StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

WTO dispute settlement procedures - Thesis Example

Cite this document
Summary
A dispute within the global economy and trade arises when one Member State frames a trade policy or takes up some measures that the other Member States perceive as a direct violation of the WTO treaty agreements…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
WTO dispute settlement procedures
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "WTO dispute settlement procedures"

Table of Contents 2 1Introduction 3 1Background history 3 2Problem ment 4 3Aims and objectives 5 4Significance of the study 5 Bibliography 6 Abstract The Dispute resolution/settlement procedure under the World Trade Organization (WTO) is considered to be at the core of the global multilateral trade of the 21st century. A dispute within the global economy and trade arises when one Member State frames a trade policy or takes up some measures that the other Member States perceive as a direct violation of the WTO treaty agreements.

However, various instances show that the dispute resolution process under WTO has some inherent flaws that give scope to the economically stronger nations to ignore the WTO’s rulings against them. In view of some of the recent cases, it is time that the entire system is reviewed, and new reforms added, so that the developing countries get a fair chance at justice, and an equal share within the global trade and economy. WTO Dispute settlement procedures 1 Introduction 1.1 Background history The Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU) procedures under the WTO were established owing to the futility of the disagreement settling processes that were previously in existence under the GATT, since 1947.

Under GATT, the procedures for settling disputes were invariably long-drawn and ineffectual, and any nation, especially the one against whom the complaint had been filed, could effectively delay or even block the dispute resolution process (Bello and Holmer, 1994, 1096).  Since the GATT did not function as a formal institution, it lacked official procedures with which it could make the rules obligatory on the contending parties. Later in 1989, the Montreal rules or the Decision on Improvements to GATT Dispute Settlement Rules and Procedures were approved during the Uruguay Round, which gave the dispute system under GATT a more legal outline, and removed the power for blocking the resolution process while also setting a certain time limit for all dispute resolutions (Mora,  1993).

Finally, in 1994 under WTO, the “Final Act” was ratified (in the Uruguay Round), that established the “Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes” or DSU, and created an Appellate Body (AB), and a Dispute Settlement Body (DSB), which gave the entire process a more legal standing and rationality. This new stronger dispute resolution procedure under WTO primarily aimed to resolve the "fine line between national prerogatives and unacceptable trade restrictions"(Abels, 1996, 503).

The process of dispute resolution is: Complaint filed Consultations Panel proceedings Appellate Body Compliance Panel Arbitration Panel (Busch, and Reinhardt, 2004, 8). The time limit set for resolving a dispute is one year for a dispute case without appeal, and one year three months for a case with appeal (Understanding the WTO: Settling Disputes, A unique contribution). The process under WTO has shown a fair amount of success, where we find that “by January 2008, only about 136 of the nearly 369 cases had reached the full panel process.

Most of the rest have been notified as either settled “out of court” or remain in a prolonged consultation phase — some since 1995” (ibid). Some of the more famous cases under WTO dispute resolution are the European Hormone case (WTO watch--sample of new report, 1998), the EU Regime Case (World Trade Organization, May 1997), the Kodak-Fuji Case (Holloyway, 1997), and the Japan Alcohol Case (Bhushan, 1997). 1.2 Problem statement Observations reveal that under the GATT dispute resolution, the developing countries like the Asian countries, the Middle East countries, and the Latin American countries, very rarely used the process of adjunction.

The dispute resolution procedure under WTO was framed with the express aim that the new procedure would facilitate the use of the system, especially by the developing countries, despite their small size and relatively less power. However, the process even under the WTO failed to live up to its expectations and the developing countries continue facing problems, regarding the use of the WTO dispute settlement system, though some of them have appeared in the DSM as third parties. Many NGOs have appealed to the DSM as amici curiae, as in the Asbestos dispute case (European Communities – Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos-Containing Products, 2001), and the Shrimp dispute case (United States-Import Prohibition of Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products, 1998), while pressure is high to allow more economically weaker countries into the system as a third party witness.

There are also complaints that when retaliatory measures against the economically strong nations are awarded by WTO, the former tend to ignore the rulings and do not implement it, thus making the entire dispute resolution process a toothless one (Obijiofor, 2007). 1.3 Aims and objectives The paper aims to study the process of dispute resolution under WTO, right from the time of its conception (under GATT) to the recent times, and will study how the machinery has evolved over the years. It aims to make an in-depth study of the work of the panels, the various procedures that are involved from the time of complaint filing to the final resolution.

It will also seek to explore the various problems associated with this system, while seeking to find resolutions for bringing in various reforms within the dispute resolution process, to make it more suitable for the developing countries. 1.4 Significance of the study The research study is significant, as it seeks to find reformatory processes within the WTO DSM, in favour of the developing countries. In this era of globalisation and thriving global trade and commerce, there must be efforts made to allow the economically weaker nations to voice their opinions and get justice from the trade related dispute cases, where instances show that under the existent system the developed nations with their stronger economy always tend to get an upper hand.

Bibliography Abels, T., 1996. The World Trade Organization's First Test: The United States-Japan Auto Dispute. 44 UCLA Law Review, 503. Bello, J., and Holmer, A., 1994. U.S. Trade Law and Policy Series No. 24: Dispute Resolution in the New World Trade Organization: Concerns and Net Benefits. The International Lawyer (28), 1096. Bhushan B., 1997. 16th December 1997. Face Off. Wall Street Journal. Busch, M., and Reinhardt, E., 2004. Trade brief on the WTO dispute settlements. SIDA, retrieved from, http://userwww.service.emory.

edu/~erein/research/SIDA.pdf. European Communities – Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos-Containing Products, Appellate Body report, March 2001, WT/DS135/AB/R. Holloyway, N., 24th July 1997. Black and White. Far Eastern Economic Review, Vol.60 No.30, 77-78. Lowenfeld, A., 2007. “Preface - First Thoughts on Dispute Settlement in the World Trade Organization.” In, Pierre Pescatore, William J. Davey, Andreas F. Lowenfeld (Eds.), Handbook of WTO/GATT Dispute Settlement. NY: Translations Publishers Inc.

 Mora, M., 1993. A GATT with Teeth: Law Wins over Politics in the Resolution of. International Trade Disputes. 31 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law, 103. Obijiofor, A., 2007. Food Safety, South-North Asymmetries, and the Clash of Regulatory Regimes, 40 Vand. Journal Transnational Law, 1099, 1112. Shell, R., 1995. Trade Legalism and International Relations Theory: An Analysis of the World Trade Organization. Duke Law Journal, Vol. 44, No.5, 339. Understanding the WTO: Settling Disputes.

A unique contribution. Retrieved from, http://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/whatis_e/tif_e/disp1_e.htm United States-Import Prohibition of Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products, panel report, WT/DS58/R, 15th May 1998, Appellate Body report, WT/DS138/AB/R, 12th October 1998. . World Trade Organization, 22nd May 1997. European Communities - Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas. Report of the Panel, WT/DS27/R/USA. WTO watch--sample of new report, January 21, 1998. EU bananas.

 WTO News--Vol. 1, Number 1, retrieved from http://www.mail-archive.com/pen-l@galaxy.csuchico.edu/msg24572.html

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“WTO dispute settlement procedures Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1424093-wto-dispute-settlement-procedures
(WTO Dispute Settlement Procedures Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/business/1424093-wto-dispute-settlement-procedures.
“WTO Dispute Settlement Procedures Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1424093-wto-dispute-settlement-procedures.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF WTO dispute settlement procedures

The GATT/WTO Agreements effectively protect the interests of the developing country members of the WTO

… The paper shall choose to discuss three crucial components of the GATT/WTO that impact upon developing countries: the tariff and subsidies issues surrounding the trade in agricultural products, the protection of trade-related intellectual property rights, and the application of the dispute settlement mechanism.... More formally known as the Doha Development Agenda, it is comprised of talks in the areas of agriculture, non-agricultural market access (NAMA), services, intellectual property (TRIPs), trade and development, trade and environment, trade facilitation, WTO rules, special and differential treatment, and the dispute settlement understanding (DSU)....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

China as the Fastest-Growing Countries

China China is one of the fastest growing countries in the world.... It is a country that is emerging from tight controls, where the government through its arms controlled economic activities such as setting up prices of various commodities, fixing foreign exchange rate and regulating the international trade....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

WTO dispute settlement procedure

… The World Trade Organization claims that the changes implemented by the World Trade Organization's dispute settlement system strengthens the role that dispute resolution plays in success of the World Trade Organization's multilateral trade regime The World Trade Organization's dispute resolution system has been the subject of both self-praise and observer praise.... The World Trade Organization claims that the changes implemented by the World Trade Organization's dispute settlement system strengthens the role that dispute resolution plays in success of the World Trade Organization's multilateral trade regime....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Effectiveness of the Dispute Settlement Procedure Under WTO

Efforts directed towards improving the DSU and the WTO dispute settlement procedures 49 2.... hellip; Consultations, WTO Panel hearing of a dispute and appeal to the WTO Appellate Body are components of the dispute settlement procedures under the WTO that must present practical solutions that are fair, judicious and acceptable to all parties.... However, although the dispute settlement procedures under the WTO have operated since the inception of the WTO in 1995, on-going efforts have continued to try to improve on these procedures....
76 Pages (19000 words) Dissertation

Dispute Settlement Understanding

This paper ''dispute settlement Understanding'' tells that The World Trade Organisation or WTO has over 140 members including all of the major trading countries and trade disputes are likely among these members as WTO agreements may be interpreted or applied differently by different WTO members.... hellip; Considering the possibilities and of trade disputes, the dispute settlement Understanding has been used by the WTO as a legal and administrative tool to settle disputes between trading members....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Why Did the EU and the US Engage in an Eight-Year Dispute over the Banana Trade

Despite repeated rulings under the GATT and later under the World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement procedures in 1993 1994, 1997, and 1999 that the European banana import system was illegal under international trade law.... The report covers the banana trade wars which erupted between the United States and the European Union in 1993 and lasted eight years before an agreement for settlement was reached.... This particular transatlantic trade dispute is of unique importance because neither of the parties involved either produces nor exports the crop in question....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Effectiveness of WTOs Dispute Settlement Procedure

The WTO dispute settlement system was built upon on the basis of the GATT dispute settlement procedures.... This paper deals with the extent of the effectiveness of WTO's dispute settlement procedure in the practical sense.... To examine its effectiveness, the dispute settlement procedure is studied first.... Nevertheless, the effectiveness of the dispute settlement procedure of the WTO gives rise to controversies related to its verdicts and operating techniques....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

WTO as a Dispute Settlement Body

the 1947 Dispute Settlement Procedure – which was the first on the specific field, the 1979 and the 1989 dispute settlement procedures were partially used in developing the DSP of 1994 – on which the current System is based (Hartigan, 2009,p.... he wto dispute settlement system (alternatively mentioned from now on as the 'System') has a rather short history; its operation started about 15 years before and shortly it has become one of the most important features in the resolution of disputes related to the international trade....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us