StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Flannery O'Connor's Misfit and the Mystery of Evil - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Flannery O'Connor's Misfit and the Mystery of Evil" focuses on short stories that use the element of individual versus the individual in a mostly similar manner. The most evident expression of individualism is with the way both the writers symbolically name their characters…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Flannery OConnors Misfit and the Mystery of Evil
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Flannery O'Connor's Misfit and the Mystery of Evil"

Literary Analysis Avia Brown Ashford February 7, ENG 125 Introduction to Literature Angela di Gualco Introduction Normally people will be different with each one exhibiting their individuality. Although, individuals could share certain characteristics with others, most of the time, they will be distinct with not only different physical attributes but also unique thought processes. So, when these individuals interact with others, it can sometimes lead to conflicts in certain situations. That is, although these types of interactions do not always lead to conflicts, there are possibilities, especially when there are interactions between a gullible woman and a scheming man. As both the woman and the man interact with each other based on their own individualistic mindset and motivations, chances of conflicts increases. This aspect of individualism-based conflict is visible in the short stories “Good Country People” by Flannery O’Connor and “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates. In “Good Country People”, the character of Joy or Hulga trusts and interacts with a shady bible salesman named Manley Painter, but because of their different individualistic motivations, their short-lived interactions ends heartbreakingly for Joy. On the same lines, in “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been”, female protagonist Connie’s interactions with a dubious man named Arnold Friend takes a dangerous turn because of their different individualistic motivations. So, both these short stories will be compared and contrasted focusing on the above-discussed individualism-based conflicts using the literary techniques of symbolism, tone, and irony. Symbolism The differing personalities and the resultant conflict between the characters or individuals in both the stories can be understood by focusing on the names of the characters. Character names have clear symbolic connotations. That is, both the authors have named their characters to symbolically highlight their personality, individualism, and motivations, and how it leads to conflicts. In “Good Country People”, author O’Connor has named the female protagonist first as Joy, but makes her legally change the name to Hulga. Although, her mother Mrs. Hopewell named her as Joy with the wish that she would live a joyful life, her accident and the loss of her leg forces Joy to change her name to Hulga. That is, she felt that she has become an unattractive or even an ugly individual and for that reason has chosen an ugly sounding name. “…she had hit upon the ugliest name in any language” (O’Connor, 2009). This form of self-pity is imbibed in her personality and so it is used to symbolically denote her individualistic personality. As far as the name of Manley Pointer is concerned, Manley or manly denotes the negative depths to which “mankind” could descend to fulfill their dubious wishes, even to the detriment of innocent individuals. As Manley removes physically-challenged Hulga’s wooden leg and abandons in a barn, it reflects the extreme lengths this man or Manley could go. So, although, Hulga interacts with Manley trusting him and loving him, Manley’s deceiving mindset leads to conflict between these two individuals. On the same lines, in “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been”, the character of Connie is seems to be named so because she is the one who is conned by an individual named Arnold Friend. Although, like a typical teenager, she believes that she is in control of most situations, she is conned and pressurized by Friend. As far as the name, Arnold Friend is concerned; Oates has used this name to imply that although he may appear to be a friend, actually he is not. This aspect is sensed by Connie but she did not do anything about it. “She looked at the name, Arnold Friend. She looked at it for a while as if the words meant something to her that she did not yet know” (Oates, 1994, pg.36). He befriends Connie with ulterior motives that are revealed when he takes advantage of her and corners her. He does something a friend should not do, and passes as a devilish person who besides taking away a young girl’s innocence, also forces her to abandon her parents. Although Connie wanted to have an innocent romantic fling with Friend, his motivation to threaten and exploit her makes their interaction dangerous and conflicting. So, it is obvious that in both the stories the individuals or characters’ differing individualism and personality is symbolically reflected in their names, and that differing individualism leads to conflict. Tone The tone exhibited or maintained in both the short stories by the respective authors not only reflects the personality and individualism of the characters, but also how their interactions turn into a conflicting one. In the case of “Good Country People”, the tone that is predominant is satirical with traces of tragedy towards the end. The satirical tone is visible even in the title of the short story. That is, it is assumed that people from the country side or rural areas, particularly ones with religious affiliations, are always good, who do not indulge in dubious activities. However, in line with this sardonic tone, Manley Painter despite being portrayed as a bible selling salesman who appears to be a good individual, is actually an immoral and deceiving individual who exploits and abandons Hulga. So, Manley is portrayed as a bible man on one hand and a con artist on the other. This implies that people from certain background are stereotypically viewed as good without checking their antecedents and activities. Then, when it comes to Hulga, although she is a PhD holder, she was easily hoodwinked and entrapped by a con artist. This clearly shows that the perception that well-educated are always smart and cannot be deceived may not hold true in all situations. This satirical tone takes a slightly tragic tone when the trusting Hulga is abandoned by Manley in the barn without any support. So, the satirical plus tragic tone is in line with the differing individualism of both the characters, with each character’s negative attribute being satirically reflected and how that attribute leads to conflicts between the two. As far as “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” is concerned, in contrast to the above story, the tone is mainly innocent and sympathetic with tragic tone being visible towards the end. As the story is told from Connie’s viewpoint, the tone is wholly sympathetic towards her and generally explores her feeling and thoughts. Being the protagonist, the writer in a sense maintains her liking affection for Connie, even when criticizing the superficial nature of Connie’s romantic notions. The tone of Connie’s vivid and sensual daydreaming is in contrast to the dismissive tone that her mother takes towards those fantasies. Then, in the final parts, the tone takes a serious turn with the threat of escalation of violence when Connie encounters Arnold. So, it is obvious that the differing tone reflects the characters’ different individualism and mindset, which in a way ends in a conflicting situation. Irony Certain ironical aspects in both the stories also bring into focus the individualism based conflict between the characters. As above-mentioned, although Mrs. Hopewell named her daughter as Joy, it turned out be ironical because she is not at all joyful. “Hulga Hopewell in "Good Country People," whose chosen ugly name "Hulga" serves as her defense against admitting her ordinary human frailty and need, as well as being a badge of her pride” (Desmond, 2004, pg. 134). On similar lines, Manley masqueraded as a bible seller but at the end of it, he turns about to be a deceiving individual. In addition, he is initially shown as a good country folk only to be revealed as a bogus individual who even hides whiskey, condoms, and other items in his supposed bible. Furthermore, it becomes clear that he does not even believe in anything, even in the God. “I been believing in nothing ever since I was born” (O’Connor, 2009). As discussed earlier, even the title “Good Country People” is also ironic, because the people are full of deceit and are willing to trample on each other’s rights and state of being for their own ends, which in a way result in conflicts. In “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” also, ironical aspects are visible in relation to the two key characters of Connie and Arnold Friend. In the case of Connie, it is ironic that she herself invites Friend without knowing that she is going to become a victim. That is, when Friend comes calling, she is at the home day dreaming about boys and having relationship with them. However, when she finds out Friend’s intimidating tactics, she ironically understands that he is not the one whom she is daydreaming. “Oatess teenage protagonist, Connie, discovers that her dream love-god also wears the face of lust, evil, and death” (Wegs, 1975, pg. 66). So, in both the works, it is evident that certain ironical aspects brings out the dubious personality or motivations of the male characters thereby leading to conflicts Conclusion Both the short stories use the element of individual versus individual in mostly similar manner, with certain exceptions. The most evident expression of individualism and the resultant conflicts is with the way both the writers symbolically name their characters. Then, when it comes to the tone of the works, there are some differences with “Good Country People” exhibiting a satirical and tragic tone while “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” reflecting a sympathetic, innocent, and tragic tone. As far as irony is concerned, both the works are replete with number of ironical aspects, which showcases the mindset and individualism of the key characters. So, it is obvious that both the works had characters who exhibited individualism with dubious motivations, leading to conflicts. References Desmond, J. (2004). Flannery OConnors misfit and the mystery of evil. Renascence, 56 (2): 129-137. Oates, J. C. (1994). Where are you going, where have you been? Rutgers University Press OConnor, F. (2009). Flannery OConnor Complete Stories. Z. El Bey Wegs, J. M. (1975). “Dont you know who I am?: The grotesque in Oatess where are you going, where have you been?” The Journal of Narrative Technique, 5 (1): 66-72 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Literary Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1676703-literary-analysis
(Literary Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1676703-literary-analysis.
“Literary Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1676703-literary-analysis.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Flannery O'Connor's Misfit and the Mystery of Evil

Flannery O'Connors Literature Work

Lytle was the first person to criticized o'connor's essays (Wood 01).... The comments and critic of her work by senior editors helped in developing o'connor's literature works especially in writing style and plot development.... Despite o'connor's sheltered life, her literature work especially her writing reveals an uncanny gasp that concentrates on the nuance of human behavior.... Notably, these literatures were never friendly to the unsuspecting readers since the stories subjected them to disturbing repercussion of tense fiction that formed the main structures of o'connor's writings (Desmond 01)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Reflections of observing a self serving life

These characters represent a kind of evil threat placed to test a characters religious obedience.... hroughout the story, the grandmother is described as a pessimistic, selfish, and devious woman As the misfit and his cohorts begin to murder the Grandmother's family, the Grandmother begins to plead with the Misfit, using religion as a way to try and convince the Misfit to spare her life.... flannery o'connor's story, "A Good Man is Hard to Find" brings to light,the author's opinion that faith can blind individuals from the truth....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

The Fabric of Characterization, Theme, and Setting in A Good Man Is Hard to Find

In the following analysis let us look at the dynamics of characterization, theme, and setting in flannery o'connor's A Good Man Is Hard to Find.... These words are definitely not to influence the killer against shooting her but it is her saving moment of grace where she realizes the hollowness of her hitherto existence and recognizes the misfit as the medium of grace.... Frederick Asals in his Introduction to the book A Good Man Is Hard to Find: flannery O'Connor notes the story 'was established for long enough to remain the single tale most immediately associated with flannery O'Connor' (4)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

A Good Man Is Hard to Find: The Misfit as a Reactive Criminal and a Lost Prophet

This research paper "A Good Man Is Hard to Find: The misfit as a Reactive Criminal and a Lost Prophet" discusses the misfit as a wanted criminal, who chances upon a family when they crash their family car in the woods.... The misfit has a moral code, and so he orders the family executed.... The misfit constantly questions the meaning of life and his role in it.... He renames himself as the misfit as a consequence of his belief that his punishment did not fit his crime....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Flannery OConner Biography

The author of this essay "flannery O'Conner Biography" touches upon the biography of flannery O'Conner.... It is mentioned that flannery O'Conner is an American writer renowned for writing riveting stories that captured society during her time.... flannery's life as a writer was very eventful and comprised of numerous literary works that earned her fame.... The New York Times positively reviewed flannery's novel and this paved the way for later success....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

A Good Man is Hard to Find by Mary Flannery OConnor

Mary flannery O'Connor published “A Good Man is Hard to Find” in the year 1953 by flannery O'Connor.... It was a part of a collection with a similar name;A Good Man is flannery's second published work, the group established a major voice in American literature mainly Southern literature, up to the time she died in 1964, at the age of 39.... flannery's novels were viewed as critically less fortunate.... According to (Fitzgerald 90)flannery said that the stories she had written were hard since there is nothing difficult or less sentimental than Christian realism....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

A Good Man is Hard to Find and The Life You Save May Be Your Own written by Flannery OConnor

Each of these stories also features a battle between guilt and innocence, as this guilt if often represented by the evil actions of the characters.... Also, even as her family was being murdered, the Grandmother appears to be more concerned with her own safety, pleading for 'The misfit' to spare her life and many will be 'appalled by a calculating opportunist who is capable of embracing her family's murderer, to save her own skin' (Bandy 2).... In the end, she attempts to touch her killer, possibly as a last-ditch effort at saving her own life, but also possibly as a symbol of finally reaching personal enlightenment, just moments before her death, as 'critics like to interpret the moment that the grandmother reaches out her hand towards 'The misfit' as a moment of grace, and thus conclude that this gesture will become an epiphany that leads The misfit upward to God's grace....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Flannery OConnors A Good Man is Hard to Find

The tragic encounter between the misfit and the unfortunate family represents O' Connor's illustration of the disturbance in societies reflected through the uncontrolled and instinctive reaction of the Misfit.... " flannery o'connor's A Good Man is Hard to Find" paper focuses on the short story that raises moral and behavioral issues in society.... In a society where innocent people can be sent to jail or killed, a true subversion of values prevails, and evil reigns....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us