StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Insanity defense : - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The insanity defense has been a relatively recent phenomena in court cases having first appeared in 1843 at the trial of Daniel M’Nagten, a woodworker Scotsman who killed the secretary to the British Prime Minister in a mistaken attempt to kill the man he believed was…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Insanity defense :
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Insanity defense :"

The insanity defense has been a relatively recent phenomena in court cases having first appeared in 1843 at the trial of Daniel M’Nagten, a woodworker Scotsman who killed the secretary to the British Prime Minister in a mistaken attempt to kill the man he believed was targeting him (Martin, 1998). As a result of this trial, judges determined the insanity defense might be invoked if the defendant was operating “under such defect of reason from disease of the mind” as to not realize that what they were doing was a crime (Martin, 1998).

It is this right versus wrong idea that has formed the basis of most of the American laws regarding this defense argument. Yet, the insanity defense has come under attack numerous times since its inception because of its very malleable nature – some who are obviously insane, such as Charles Guiteau who shot President Garfield in 1881, are found incontrovertibly guilty while others, such as John Hinkley who shot President Reagan in 1981, are found not guilty by reason of insanity. “There is a very strong perception in America that defendants are abusing this defense to escape murder charges in the nation’s courts” (Gado, 2005).

In terms of the defense actually being used, reports indicate that the insanity defense is “difficult to plead, seldom used and almost never successful” (Gado, 2005). Despite this, I do believe there are some instances in which the insanity defense is plausible and appropriate, such as in the case of Daniel Zwack.In the case of Daniel Zwack, the defendant was convinced at the time of his crimes that he was being targeted by the CIA, the Masons and numerous other shadowy figures, forcing him to stock his vehicle up with weaponry and head back home to Minnesota in violation of his parole.

What makes this case distinctive is that when his family started noticing strange behavior in their son – spraying mace in his mother’s face for refusing to hand over a negative letter regarding him, for instance – they tried to have him committed in an effort to obtain for him the medical attention they felt he obviously needed. However, the courts, deciding he wasn’t dangerous enough, refused to confine him to the hospital. It wasn’t until he was involved with a shootout with Texas police (and one federal officer, for whom he was given an additional 17 years) that Zwack was finally determined dangerous.

His mother, though horrified, said she also felt some relief, believing her son would finally be found insane and be given the medical treatment he needed (Biewen, 2006). Instead, he received 62 years in maximum security prison. However, while there, he has received some medical attention that has demonstrated that insanity was a plausible reason for his rampage. While in prison, Zwack has been taking Risperdol, which has worked to stop hallucinations and reduce the voices Zwack claims to hear.

He even reported receiving a phone call in his cell once to remind him to take his medicine. He, of course, does not have a phone in his cell. When a person is demonstrably ill in his thinking, as in the case of Daniel Zwack, to such an extent that family and friends have worked to have this person committed at some time in the past, the insanity defense should be able to be used. In this particular case, the individual suffering the mental disease was not even aware of his wrong-thinking until after he was placed on medication and the medication had a chance to begin functioning.

When he has been too long off of the medication, he now reports instances in which he is still thinking in strange ways. Other cases, in which the individual knows they are not thinking correctly, but are unable to obtain help for one reason or another, could just as easily be considered crimes committed while insane. While there is room for abuse in such cases, I believe if one is sick, mentally or otherwise, there should be methods in place for them to obtain the help they need before the crimes occur, and, in the absence of such, it is unethical for the rest of us to hold them responsible for what they do in the twisted reasoning of an injured mind.

ReferencesBeiwen, John. (2006). “Not Sick Enough: The Insanity Defense.” American Public Media. Retrieved February 3 2006 from .Gado, Mark. (2005). “You Must Die!” Court TV Crime Library. Retrieved February 3 2006 from .Martin, John. (February 27 1998). “The Insanity Defense: A Closer Look.” Washington Post. Retrieved February 3 2006 from .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Insanity defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Insanity defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense
(Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense.
“Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Insanity defense :

Insanity plea

Actual Defense The Insanity defense is one of the numerous misused features of the forensic psychiatry that does not only allow sane persons to impose ‘insanity traits' in courts but it also allow to criminals or dangerous people to continue being in the society especially after they have undergone medical tests (Anderson and Gardner 50).... In any court proceeding where the accused is thought of being insane or an Insanity defense is found necessary, the accused begins by admitting that he or she committed the crime before a panel of a jury or judges....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Insanity vs Psychosis in a legal concept

This has consequences, through the practice of law over time, brought about what is known as the “Insanity defense Law” which extensively connects psychiatry and law.... The Insanity defense Law, used by criminal defenders or lawyers, is based on the provisions that a defendant must be found not guilty by reason of insanity if, at the time of the alleged offense, and as a result of severe mental disease or defect, he/she did not know what he/she was doing, or that what he was doing was wrong (Ewing, 2008)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Critical Thinkning / Reaction Paper

Mark Gado explains the background history and implications of the Insanity defense and argues for a better use… One cannot reject the significance of Insanity defense in an age where scientific studies on the human mind are fast progressing.... The interesting part of is that those who are acquitted of their crime due to their proven insanity are not The Insanity defense The Insanity defense is commonly misunderstood as a smart ploy performed by well-paid advocates to save their rich and famous clients....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

How Has the Insanity Defense Been Used in the Films Primal Fear and Nuts

The review "How Has the Insanity defense Been Used in the Films Primal Fear and Nuts?...   states while the Primal Fear seeks to establish the Insanity defense to gain a verdict of not guilty from the Court, in the film “Nuts” the Insanity defense is used more peripherally, to establish the competence of the defendant to stand trial for her crime.... hellip; The films titled “Primal Fear” and “Nuts” both revolve around crimes that have been committed, where the counsel for the defendants base their defense on the criminal Insanity defense – “not guilty by reason of insanity....
8 Pages (2000 words) Movie Review

Not Guilty by Reasons of Insanity

) Discuss the two Insanity defense standards, M'Naghten and American Law Institute (ALI).... ) Identify at least 3 points of concerns that gives rise to requests for Insanity defense reforms.... ) Tests: EEG, CAT scan of brain, Chromosomal analysis, WAIS-R, Rorschach, MMPI Diagnosis: Mixed Personality Disorder with strong psychopathic and sadistic features 4) - Insanity defense may be overused - Insanity defense is used just about exclusively in scandalous crimes - people acquitted with Not Guilty by Reasons of Insanity(NGRI) are quickly released - people acquitted as NGRI are dangerous because of their mental disorder/defect 5) In NGRI the defendant is considered “not guilty” of a criminal act if he is able to met Insanity defense standards....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Definition and Criticism of an Insanity Defense

Insanity defense typically refers to a plea that defendants are not guilty because they lacked the mental capacity to realize that they committed a wrong or appreciate why it was wrong.... It may also allow defendants to argue that they understood their behavior was criminal but… Insanity defense is an attempt to impose a moral check on a system which is largely designed to weigh facts and evidence.... For instance, a number of US states have Insanity defense of Institute] The Definition And Criticism of Insanity defense Insanity defense typically refers to a plea that defendants are not guilty because they lacked the mental capacity to realize that they committed a wrong or appreciate why it was wrong....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Defense in a Criminal Case

The… The defendant or the lawyer purports that the defendant committed the crime but did not have the understanding that the act was wrong or never had Insanity defense Mechanism al affiliation The conviction of defendant requires evidence that is beyond a reasonable doubt to prove the defendant guilty of the charges.... The Insanity defense mechanism is one of the methods used and has led to freeing of some of the offenders in cases related to murder....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Media Coverage of John Hinckley

hellip; The media coverage did portray the Insanity defense as a symbol and a cause of social dangers and ills associated with a society.... In taking this dimension, the media in some way lead people to have an inward fear that a murder such as Hinckley would be released into a community in case the Insanity defense carries the day.... For example, throughout the articles, there are a number of instances of inaccurate media reportage that seemed to glorify the case by excluding or sometimes de-emphasizing Hinckley's proven criminal insanity as the real cause of his actions (Ann, 1985)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us