StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

American Criminal Justice System - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "American Criminal Justice System" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the American Criminal Justice system. Many observers have rightfully pointed out that the United States does not have a unified system of criminal justice…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
American Criminal Justice System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "American Criminal Justice System"

For instance, according to Article III of the constitution, it is the federal courts that are vested with the paramount judicial powers. And, Article III ensures both federalism and separation of powers by providing a mechanism for the Supreme Court to put forward guidelines for the lower courts. It is pointed out that “the Constitution does limit in important ways congressional power to shift ultimate judicial power from federal to state courts” (Amar, 271). Additionally, there are mechanisms such as “the case or controversy requirement, also called the “justiciability” doctrine, includes more specialized notions of ripeness, mootness, and standing to sue, and prohibits consideration of constitutional issues except as a necessary incident to the resolution of a concrete “case” or “controversy” (Brilmayer, 297).

Also, judicial precedent is one of the constitutional provisions for ensuring coherence in the praxis of criminal justice in the United States. The doctrine of judicial precedent in America is closely linked to other constitutional provisions such as the hierarchy of courts, separation of powers, judicial supremacy, and the ideology of judicial adjudication. The interpretative nature of judicial precedent is based on the fact that “judicial outcomes are fundamentally indeterminate” (Shapiro and Sweet, 122).

However, judicial precedent functions in all directions as all courts have to refer to each other decisions on criminal justice of similar type irrespective of the court hierarchy. It means that judicial precedents, in practice, “help judicial law-making -an intrinsically decentralized mode of governance- achieve a semblance of centralization and systematic coherence” (Shapiro and Sweet, 121). American federalism is deep and substantial as it allows an inherently heterogeneous legal system wherein state laws exist in competition with what is legal in the federal realm and other states.

American criminal justice system too is highly influenced by Montesquieu's ideas of division of powers. However, practicing the doctrine of the division of powers in the American context has become a division of institutions of criminal justice in the country and the separation of criminal justice systems in the states from each other and the federal system. However, coherence in the criminal justice system is achieved through the “established hierarchy of the courts and operates in such a way that generally, a court is bound by the ratio decidendi, or rule of law implicit in the decisions of a court above it in the hierarchy and usually by a court of equal standing in the hierarchy” (Slapper and Kelly, 3).

Green is of the view that since there is more emphasis on the protection of fundamental rights of “the defendants who are entitled to a range of elaborate procedural protections that apply regardless of the seriousness of the penalties they face”, the competing and overlapping organizational structure is not a hindrance (53). On the other hand, this institutional diversity and complexity help the best outcome in criminal justice cases.  However, such measures could be curtailed by some other grass root issues.

Perhaps, one may argue that victims’ rights are more vital to procedural protection than the rights of criminals as the “citizenry cannot be seen as a whole, rather, needs to be distinguished as victims and criminals” (Cartwright, 18). Such a distinction is important in understanding the issues of illegal immigrants like the battering of an illegal immigrant woman. 

Different states have different legal procedures to deal with gender violence against illegal immigrant women. Also, there is no consensus over whether we need to consider illegal immigrants on par with the citizens in terms of legal rights. The discourse on a federal health care system too is contested by the argument that it is an overreach on the state functions.

To conclude, it is possible to say that the fragmented nature of the American criminal justice system helps ensure the resilience of the federal setup, it constrains the system in tackling certain critical issues such as immigration and health care. And, many constitutional provisions such as Article III and judicial precedent enable the criminal justice system in practice to achieve high levels of cohesion.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Crimminal justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Crimminal justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1580288-crimminal-justice
(Crimminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Crimminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1580288-crimminal-justice.
“Crimminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1580288-crimminal-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF American Criminal Justice System

Discuss how the American criminal justice system has impacted the Black community, 1880-2011

Title of Paper: American Criminal Justice System and Its Impact on Black People Writer Name: Date: The present research paper sheds light on American Criminal Justice System and discusses its impact on people of Black community in America.... of Paper: American Criminal Justice System and Its Impact on Black People The present research paper sheds light on American Criminal Justice System and discusses its impact on people of Black community in America....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Problems in Criminal Justice

In the paper “Problems in Criminal Justice” the author analyzes the American Criminal Justice System functions with three components such as “the police, the courts and corrections”.... The American Criminal Justice System is based on the concept of free and fair trial.... Besides, they also must be provided with latest technological support to monitor, investigate and process criminal cases....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Minorities in the American Criminal Justice System

From the paper "The Minorities in the American Criminal Justice System" it is clear that racial discrimination is evident from the fact that blacks represent in excess of one-half of the prison population in the USA, whereas they make up only just 12% of the USA's population.... Despite the fact of the introduction of the 5th and 14th Amendments and the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, there exist racial inequalities in the American Criminal Justice System even today....
13 Pages (3250 words) Term Paper

Women and men serial killers; gender inequality on crime sentencing

There are many cases in which criminal justice system adopts double standards while analysing crimes of similar nature committed by different persons.... This paper analyses how gender inequality affect criminal justice system while dispersing punishments for similar crimes committed by males and females.... Even criminal.... Serial killing is one of the major criminal activities of modern era....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Torture in the American Criminal Justice System

This report "Torture in the American Criminal Justice System" presents torture in the American correctional system and traces its origins as well as details steps to eradicate it.... As a related subject matter, this paper also dwells on the American Criminal Justice System itself.... Indeed, american intelligence agencies, especially after the September 11 attacks on the World Trade Center had come up with a harrowing and systematic mode of torture that constitutes an all-out assault on the detainee's senses....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Operations of the American Criminal Justice System

The paper "Operations of the American Criminal Justice System" discusses that tough conditions must be set by the laws for the release of prisoners through detention, and this must be after consultations with various states and experts on parole policy.... Under the act, the courts, the police, and the department of correctional services are elements of the criminal justice system.... This paper focuses on the department of corrections as an element of the criminal justice system, and in doing so this paper discusses parole as an aspect of the corrective system....
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

Racial Discrimination In American Criminal Justice System

The paper presents racial discrimination in the USA criminal justice system.... There have been accusations in the pickles domain as well as the academia about the racism in the US criminal justice system.... On one hand, there is proof about the racial differences and inequalities in the justice system.... The justice system in any country, much more in the most democratic nation on earth (USA) is set to provide justice to all at all time....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Racism in American Criminal Justice System

The paper further addresses the issue of racial discrimination in the criminal justice system of the US.... Racism has been eliminated from American society when it comes to laws and other policies however authorities have been unable to eradicate it from the criminal justice system.... here statistics and a significant amount of research have indicated that more colored people are treated in an unjust manned by the criminal justice system, it needs to be understood that the treatment in such system affects greater population outside of it (Banks 87; Reiman n....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us