.... Kahanamoku Analysis of the Case of duncan v.... duncan, the Supreme Court started to address the legality of the martial law in Hawaii.... duncan was a civilian who worked for the navy.... Under the martial law, the military tribunal tried, convicted, and sentenced duncan for six months in prison....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A Confederacy of Dunces

Many fictional characters have had an influence on my life, but there has been one in particular that stands out.... It would be difficult if not ridiculous to say that I have patterned my way of life on this character;… Many fictional characters have had an influence on my life, but there has been one in particular that stands out....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Product Positioning in the Duncan Industries

In the paper “Product Positioning in the duncan Industries,” the author analyzes duncan Industries, which should conduct an aggressive marketing campaign for brand awareness.... will reach only the wage earners and they, of course, do not have much to about the duncan industry product.... The competitors of duncan industries were using a combination of wholesalers and company salespeople.... duncan industries can also work on those lines and develop a good strategy so that their price is also very competitive and also try to use a combination of wholesalers and sales personnel to increase their sales....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Why I feel Grateful to Duncan Abdelnour

In the paper “Why I feel Grateful to duncan Abdelnour” the author describes a point in one's life when an awareness of the future emerges.... It was so interesting for me because the name tagged to it is someone I know or, at least, someone I am familiar with: duncan Abdelnour.... Here is the thing: Reading about duncan Abdelnour and Beatmerch sort of woke me up and inspired me at the same time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Domestic Terrorism: The Christopher Dorner Manhunt

The paper discusses the domestic terrorism case involving christopher Jordan Dorner.... The man was a former cop in LAPD having acquired qualified training and served in US Navy, and several divisions of LAPD before being relieved from duty, for reasons claiming false accusations against other officers… christopher was accused of killing innocent people, causing linked injuries as he tried to attack his targets, and caused indirectly related harm through the LAPD open fires as they looked, and mistakenly shot members of the society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us