StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Response to by Karl Hostetler - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
Critical Response to Article. The article by Karl Hostetler (2005) on what constitutes “Good” Educational Research considers not only the academic quality of any research in this field, but also its connection with “a robust and justifiable conception of human well-being” (Hostetler, 2005, 16)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical Response to by Karl Hostetler"

Download file to see previous pages

This preamble marks the paper out as something a little different from the usual mainstream literature, and the impression of novelty is further enhanced by statements to the effect that researchers need to be playful and irreverent about serious subjects, and need to offend some people and annoy others. Hofstetler certainly practices what he preaches, since the article is full of provocative statements that could be taken as undermining the most fundamental values of academic research activity in most contemporary universities.

The key problem that Hostetler identifies is a tendency for education researchers to focus on how their work is done, rather than undertaking a deep analysis of what they are doing and why they are doing it. Analogies such as debating which way to investigate the effectiveness of thumbscrews (Hostetler, 2005, 16-17) or herding lemmings toward the cliff (Hostetler, 2005, 17) or even sticking students with cattle prods (Hostetler, 2005, 19) are somewhat ludicrous, but the point important: too many researchers do not reflect enough about the fundamental aim of education and how far their work helps of hinders people who might be affected at some later date by the outcomes of this research.

This line of argument flies in the face of standard notions of research which involve concepts such as objectivity and scientific rigor. Without the use of statistics and analytical methods, there would be very little beyond anecdotal evidence to inform policy making and practice. Hofstetler makes a valid point, but he overstates it with his deliberately “naughty” (Hofstetler, 2005, p. 17) examples, and he risks not being taken seriously by the vast majority of interested readers who are quite capable of combining scientific methods with careful ethical reflection, and see no necessary conflict between the two.

A second problem that Hostetler describes is that of definitions, for example the very different ways that the conception of “character” in school programs is constituted. Clearly there are quite fundamental variations in the ideologies that can underpin such notions, and Hostetler argues that this complexity is something that needs to be more fully taken into account by researchers. On this point the article is convincing, and certainly there is a case for more clarity in the way that abstract educational terminology is used, especially in government slogans and initiative titles.

Hofstetler speaks up for the particular student experiences that are hidden within the data of randomized trial procedures, for example, suggesting that some of the generalizing theories that researchers produce may contain within them actual harm to individual students, since minority results tend to be lost in the bigger picture. Hofstetler questions whether the trade-off is justified, and this is a commendable observation because it highlights the dilemma of that section of the school population with behavioural or learning disorders who are so often lost in the drive for overall quality improvements.

This article raises a number of valuable questions, and provides much material for reflection, but it is rather short on concrete answers to these questions. The conclusion which is reached is little more than a platitude expressing approval of the likes of Mahatma Gandhi, Mother Teresa and other moral giants of history and calling for a more

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article
(Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article.
“Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler

Article response paper

Article response Paper Name Institution Main Issues/Points Discussed in Article The authors of the article seek to bring out facts about third language (L3) acquisition.... In an effort to answer questions asked perennially, they analyse several theories fronted for the relevance of L3/Ln acquisition in adults....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Article response paper

Article response Paper Name Institution Main Issues/Points Discussed The article talks about the recognition of emotions in people's voices as they speak, regardless of the speaker's language.... In particular, the article talks about emotion recognition across cultural differences in people speaking different languages....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Article response paper

Article response Paper Huang, Jinyan.... (2009) "Factors affecting the assessment of ESL students' writing.... Main Issues/Points Discussed in Article The author of the article seeks to bring out facts related to factors affecting the assessment of ESL student's writing.... hellip; While making detailed discussion about the different questions asked from various platforms, he analyses several theories tendered on the subject of ESL student's writing....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

HIP HOP Dance (Article Responses)

Hip Hop Dance – Eventual Development Hip hops have been an inspiration to the recent disco beats which set the floors of the night clubs on fire.... The author Manali Oak brings in all elements related to hip hop culture in a short and informative article in the context of Afro-American culture....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Response to Article Questions

he reported information is not detailed enough and it fails to address a number of very critical issues, which leaves the leader in doubt on the accuracy of the information.... The article claims that flavonoids in cocoa might play a major role in regulating blood pressure or even preventing occurrence of ailments such as cancer, heart diseases as well as relieving aching… Additional claims in the article is the likelihood that cocoa could be effective in relieving migraines in human, just like it has done in research involving mice....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Tariffs for Cars in the USA and China

response to the acceleration of tariff on American-made sport utility vehicles and midsize and large cars.... According to the article, it was not only United States but even the Topic - Article response - China Yawns as U.... om/2012/07/07/business/global/china-response-mild-to-us-trade-complaint-on-cars....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Influence of L1 over L2 and L3 Acquisition

The article covers a study done whose main aim is to find out if L2(second language) has a greater impact on the L3(third language) lexicon of the learner/candidate who has attained a higher level of second language proficiency and also has had significant exposure to it.... The… dy focused on determining the different ways in which varying/different language systems interact in the mind and affect either the linguistic development, performance or both of the person/individual concerned....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Summary and Critical Response

The students conducting such part time jobs are Summary and critical response Summary In the article “Working At McDonald's” the Amitai Etzioni has highlighted the reality of working teenagers in different sectors like Mc Donald's, and Kentucky fried chicken among others in order to earn reasonable amount of money.... auer/engl1301/midterm-essay-exam-prompts-and-preparation/midterm-prompt-2-response-essay/midterm-prompt-2-response-essay-reading-1-working-at-mcdonalds Knuth, M....
2 Pages (500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us