StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Definition of Art - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the article, "Aesthetic Definition of Art" Monroe Beardsley describes unique philosophy of art and its meaning for a modern man. Monroe Beardsley states that modern art has eschewed the representation of people, things, and events. Modern art does not offer us pictures of triumphant generals, but rather color fields…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsleys Aesthetic Definition of Art
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Definition of Art"

Download file to see previous pages

The paper will review the min concepts and definitions of art proposed by Monroe Beardsley, and then, critically review the proposed concepts. In this, its ultimate role is to provide a critique of its own conditions of possibility. And, as is well known, for Beardsley this became a matter of artists acknowledging the flatness of the picture plane as a way of asserting what they took to be the essential fact about the nature of painting. Beardsley defines artwork as: "something produced with the intension of giving it the capacity to satisfy the authentic interest" (Beardsley 57).

Beardsley has in mind such audience responses as noticing details, recognizing patterns, making interpretations, filling in the work, etc (Beardsley 55). It is against this understanding of avant-garde art, the genuine art of the contemporary world, that Beardsley articulates his understanding of modern art. Avant-garde art is abstract, whereas modern art ostensibly favors representation. Avant-garde art is reflexive, whereas modern art is generally imitative. Avant-garde art is introverted -- it is about itself (it is about its medium).

Modern art is extroverted; it is about the world. Moreover, in being introverted, avant-garde art is detached from practical affairs and disinterested, whereas by representing the world, modern art is implicated in practical concerns (Beardsley 55). In order to accomplish this, genuine art must be difficult, whereas Beardsley believes that modern art can be enjoyed without effort. Moreover, this emphasis on the active response of the spectator in genuine art is what leads Beardsley to nominate avant-garde art as the genuine art of our times, since avant-garde art requires an active spectator to fill in its open structures.

Thus, avant-garde art can be said to preserve the central value of art properly so-called. For art properly so-called has always been dedicated to engendering active spectatorship. Indeed, commitment to this role, it would appear, is a necessary feature of art for Beardsley, as it is for many other modern theorists of art. On the other hand, Beardsley maintains that art involves 'unreflective enjoyment'. It abets passive spectatorship -- of the sort putatively evinced by 'couch potatoes' -- whereas Beardsley, with the authority of a long tradition behind him, presumes that a necessary feature of genuine art involves a commitment to active vowing (Beardsley 56).

Avant-garde art accords with this profile. In order to appreciate it, a certain sort of knowledge and background information will have to come into play, if, for example, one is to identify the reflexive comment that an abstract array makes on the nature of painting. Beardsley argues: "once we know what things are artworks in a particular society, we can identify artistic activities by discovering which activities involve interaction with artworks" (Beardsley 57). To interpret such a work one must be initiated into a certain discourse and, even after one assimilates the relevant art discourse, a great deal of cogitation will still be required in order to apply that discourse with understanding to the painting at hand.

Such painting demands intellectual work from the spectator because of its hermetic structure, which serves as a difficult obstacle, or puzzle,

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Definition of Art Essay”, n.d.)
Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Definition of Art Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516431-philosophy-of-art-monroe-beardsleys-aesthetic-definition-of-art
(Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley'S Aesthetic Definition of Art Essay)
Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley'S Aesthetic Definition of Art Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516431-philosophy-of-art-monroe-beardsleys-aesthetic-definition-of-art.
“Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley'S Aesthetic Definition of Art Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1516431-philosophy-of-art-monroe-beardsleys-aesthetic-definition-of-art.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophy of Art Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Definition of Art

The Philosophy of Art

From being delineated to the definition of the philosophy of art, subsequent years yielded focus on its value and experience in relation to the aesthetic attitudes.... The philosopher Immanuel Kant was the first to give a more thorough discussion of what the philosophy of art is.... If someone sees something beautiful and takes pleasure from, then, shares this with another person is the full circle of the philosophy of art.... But Kant is quick to add that not every piece of art contains this....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Art & Eight Different Kinds of Art

Name Tutor Institution Subject Code Abstract There have been different opinions by philosophers on the precise definition of art and as varied as they may be, each definition provides an explanation as to what art is or is supposed to be.... definition of art According to George Dickie (1956), art in the classificatory sense is an abstract or a collection of pieces of which are meant for appreciation by a person or individuals acting on their own behalf or that of an institution....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Plato and a More Definitive Understanding of Art and Philosophy

The ultimate purpose for referencing the third right within this understanding of Plato's virtuous end good definition of art is with respect to the fact appointed to the ultimate subjectivity that a society and/or an individual may ascribe with regards to the way that art can and should look.... Another noted shortcoming with regards to Plato's definition of art/philosophy and the means by which it should be integrated with the populace is with respect to the fact that he denotes that those who merely seek the reflections of the forms and not for themselves are not artists....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Aesthetics- Philosophy of Art

The above discussion brings us to compare art with emotions, the reason why identifications with artists and imaginative participation in experiences and emotions are available to us is that works of art are made things, products or instances of human action.... The understanding of art is much related to exploring, to understand art critically is to explore it imaginatively, guided by a range of relevant... Beautiful objects of nature or art engage our attention....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Changes in the Definition of Art

In the paper “Changes in the definition of art” the author describes how the very definition of art has changed over the last 100 years, using specific examples to describe that change.... It is obvious that the definition of art has changed substantially over the last 100 years with the wide proliferation of museums, galleries, biennales, fairs, etc.... hellip; The author of the essay states that primarily the concept of 'art' notes the historical changes of forms and types of cultures, their interactions, and is determined by the nature of philosophy, art history, artistic and poetic reflection; and to date it is a multidimensional meaningful education....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Exploring the Idea of Art

According to Lazzari and Schlesier (2011), no definition of art is absolute or timeless.... According to the definition of art provided by Dickie, any piece or work of art which is displayed or presented in places like museums, theatres etc is a piece of art.... In this assignment, we will discuss the institutional theory of art, conservative views, art… For some individuals art is the creation of a beautiful masterpiece which looks beautiful....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Aesthetic Ideas According to Kant

The idea of functionality is also predominant in the second indicated objective of Kant's philosophy of art that is to differentiate art from craft.... These ideas are, as he argues, vital in clarifying how we observe works of art, as they facilitate between These ideas pursue to estimate to a demonstration of cogent ideas (Makkreel, 1990).... According to Makkreel (1990), by Critique of the Power of Judgment, he demanded that a work of art is a media by which an artist may express such an idea, a notion that may not immediately be intelligible....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Entertainment and Sports of Classical Greece: the Philosophies and the Religious Center

This was combined with philosophies of how to reach perfection, all which were defined in the several arts that were a part of the Classical Greek definition of culture.... Each of the areas of entertainment, such as art, literature, and sports were to demonstrate the concept of the Greek gods and goddesses as well as the way of living that was pertinent to this particular set of concepts and philosophies.... “Greek art [is] considered as a reflection of the ideals which dominated Greek life from time to time....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us