StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth" discusses that an Afro-Argentine magically gave birth to white children and grandchildren. The fact that these Afro-Argentines were, in essence, moving up in the racially prejudiced society is also to blame for this tampering in the records…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth"

Corey Aguayo Greg Landau History 18 25 April Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth. Today, Argentina is termed as the “whitest” Latin American country, with an approximately ninety-seven percent of so-called white or ethnically European population. However, just how a country surrounded by others with such large Afro/black populations, and a country having a history of African slavery, have such a low population of non-whites is a question that many in Argentina have either ignored or made excuses for. Latin America has a large population that comprises of people from African ancestry, yet Argentina, a Latin American country, does not have such a population, and offers little or no reason for this phenomenon. For those of African ancestry, in particular those in Argentina, it is important to find out just why their history and perhaps their very existence have been so whitewashed. These questions are just as important to a historian, or any person who is interested in the matter, and need to be answered. Argentina was not a plantation oriented country; therefore, the slave trade did not flourish as much as in other parts of Latin America. However, this does not mean that there were no slaves in Argentina in general and Buenos Aires in particular. Buenos Aires was, in fact, one of the major ports where the slave ships were docked (Molina). From these slave ships, a lot of slaves were smuggled into Buenos Aires, of course with the tacit consent of the authorities. Most of the African slaves that were obtained in Buenos Aires were either for household help purposes (cooks, handmaids etc.) or were artisans who were rented out by their masters to those in need of their services (Quintana). Moreover, the tasks that were considered to be below the dignity of the “white” population, such as cleaning the sewers, were also relegated to them (Quintana). Some estimates state that about one-fourth to one-third of the population of Buenos Aires, in the early nineteenth century, comprised of Afro-Argentines (Gudmundson). However, by the late nineteenth century, in the 1887 census to be exact, they comprised of about 1.8% of the population (Reel 1), after which a new category was introduced in their stead, that of “trigueno” or “wheatish” (Mundra 1), which of course included such white Europeans as the Italians and Sicilians who were darker than the others. So the question that begs to be asked is: where did all these Afro-Argentines disappear? And if it is to be accepted that there is no longer any Afro-Argentine or black population in Buenos Aires, then how does one account for people who claim to be Afro-Argentines, people like Miriam Gomes, an Afro-Argentine described by Reel in her report (1)? Some hypothesis have been forwarded before in this regard: some state that it was due to some sort of epidemic that swept the black population in mid nineteenth century, and other put the blame on many of the blacks dying on the front lines in wars (Reel 1). However, these views have been challenged now. George Reid Andrews is a major proponent of the theory that it was not so much as blacks dying in war that the population of Afro-Argentines has decreased, but that there are other reasons thereof. Andrews clearly shows that though there were segregated units in the Argentine army, however, integration was much more the norm, with Afro-Argentines being promoted to officer ranks as well, even though the whites were much more likely to be promoted to senior ranks (Andrews 69, 70 & 76). Andrews also points out that many historians have tried to wash over this fact in order to promote their theory of the blacks being “cannon fodder” to the whites (71), which Andrews asserts was never the case with Argentina (63-64), even though such a policy was adopted in the rest of Latin America. Moreover, Andrews also states that not only did the Afro-Argentines not die at a faster rate in the army than their white counterparts, but they also had a sense of self-preservation and did not fight without any consideration for their own protection (65 & 68). This clearly shows that despite what the historians claim, the scourge of war and the fate of becoming cannon fodder was not what eliminated or decreased the Afro-Argentine population so drastically. The question about what happened to the Afro-Argentines, therefore, remains unanswered, because the assertions made before are now found to be incorrect. Gudmundson points out that it was not merely due to the ever popular causes of fever or war that the population of Afro-Argentines was decreased, but that the living standard of those days was such that not only was the infant mortality rate higher among the Afro-Argentines, but that the marrying age of Afro-Argentine women was much higher than those of their white counterparts, which resulted in lesser pregnancies. Also, most of the Afro-Argentine slaves in cities were women (Gudmundson states that women almost outnumbered men 2 to 1 in cities), which made it increasingly hard for them to find Afro-Argentine men to marry them, as such men were mostly either living at the country side or conscripted with the army. In such a scenario, Gudmundson points out, the slave women usually were concubines to white men, whether their masters or not, and in some cases were even married by them, thereby changing their status. Their children, later on, took on the ancestry of their white father and proclaimed themselves to be white. This also caused a great decrease in the Afro-Argentine population as a lot of them were hesitant to call themselves anything but white. An interesting point in this regard is the fact that though most of the Argentines do consider themselves to be white, they are not considered so in North America or Europe, where they are called Latino or Hispanic (Aido). This shows that the term “white” is very relative. Moreover, when Miriam Gomes, with funding from World Bank, started a project of limited census to see how many of the so-called white populace of Buenos Aires was in fact white (Reel 1). The census helpers observed that in some cases those who were apparently black, or those who present black characteristics, refused to take part in the census, denying their Afro-Argentine roots (Reel 2). Andrews also points at this trend by illustrating the case of Captain Gregorio Sanfine, an Afro-Argentine, who was later classified as white in the census and through his personal papers, and his children and grandchildren were also so transformed (71). So an Afro-Argentine magically gave birth to white children and grandchildren. The fact that these Afro-Argentines were, in essence, moving up in the racially prejudiced society is also to blame for this tampering in the records This bias has not changed so far, and perhaps that is why the response of Afro-Argentines to the census is also understandable, as the racial prejudice in Argentine society is great and being non-white or Afro-Argentine automatically results in one being termed as inferior or an oddity. As Molina pointed out in his essay, some of his own compatriots ask him which country he comes from, or treat him like a pet or an oddity, touching his hair because they say it brings luck. The census takers, knowing of all these sensitivities and peculiarities of the Argentine culture, also took DNA samples, the results of which clearly showed that about 10 percent of those who claimed to be white were actually part descendants of Afro-Argentines (Reel 2; Mundra 2). The attitude of the blacks during this census clearly shows that what an anthropologist stated about Afro-Argentines themselves keeping their identity secret is true (Mundra 2). Though one has to respect that fact, keeping in mind that though the time may have changed in respect to the epoch, yet the Afro-Argentines feel that it is the same when it comes to racial prejudice, thereby making it necessary for them to hide. This trend, however, is changing now, with organizations like Africa Vive, Grupo Cultural Afro, and, much recently, Associacion Misibamba coming out to proclaim their Afro-Argentine roots, and celebrate their ethnic diversity. As these groups rightly point out, Afro-Argentines have shaped much of the white Argentine culture as well, and should be respected in this regard. Moreover, they need to be given their due in historical records as well; in the words of Andrews, “The Afro-Argentines lived in a white man’s society; the alternatives were either to fight his wars or to suffer the consequences of refusing to do so. While fight those wars they served not only as followers but also as leaders, and as soldiers and officers they compiled a record of achievement that has been too easily relegated to history’s back drawers. Let the record stand corrected” (Andrews 77). Works Cited Aidi, Hisham. “Blacks in Argentina: Disappearing Acts.” The Global African Presence. Runoko Rashidi. 14 June 2002. Web. 26 Apr. 2010. Andrews, George Reid. “The Black Legions of Buenos Aires, Argentina, 1800-1900.” Slavery and Beyond: The African Impact on Latin America and the Caribbean. Ed. Darién J. Davis. Lanham, MD: SR Books, 1995. 55-80. Print. Gudmundson, Lowell. “Black into White in Nineteenth Century Spanish America: Afro-American Assimilation in Argentina and Costa Rica.” Slavery and Abolition 5.1 (1984): 34-49. Web. 26 Apr. 2010. Molina, Lucía Dominga. “The Black in a Supposedly White Society. (El Negro en una Sociedad Pretendidamente Blanca)” Agencia Latinoamericana de Información. América Latina en Movimiento. 10 Jan. 1995. Web. 25 Apr. 2010. Mundra, Anil. “The Reawakening of Afro-Argentine Culture.” Global Post – International News. 30 Aug. 2009. Web. 25 Apr. 2010. Quintana, Antonio. “The New World.” Zevallos TV & Networking Friends. Zevallos TV. n.d. Web. 26 Apr. 2010. Reel, Monte. “In Buenos Aires, Researchers Exhume Long-Unclaimed African Roots.” The Washington Post: The Washington Post Company. 5 May 2005. Web. 25 Apr. 2010. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Afro-Argentineans Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Afro-Argentineans Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565559-afro-argentineans
(Afro-Argentineans Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Afro-Argentineans Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565559-afro-argentineans.
“Afro-Argentineans Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565559-afro-argentineans.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth

Nationalization of oil industry in Argentina

This paper 'Nationalization of oil industry in Argentina' critically analyses the decision to nationalize oil companies in Argentina.... Under these circumstances, Argentina's actions would definitely force international companies to think many times before investing in Argentina.... ... ... ... The author believes that nationalization of Argentinian oil industry has raised many concerns not only in Argentina, but also in other countries, especially in Spain....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Argentine Americans

This paper describes Argentine Americans.... The word Argentina was actually derived from Latin.... The English meaning for it is Silver.... May be this is the reason why sometimes Argentina is referred as "The Land of Silver" (Rodriguez).... "The official name of the country is Republic of Argentina (Rodriguez)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

Genetically Modified Foods

oybeans and corn are the top two most widely grown crops (82% of all GM crops harvested in 2000), with cotton, rapeseed (or canola) and potatoes trailing behind.... The paper "Genetically Modified Foods" underlines that genetic engineering has a lot to prove in future and therefore, we should not ignore the technology which has great benefits, but it is necessary to make use of the technology with care and caution....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Origin of UK and Argentina Conflict

However, in reality, the Britons living 200 miles off their coast were by no means a threat to the Argentines.... The paper "Origin of UK and Argentina Conflict" tells that the Falkland Islands war of 1982 involved the United Kingdom forces resisting the illegal occupation of Argentine forces in the Falkland Islands....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Argentine Military Terror

In this context, terrorism referred to issues that were aimed to threaten or intimidate political opponents.... Argentina's politics in 1970-1980 s was also influenced by tension between Russia and the United.... ... ... The period was also marked by left-wing terrorism or Marxist terrorism, which sought to overthrow the capitalist regimes and possibly replace them with socialist governments....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Economic Globalization of Argentina

Looking into Argentina's past, the formerly closed economy later opened, allowing its economic integration to the global economy.... The structural reforms.... ... ... out in Argentina in the 90s set its economy on a path to sustained growth, after the country's financial difficulties and poor economic performance that resulted to hyperinflation towards the end of the 80's....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Argentinas Government Structure and Domestic Society

This report "Argentina's Government Structure and Domestic Society" discusses Argentina that is not different, and its politics and government structure are designed by its sub-national political power structures.... Its government structure has a close resemblance to that of the United States.... ...
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Asian Pacific Trade and Food Safety and Security

The trade of agro business is directly associated with the prospect of the food systems of developing as well as poor and non-developing countries.... ... ... The paper "Asian Pacific Trade and Food Safety and Security" is a perfect example of a macro & microeconomics case study.... The subject of the global trade of agribusiness is very important for all the developed, developing and underdeveloped countries....
19 Pages (4750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us