StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Thomas Nagel wrote in his essay, “What Is It Like to be a Bat?” about the concepts of reduced mean, consciousness, and physicalism. After exploring his essay and a discussion of the topic, I shall attempt to explain in my own words the meaning of these terms…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel"

Download file to see previous pages

Thomas Nagel wrote in his essay, “What Is It Like to be a Bat?” about the concepts of reduced mean, consciousness, and physicalism. After exploring his essay and a discussion of the topic, I shall attempt to explain in my own words the meaning of these terms. I will define his terms in his words and mine, giving examples from his writing. I will conclude with my understanding of the next step of Nagel’s thought, “What does this mean in my life?” Reduced Mean For something to be reduced, to be made less than what it begins, we must use “reductionism,” a presenting problem for Nagel.

Nagel says, reducing is to be “based on an analysis of what is to be reduced. If the analysis leaves something out, the problem will be falsely posed.” (158) Subjective viewpoint says that all of these descriptors are components necessary to be like something, for example, what we need to be “like a bat.” We need to take all factors into consideration, the physical properties, the mental characteristics, the mode of reasoning, the essence and “is-ness” of it, but when we reduce these properties in an objective viewpoint, we have lost the ability to “be like.

” Not having a completeness of all factors reduces the experience and essence, therefore eliminating the complete knowledge of what is. Without the complete knowledge, we cannot perceive the phenomena of being. Consciousness For Thomas Nagel, for something to be conscious, to have consciousness, is to be like one in all aspects of being. To be a bat, for example, would mean to think like a bat, feel like a bat, and have all the physical characteristics of the bat, to consume like a bat, to experience like a bat, to inhale and exhale like a bat, to be the total essence of “like a bat”.

However, as we cannot truly transform ourselves into a bat, we cannot “be a bat.” Likeness is not the same as “is-ness”. Nagel stated, “but no matter how the forms may vary, the fact that an organism has conscious experience at all means, basically, that there is something it is like to be that organism.” (155) We can imagine through our own consciousness what is similar to being a bat, we can try being blind and depending on our ears, we can imagine what it is like to fly with wings, we can become nocturnal creatures, but we are still using our imaginary skills and not creating a consciousness of “bat-ism”.

We are being subjective observers, using our logic and reason, imagination and creativity to discern what we think a bat would be. Even when we use all resources available to our creative mind, we cannot, however, become another being, although that would be true consciousness to Nagel. We are limited by our imagination and consciousness of who we are, and therefore, cannot be someone else. Physicalism Nagel argues that on the grounds of “physicalism” we cannot really know, physicalism is still too inexact.

We can change our appearance, we can explain the physical-ness of being a bat, we can explain how sonar works and what bat ears look like, but we cannot tell subjectively what it is to be a bat. We cannot explain the essence of “bat-ness,” because we are not bats. We cannot tell from the objective and physical point of view the consciousness of that bat. Nagel posits, “At the present time the status of physicalism is similar to that which the hypothesis that matter is energy would have had if uttered by a pre-Socratic philosopher.

We do not have the beginnings of a conception of how it might be true.” (160) As we describe “physical-ness” from a third person point of view, objective, we can not combine them with the first point of view, subjective, and be complete. To have all the physical characteristics is still not “knowing” in the subjective. Conclusion Nagel’s concepts are somewhat difficult to discuss, quite like his dilemma with consciousness. They are more a subjective, “be” type knowledge. Standing on the outside, with the objective view, Nagel appears to use the same words over and

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1422332-what-is-it-like-to-be-a-bat
(What Is It Like to Be a Bat by Thomas Nagel Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1422332-what-is-it-like-to-be-a-bat.
“What Is It Like to Be a Bat by Thomas Nagel Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1422332-what-is-it-like-to-be-a-bat.
  • Cited: 2 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel

Philosophy of Death

As of Epicurus, this is true in case of adults as well, but the priorities and beliefs of adults are much more sophisticated in relevancy of the matter that what will bring them pleasure.... Alternatively, one should determine what lies in one's deep-rooted presumption in terms of pleasure.... Moreover, what will compel pleasure in the short-term if doing so will conclusively influence an advance state pleasure, which will last long....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Nagels Bat Argument

In the piece, he points to the phenomenal experience of a bat and that to understand its subjective experience we must have something in… The present analysis of Nagel's main points hopes only to reconstruct and support this claim by raising a couple of challenges.... a bat, for instance, perceives its environment entirely different from how a human being would and given that there is something that the bat subjectively experiences there seems to be some ontological closure for the human mind to some facts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

What is it like to be a bat by thomas nagel

What is it like to be a Bat by Thomas Nagel In the article, Nagel believes among all the current philosophical views to shed life on consciousness; reductionism is the worse.... Nagel makes a valuable argument when he states it almost impossible understanding another organisms perspective, for instance, a bat (Nagel, 111).... Nagel makes a valuable argument when he states it almost impossible understanding another organisms perspective, for instance, a bat (Nagel, 111)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Thomas nagel

In his article, ‘what is it like to be a bat?... In his bat view, a human being cannot know how it is like to be a bat due to limiting mind resources in imagination.... The theory determines the function of something while relating to behavior, other mental state and stimulation to get the mental state thomas nagel Q1 Functionalism theory is a doctrine that suggests what forms mental of something depends on the function or role it plays in the cognitive system that it forms and not on the constitution of the material....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Can choose from three

Nagel chose the example of a bat to validate his information because of many things.... The aim of nagel is to counter the physicians view and arguments that reduce mental to merely physical.... Most people had been convinced… Moreover, nagel wanted to bring a new dimension of subjectivism in a dominated field where everyone talks about objectivism in physical According to nagel, reductive arguments seek to explain a phenomenon in terms of objectivism hence it omits the essential of the conscious experience, which are subjective....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Analysis on Humans and Animals

Thomas Nagel in his article “What is like to be a bat?... rdquo; draws parallels between a man and a bat.... Following the idea expressed by Costello, who is an imaginative character of the novelist from the book by John Coetzee, we'll develop her idea basing on works by Locke, Wallace, and nagel.... nagel underlines that consciousness is presented in animals as well as in humans.... In accordance with the scientist, bats are closely related to humans (nagel, p45)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Thomas Nagel and Aristotles Account of the Mind-body Problem

This work "thomas nagel and Aristotle's Account of the Mind-body Problem" describes the knowledge about soul and mind.... Nagel further states that even if we evolve or try to imagine a bat, we would never feel the experience of a bat.... Such is because we do not possess the internal physiological composition as that of a bat.... The author outlines nagel and Aristotle's account according to how each has conceptualized the mind-body problem....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Relationship Between the Mind and the Brain

In the article, “what is it like to be a bat?... The knowledge they have limits them to know how it feels like to be a bat.... He argues that not all facts are physical facts because even if we know all the physical facts about love, we will not know beforehand what it is like to be in love.... rdquo; thomas nagel used a bat as an example to illustrate the fact that even if human beings have all the knowledge on how bats use their abilities it doesn't mean that they will be able to view the environment and the world at large from a bat's point of view....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us