StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gender Based Violence, Police Behavior and the Court System - Research Paper Example

Summary
"Gender-Based Violence, Police Behavior, and the Court System" paper evaluates the notion of how crime is gendered. Furthermore, the paper analyzes how gender influences a better understanding of various theoretical lenses and the implications of the notion to the dimension and scope of criminology…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Gender Based Violence, Police Behavior and the Court System"

Name : xxxxxxxxxxx Institution : xxxxxxxxxxx Title : xxxxxxxxxxx Tutor : xxxxxxxxxxx Course : xxxxxxxxxxx @2010 Introduction In several ways, crime has commonly taken the dimension of gender whether openly or silently. This is confirmed by the dominant fact that one gender is majorly known to be the perpetrators of certain crimes while another is on the receiving end. Gender can be described as a social construction which shapes human behavior in every arena of life, and crime evidently is no exception. This particular paper therefore seeks to evaluate notion of how crime in gendered. Furthermore the paper will analyze how gender influences better understanding of various theoretical lenses and the implications of the notion to the dimension and scope of criminology. Gabbidon & Taylor (2005) highlight that crime has for many years been gendered, this has been advanced by numerous findings and theoretical insights and yet numerous gaps still exist. When taking a look at gender based violence for instance, an emerging area of study in the domain of human security. What is evident is that it has been given a limited perspective with much concentration on violence against women and girls and majorly sexual violence (Morash, 2006). Taking a broader view, we realize that men are also victims of gender –based crimes. They face gender based violence such as sexual assaults, forced recruitment into armies and gender selective massacre. Morsh,(2006) argues that agencies responsible for human security should realize that men equally need protection from such violence meted on them, just because they are of the masculine gender, does not mean that they can entirely defend themselves from such crimes. For instance, officially most research findings reveal that women are underrepresented in violent crimes. On the other hand sexual violence and abuse of men by women is usually overlooked and not given much attention. A considerably large number of men abused by women generally fail to report their ordeals due several personal factors and the shame that stems from the fact that the society deems it as ‘a mockery’ to manhood(Zaplin,2007).A personal safety survey curried out by the (ABS) Australian Bureau of Statistics (2009) estimated that 19/100 females subject to sexual assault managed to report their misfortune to the police, while men sexually assaulted by women rarely report the cases. It can also be argued that violent crime has also been gendered due to police behavior. Crutchfield (2000) argues that police decisions to arrest are in most cases influenced by factors that are extralegal, gender being one of the major factors. It is however unclear how gender alone or in conjunction with other factors may consciously influences police behavior to arrest, however the crime type essentially violent crimes directs the police to one particular gender; the male offender. A study undertaken by Tibbetts and Hemmens (2009) to make a comparison of the probability of juvenile male and female arrests by police after a reported incident indicated that police arrests and contact of the male offenders is more likely as opposed to the female. Also, a survey by the Australian Bureau of Statistics in three states between the years 1995-2005, indicated that male offenders were highly arrested for violent crimes as opposed to the female. Figure I below highlights arrests in terms of gender 1995-96 to 2004-05 Figure 1 Arrests In terms of Gender Between 1995-96 to 2004-05 In Queensland, Victoria, and South Australia there was a total of 162,055 offenders, whereby 126,776 were male and 35,279 were female. 21% of all offenders were female while the rest were male. Walklate (2004) argues that the organization of gender which entails differences between men and women in terms of physically differences and differences in terms of norms are major factors that influence more male police arrests as opposed to female arrests. The Police level is not the only juncture in the process of criminal justice that gender considerations are not enforced. Also at the courts level, crime is usually influenced by the aspect of gender. Crutchfield (2000) brings to light the fact that women have been given treatment that is more lenient in the early stages of court proceedings, for instance women are offered cash alternatives as opposed to bail .Furthermore variations in sentencing also occur in circumstances whereby women are given lighter sentences as opposed to the men even when both parties are involved in the same violent crimes. In most cases women are mostly given harsh sentences when they take part in non-traditional female crimes like assault or when they violate female sexual norms. When making an evaluation of the arguments raised above, an outstanding factor arises that indeed the concept of gender does matter in criminology. Various theoretical lenses have over the years being constructed for the basic purpose of explaining the integration of the concept of gender into criminology. Gender therefore greatly matters in the understanding of the various theoretical lenses. Feminism is one of the recent theoretical lenses grounded on the fact that gender is a social construction that is produced and further reproduced due to social interaction (Rafter & Heidensohn, 1995) .The Feminist view points propose two factors that influence the integration of the concept of gender into crime. One of the aspects is female nurturance and expectations which describes socially constructed attributes of the female gender. Women are naturally constructed to maintain relationships and build the family as a result illicit endeavors such as engaging in criminal activities are not part of their gender constructed roles. Also women are always required to be beautiful and to maintain sexual virtue thus engaging in crime becomes a rare attribute for the female gender. On the other hand the hegemonic roles given to men of caring for the family and enhancing family security , exposes men to higher chances of criminal activity (Gabbidon & Taylor 2005). Feminist view points have greatly influenced the development of criminology as a discipline. Feminists argue that criminology just like other social sciences is shaped by male experiences. This is essentially because the study of criminology is grounded on core general theories of crime which do not take in to account of female experiences. For instance radical feminist have reconstructed the way in which rape is perceived, whereby rather then being seen as a violent sexual crime it is viewed as male control, power and domination (Tibbetts & Hemmens 2009). Critics of feminism however argue that criminology as discipline and area of practice has been to a great extent indifferent to the role of women in crime. Many assumptions using feministic view points are made based on a biased belief that men are autonomous, intelligent and with a force in character hence are more likely to engage in crime, while women are weak, passive and compliant hence less likely to engage in crime. This has been responsible for the lack of detailed study into women’s role in crime (Tibbetts & Hemmens 2009). Masculinity is another theoretical lens that proposes that the criminal behavior of men is purported by their masculine nature. Messerschmidt (1993) argues that masculine attributes such as aggressiveness, violence and roughness were internalized in boys even during adolescence, which basically leads them to being more diligent as opposed to girls. Common masculine characteristics such as dominance and toughness are perceived as vital in order for a man to possess a strong masculine reputation (Connell1995). Messerschmidt, (1993) further argues that for a man, violent situations boost their masculinity; men are considered violent if they fight for themselves as a result the practice of violent crime is just a measure of how masculine a man is. The Masculinity view point has contributed to the development of criminology as a discipline in the sense that criminologists have attempted to utilize the concept of hegemonic masculinity to give explanations concerning the criminal behavior of men and also to give reasons why men are in most cases victimized by the criminal justice system. Kersten (1993) highlights that; at one level criminology as a discipline has been developed through a conceptual framework, which mostly describes the hegemony of men .The issue of masculinity, therefore forms the center stage in the academia of criminology, resulting to a situation whereby everything concerning crime is explicable by reference to the aspect of masculinity. Intersectionality is another approach that provides understanding of how gender is related to crime. The approach recognizes the fact that systems of power such as gender, class and race do not act alone to shape peoples experiences but rather they are simultaneous experienced and multiplicatively linked. Tibbetts and Hemmens (2009) observe that the use of the Intersectionality approach to study crime basically explores how the three attributes of inequality class, race and gender put certain members of society at risk to be rendered deviant or rather to engage in activities that result to breaking the law. The discourse of Intersectionality has had an effect on the development criminology as a discipline. The fact that Intersectionality exists across varies themes such as race , gender and class, assists the study of criminology to develop a broad approach, through making the assumption that crime is not entirely gendered, and that other factors such as race and class also influence criminal activity. It is also essential to take note of the fact that feminist criminologists also acknowledge the need for intersectionalaity in the study of criminology. Conclusion From the analysis above what is evident is that crime is basically an aspect that is influenced by gender in a variety of ways. The paper has highlighted three arenas; gender based violence, police behavior and the court system. Gender as a socially constructed phenomenon has also influenced various theoretical lenses that are used in the discipline of criminology. Theoretical lenses such as feminism, masculinity and Intersectionality, do acknowledge the fact that gender does influence the criminology and crime in general. It is however essential to take note of the fact that further research should be undertaken in order to fully verify this particular notion. References Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2009, 2002-2005. Population by age and sex, Australian states and territories (various issues). ABS cat. no. 3201.0. Canberra: ABS Retrieved Crutchfield, D, 2000,Crime, Pine Forge Press, 2000 Connell, R.W. (1995) Masculinities, Sydney: Allen and Unwin. Kersten, J, 1993. “Crime and Masculinities in Australia, Germany and Japan.” International Sociology 8:461-478 Gabbidon, S & Taylor,G,2005,Race, crime, gender and justice, Routledge Morash,M,2006, Understanding gender, crime, and justice, SAGE. Messerschmidt, J. 1993,Masculinities and Crime: Critique and Reconceptuatlization of Theory: Rowan & Littlefield Publishers, I Rafter, N. & Heidensohn, F, 1995, International Feminist Perspectives in Criminology Open Uni Press, Buckingham. Tibbetts , S & Hemmens,C,2009, Criminological Theory, SAGE. Walklate, S (2004) Gender, Crime and Criminal Justice Willan, Cullompton, UK. Zaplin,T,2007, The female offenders: critical perspective and effective interventions, Jones & Bartlett Learning. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gender Based Violence, Police Behavior and the Court System

Domestic Violence Issues

Abuse by any other name: Feminism, difference and intralesbian violence' in The Public Nature of Private violence: The Discovery of Domestic Abuse, eds M.... the manifestations of violence within what should be a loving relationship to fully understand the horror to which victims are subjected and the need for adequate protection to be provided by both the civil and the criminal justice systems.... erpetrators and Victims Domestic violence is conceived of primarily as a problem of men's abuse of women....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Violence against Women

From the perspective of Mill's personal trouble, violence is characterized by a systemic pattern of behavior (rather than isolated acts of violence) that establishes dominance over another person typically through intimidation, coercion, isolation, and terror-inducing violence and threats of violence (Dutton & Goodman, 2005:748).... The paper under the title 'violence against Women' presents violence against women which is considered an important social dilemma because of about a quarter of all women in the United States continuously 'experienced rape, physical assault, and stalking'....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Law Enforcement Agencies and the Judicial System

The following presentation will demonstrate how discrimination is used in the judicial system and law enforcement agencies in the aspects of race, gender, social institutions, or groups, employment opportunities, gender and judicial punishment and sentencing.... According to the study findings police departments and courts or judicial officers where discrimination is carried out without remorse or fear of the resultant effects.... s the discussion stresses systematic racism entangles police office where young black officers are on the receiving end....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Gender and Crime: Gender Policing

he criminal justice system has the mandate to make policies regarding crimes and criminal behavior and the people it directly affects which in this case are policemen and policewomen.... here is a widespread failure by policemen to protect women from gender-based violence.... The system can not always provide an objective review or judgment of the case and hence the women lack justice despite the heinous acts committed onto them by these men....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Criminal Law on the Side of Domestic Abuse Victims

Early concern focused on wife-beating but attention is now directed at a broader range of behavior.... For example, Hester and Radford identify 'a range of abusive behaviors' such as 'emotional cruelty, controlling and demeaning behavior including withholding of money, attempts at strangulation and threats to kill.... The behavior that is commonly called domestic violence can take on the variety of different aspects.... The paper 'Criminal Law on the Side of Domestic Abuse Victims' reports that more victims of domestic violence do not consider it shameful to seek the help of law enforcement agencies....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Criminal Justice System Interventions: Family Violence

This work called "Criminal Justice system Interventions: Family Violence" describes hegemonic masculinity in the context of family violence as well as the response of the criminal justice system to this phenomenon.... The author outlines the aspects of a feminist perspective, the problems of the criminal system.... he concept of hegemonic masculinity had an influence on the criminal justice system.... However, in this paper, hegemonic masculinity in the context of family violence, as well as the response of the criminal justice system to this phenomenon, will be discussed....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Toward a Gender-Neutral Policy: Protecting the Rights of Men

As the government moves ahead with a test program intended to better protect domestic violence victims, policy should reflect a more balanced approach to gender-based violence.... for which) individuals will use force and violence in their relationships with intimates and family members if they believe that the rewards of force and violence outweigh the costs of such behavior' (Jackson, 2007).... This paper proceeds from the understanding that domestic violence against men represents a far more pervasive problem that is reflected in government policy....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

System Thinking Is Critical in Developing Solutions to Sustainability Challenges

To achieve this positive result, experts have scrutinized domestic violence in the setting of the court system, measures to protect victims, prevention of vice reoccurrence, the vice impact on health, racial and minority effects among others (Stroh 2015).... The paper "system Thinking Is Critical in Developing Solutions to Sustainability Challenges" is a great example of a social science essay.... A system is an entity that consists of elements that interact with each other on an individual, local, or global level, to produce the desired result....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us