StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

John Stuart Mill and Aristotle's Viewpoints in Their Epistemological and Metaphysical Attitudes - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper compares John Stuart Mill and Aristotle’s conflicting viewpoints on notable issues.  For example, Stuart believes that the state should conform towards the individual while Aristotle believes that the state is inalienable to the individual’s life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
John Stuart Mill and Aristotles Viewpoints in Their Epistemological and Metaphysical Attitudes
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "John Stuart Mill and Aristotle's Viewpoints in Their Epistemological and Metaphysical Attitudes"

Task: John Stuart Mill and Aristotle John Stuart Mill is one of the most influential 19th century’s philosophers because of the breadth and depth of his arguments. Mill accorded a contemporary view of philosophy by instigating notable intellectual approaches towards epistemological and metaphysical issues. Mill, particularly, was intriguing in the sense in which his philosophies synchronized with the development of the world. On the other hand, Aristotle is a profound philosopher because he produced thoughts, which have survived through generations.

Aristotle possessed the foresight that ensured his thoughts survived through ages. John Stuart Mill and Aristotle have conflicting viewpoints in notable issues. Mill and Aristotle have different viewpoints over what constitutes satisfaction in life. In his writings on Utilitarianism, John Stuart Mill upholds utility as the ultimate happiness principle. In this sense, an individual should strive towards maximizing one’s pleasure and works towards minimizing pain (Dēmētriou and Loizides 21).

Mill, therefore, holds that pleasure and the absence of pain are the ultimate ends in a person’s life. On the other hand, in Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle describes the ultimate end of life as leaving in virtue and reason. Aristotle argues that happiness is a subjective concept that differs in every person. He refutes honor as concerned with seeking legitimacy among other people. In this sense, honor is not necessarily the legitimacy that it represents. Aristotle argues that a satisfied person must master the intellectual virtue and the moral virtue.

Besides, satisfaction demands that a person possesses the ability to use one’s faculties of reasoning in the appropriate sense. John Stuart Mill and Aristotle disagree over what makes up correct knowledge. Aristotle, in the Organon, developed a method of logic that comprised a system of principles for establishing syllogisms. In this sense, individuals could utilize their intuition to develop logic. Such forms of arguments start with a core premise that precedes a conclusion. On the other hand, Mill, an empiricist, believed that knowledge could only form out of senses.

Forming logic depends on observing a system of related instances that bear a premise true. In his System of Logic, Mill created hegemony between deductive thinking and inductive thinking. In deductive thinking, a conclusion leads towards the development of principles that support it. On the other hand, inductive thinking involves drawing a conclusion from clearly stated premises. Stuart and Aristotle’s view of social contract differ in notable ways. Aristotle views individuals as political animals thereby heralding the formation of the state as an inevitable end.

He also argues that individuals’ welfare improves when the individual belongs to a community. In this sense, Aristotle argues that a state legitimizes the existence of the individual. On the other hand, Mill views the individual as a sacred entity, whose existence supersedes the existence of the state (Dēmētriou and Loizides 21). The society, in this position, becomes a basis for exploring the individual’s talents and gifts. Indeed, Stuart and Aristotle have differing viewpoints in their epistemological and metaphysical attitudes.

Stuart believes that happiness should be an ultimate end in life as an individual maximizes pleasure and minimizes pain. On the other hand, Aristotle believes that a satisfactory life comprises a robust intellectual virtue, a sound moral virtue, and developed reasoning faculties. In addition, Stuart believes that only senses should be employed in deriving knowledge while Aristotle believes that true knowledge builds from stated premises. Besides, Stuart believes that the state should conform towards the individual while Aristotle believes that the state is inalienable to the individual’s life.

Works cited Dēmētriou, Kyriakos N, and Antis Loizides. John Stuart Mill: a British Socrates. Basingstoke, HA: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“John Stuart Mill and Aristotle's Viewpoints in Their Epistemological Essay - 6”, n.d.)
John Stuart Mill and Aristotle's Viewpoints in Their Epistemological Essay - 6. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1640570-please-give-me-a-suitable-topic-of-this-essay-thank-you
(John Stuart Mill and Aristotle'S Viewpoints in Their Epistemological Essay - 6)
John Stuart Mill and Aristotle'S Viewpoints in Their Epistemological Essay - 6. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1640570-please-give-me-a-suitable-topic-of-this-essay-thank-you.
“John Stuart Mill and Aristotle'S Viewpoints in Their Epistemological Essay - 6”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1640570-please-give-me-a-suitable-topic-of-this-essay-thank-you.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF John Stuart Mill and Aristotle's Viewpoints in Their Epistemological and Metaphysical Attitudes

The Ultimate Causes and Underlying Nature of Things: Metaphysics

Some philosophers, however, saw apparent inconsistency in aristotle's theory of matter (Wedin, 2002, 1).... Some philosophers, however, saw apparent inconsistency in aristotle's theory of matter (Wedin, 2002, 1).... A Commentary on aristotle's Metaphysics: A Most Ample Index to the Metaphysics of Aristotle (Doyle, J.... aristotle's Theory of Substance: The Categories and Metaphysics Zeta....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophical Ideas of John Stuart Mill

hellip; The constraint may be physiological, moral, social , religious and in all the cases it limits the human being. john stuart mill discussed this problem, of liberty-constraint in his essay: "On liberty".... john stuart mill was educated by his father, James Mill, who was cold and rigid.... john stuart mill, Life and writings) john stuart mill, in his essay "On liberty", mentioned liberty and the relationships between freedom and state....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

John Stuart Mills Utilitarianism

The aim of the essay “john stuart mill's Utilitarianism” is to analyzes the concept of happiness, which can be gleaned in john stuart mill's Utilitarianism.... mill and Kant are structurally so different in as much as Mill puts primary importance, and strictly, on empiricism, or natural experience as the basis for morality, whereas Kant's basis for morality (the morality of metaphysics) stems from a priori knowledge or what he calls pure reason - laws which are evident in every rational being....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Epistemological and Methodological Approaches

The study has also taken into account the difference in attitudes between the fire-setter and non-fire setter children.... The positivist approach can also be called a scientific inquiry that emerges from the metaphysical reaction.... The epistemological approach involves a conceptualizing process which shows how theory involves and how the theory is revised by varying degree.... The epistemological approach involves the development of a qualitative approach and the qualitative approach gets validated by the quantitative methods....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

John Stuart Mill

The paper "john stuart mill" states that john stuart mill effectively points out that the defects of the government may either be positive or negative and that the government's defects can be negative if it the government does not concentrate efficient in the hands of the sufficient authorities.... hellip; According to Chapter 5 of the Proper Functions of Representative Bodies, john stuart mill elaborately explains the meaning of a representative government whereby the people have the absolute power to exercise through their elected deputies the ultimate controlling power....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Influence of Aristotle on John Stuart Mills and Karl Marxs Studies

The research question that guided the research purpose was “In what ways, if any, do john stuart mill and Karl Marx each appear to have been influenced by Aristotle?... rdquo; Critically, the researcher related the research question directly to the research purpose.... hellip; This research will begin with the statement that according to Aristotle, all the action that we perform has an end, and everybody is determined to live a good life....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

John Stuart Mills Utilitarianism

This paper is a discussion of the mills statement that “it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig john stuart Mills Utilitarianism john stuart Mills Utilitarianism Mills observes many individuals misunderstanding utilitarianism by viewing utility as opposition to pleasure.... This may be associated with the love of liberty and independence (mill, 2002).... I agree with mill in his statement that it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

John Lockes and Aristotles Understanding of Moral Life

Th paper "John Locke's and aristotle's Understanding of Moral Life" is aimed to give an analysis of similarities and differences between John Locke and aristotle's understanding of moral life and model of governance.... John Locke and aristotle's understanding of moral life and model of governance Introduction John Locke and Aristotle both focused their attention on how humans coped in a free state of nature, contrary to a structured society....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us