StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper aims to analyze “The Robertson Foundation Case” in terms of its possible implications on fundraising and endowments in the future. The case would be evaluated based on the ethical context of fundraising.The Robertson Foundation Case exemplifies concerns fundraising and philanthropy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis"

The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis This paper aims to analyze “The Robertson Foundation Case” in terms of its possible implications on fundraising and endowments in the future. The case would be evaluated based on the ethical context of fundraising. Introduction “Every organization needs money to survive, develop, and expand. Fundraising is vital to reducing dependency on some parent organization, or founder, or limited funding source. Fundraising is vital for an organization’s viability over time.” (Norton, 2003) The Robertson Foundation Case exemplifies relevant concerns encompassing fundraising and philanthropy. It provides an actual ongoing case between a prominently famous university and a philanthropic donor. The Robertson Foundation was established by spouses Charles and Marie Robertson in 1961 with the following specific objectives, to wit: “(a) “To establish or maintain and support, at Princeton University, and as part of the Woodrow Wilson School, a Graduate School, where men and women dedicated to public service may prepare themselves for careers in government service, with particular emphasis on the education of such persons for careers in those areas of the Federal Government that are concerned with international relations and affairs; and (b) To establish and maintain scholarships or fellowships, which will provide full, or partial support to students to each Graduate School, whether such students are candidates for degrees, special students, or part-time students.” Its initial endowment was worth $35million composed of 700,000 shares of A & P stocks. Problems ensued when Princeton University allegedly spent portions of the funds for purposes beyond those which were specifically mentioned. This was complicated by the fact that Princeton University was accorded full control of the Robertson Foundation with four members of the board from the university and only three members representing the Robertson family. In this regard, this case would be assessed in terms of its possible implications on fundraising and endowments in the future. Further, the case would be evaluated based on the ethical context of fundraising. Case Arguments A case was filed by the Robertson family on July 2002, represented by the four children and a cousin. Wooster (2006, 4) averred that “the initial charge in the complaint was that the university was illicitly commingling Robertson Foundation money with the university’s endowment and using foundation funds for activities that had nothing to do with training students for careers in civil service.” In fact, the following allegations were noted: (1) “whether or not the “public service” President Goheen referred to is the same as “government service”; (2) the endowment, previously managed by Essex Street Investment, was planned to be managed by PRINCO, an organization managing Princeton’s investments; (3) withholding of current financial information to the foundation board; (4) excessive charging of overhead; (5) defrauding other donors and covering up misallocation of funds; (6) diverting funds for purposes other than intended; among others. On the other hand, Princeton University, tried to defend itself by stipulating the following, to wit: (1) the Robertson Fund could not be transferred to another university; (2) that PRINCO could manage the endowment funds; (3) that capital gains plus interest from the fund could be spent by Princeton; (4) “the Robertson family trustees were “attempting to hold the foundation and the Woodrow Wilson School hostage” and that the Robertson family was engaging in a “gratuitous, baseless public relations campaign” which would harm both “the potential pool of student applicants [and] the receptiveness of funding agencies to Woodrow Wilson School grant applications.” (Wooster, 2006, 5) Analyses of Arguments The underlying issues all point to Princeton University’s non adherence to donor’s intent. Even the lawyer of Princeton University, Douglas Eakeley, “admitted that foundation money was used for departments outside the Wilson School”. Further, when Hechinger and Golden also reported that the foundation spent $750,000 for student tuition in courses that weren’t part of the Wilson School curriculum, “Princeton failed to disclose the diversion and admitted to the Journal that its action was “inappropriate.”” (Wooster, 2006, 6) These instances could tantamount to admission of guilt and a violation of the ethical standards of fundraising. Further, Princeton University’s record of using donor’s funds for purposes beyond those stipulated also diminishes its credibility. In a book written by Kelly (1998, 308) on Effective Fund Raising Management, she presented a Donor Bill of Rights which stipulates that all donors have the following rights, “to have access to the organization’s most recent financial statements; and to be assured their gifts will be used for the purposes for which they were given”. On these two major counts, the Princeton University allegedly violated. The source of the dilemma was primarily due to the flawed agreement between Robertson Foundation and Princeton University on the following aspects: (1) giving full control on the endowments funds to Princeton by agreeing to make majority votes to 4 Princeton members versus only 3 from the Robertson family; (2) by not providing clear and specific statements of the intent of the funds causing disputes on “public service versus government service”; (3) a silent dispute that existed for more than thirty years before it was legally addressed; (4) lack of monitoring and application of appropriate action in cases of violation; and (5) non adherence to a clear and agreed code of ethics. The Future of Fundraising Endowments The Robertson Foundation case clearly presents scenarios undermining possible implications of recipients’ misuse of donor’s funds. Ethical aspects of fundraising should emphasize a previously forged comprehensive code of ethics with four specifically defined guidelines: (1) “a credo, which is an ‘overarching statement of organizational philosophy and values’ (p.70); (2) general guidelines for decision making; (3) specific rules that prohibit certain actions and require others; and (4) definitions, rationales and illustrations.” (McElreath, 1997 in Kelly, 1998, 273). Without this and with the flaws enumerated in the Robertson Foundation case, fundraising endowments would face severe criticism and stricter scrutiny from the public and from the beneficiaries of the funds. As indicated, should Princeton University win this case, despite abundant evidence of defying donor intent, “it will be a grave blow to the cause”. (Wooster, 2006, 9) However, the case provided an enlightening revelation in the weaknesses of the system or agreement forged between the donor and the recipient. With more controls instituted and required by local and state governing bodies, the future of fundraising could still be saved. Conclusion An understanding of the concepts of fundraising and philanthropy should encompass ethical aspects for any undertaking to be successful. The importance of integrity, honesty and adherence to the purpose by which endowment funds are given must take priority in the accomplishment of the organization’s goals. References Kelly, K.S. (1998). Effective Fund Raising Management. London: Routledge. Norton, M. (2003). The Worldwide Fundraiser’s Handbook. London, England: Resource Alliance. Wooster, M.M. (2006). The Robertson Foundation Case: Can Princeton Ignore A Donor’s Intent? Retrieved 19 September 2009 from < http://capitalresearch.org/pubs/pdf/FW0506.pdf> Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis Essay”, n.d.)
The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1557629-robertson-foundation-paper
(The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis Essay)
The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1557629-robertson-foundation-paper.
“The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1557629-robertson-foundation-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Robertson Foundation Case: An Analysis

US Criminal Law: A Murder from the Perspective of US Criminal Law

A paper "US Criminal Law: A Murder from the Perspective of US Criminal Law" claims that under the litigation of criminal law the accused also has the right to protect themselves from any kind of abuse during the investigation and prosecution period by the concerned authoritative bodies.... hellip; Criminal law system is the practice performed by the law and order institutions of governments in order to uphold the social control with the intention of deterring and mitigating crime....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Recruitment and Selection Process of the Applicants to Fifteen Restaurant

Oliver created a permanent foundation to recruit and train disadvantaged young people to become chefs.... By 2005, the restaurant was doing so well financially; it could contribute substantially to the foundation.... The paper "The Recruitment and Selection Process of the Applicants to Fifteen Restaurant" states that most of the students completed the course....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Nationalism and National Identities in a Globalised World

However, the imported culture has over the years taken up the local culture specifically true in the case of Asia.... The reason behind this very common thinking to be bogus is that being so it would itself then alter the very foundation of nationalism.... This could adversely affect cultures from becoming non dissociating or nondistinct (robertson, 2003)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Why Pete Should Not Get Punished under Court of Law

The paper "Why Pete Should Not Get Punished under Court of Law " highlights that some legal issues relating to the business contract law are very much involved here, hence, Pete is strongly suggested to deal this case intelligently by making his legal ground logically.... nbsp;… In general, Pete may explore the possibility of solving this issue by entering in to direct negotiation with Medium Ltd (in case of the court case is filed by Medium Ltd....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Direct and Database Marketing of Joe Deluccis in the UK

This paper “Direct and Database Marketing of Joe Delucci's in the UK” presents the idea of integrating marketing tools and how it benefits companies which implement it.... Marketing effectiveness is demonstrated by the example of a company that sells Italian ice cream the Southern region of the UK....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Enterprise Architecture and the Foundation for Execution

n the case of Adopt-A-Farm, the foundation for execution can be said not to have attained its level best.... The writer of the paper “Enterprise Architecture and the foundation for Execution” states that having a concrete plan for the transition from the current state involves such aspects as having plans to customize it in a manner that it will be able to serve a huge number of stakeholders in the future.... To achieve a good foundation for execution, proper business-IT alignment is fundamental (Ross et al....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Tourism Policy, Planning, and Development of Kangaroo Island

… The paper "Tourism Policy, Planning, and Development of Kangaroo Island" is an outstanding example of a case study on tourism.... The paper "Tourism Policy, Planning, and Development of Kangaroo Island" is an outstanding example of a case study on tourism.... This case study seeks to analyze the tourism policy, planning, and development on Kangaroo Island....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Effectiveness of Child and Adolescent Mental Health Interventions in the UK

This research conducted a detailed analysis of the interventions to determine their effectiveness and significance.... … The paper "Effectiveness of Child and Adolescent Mental Health Interventions in the United Kingdom" is a good example f a case study on psychology.... The paper "Effectiveness of Child and Adolescent Mental Health Interventions in the United Kingdom" is a good example f a case study on psychology....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us