StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Juvenile justice system is a legal framework designed to punish, rehabilitate, and correct some of the deviant behaviors among young offenders.Criminal justice system,on the other hand,is a legal structure that punishes or rehabilitates adult offender for committing unlawful acts. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems"

Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Task: Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Introduction Juvenile justice system is alegal framework designed to punish, rehabilitate, and correct some of the deviant behaviors among young offenders. Criminal justice system, on the other hand, is a legal structure that punishes or rehabilitates adult offender for committing unlawful acts. These two systems are similar and dissimilar in a certain capacity. Therefore, this document will point out some of the similarities and differences that exist between the two systems, juvenile justice and criminal justice systems.

Dissimilarities Lawmakers have continuously contributed to the existing similarities and differences between the adult criminal justice and the juvenile justice system. One of the differences exists within the purpose of these systems. The adult criminal justice system administers punishment to the offender, while the juvenile justice system insists on rehabilitation of the offender. The constitutional rights stipulate that young people are dependent of their parents thus their behavior can be corrected.

Therefore, it considers young offenders as people who can reform, as opposed to adults who face full sentence, equal to the crimes committed. Additionally, the proceedings in an adult criminal court are open to the public, while those of the juvenile court are conducted in closed sessions. Moreover, bails may be given to an offender in a criminal court but not in a juvenile court. The details of the court proceeding in an adult court must be released to the press, while those of the juvenile court remain private and confidential.

All adults have a right to jury trial; however, this is not the same in the juvenile justice system since most states do not provide this right to the offender. A young offender may be charged for acts that an adult would not be charged; whereas, adults are charged for acts considered illegitimate by the law. For instance, a young person may be charged in a juvenile court for disobedience, which is a contrary to the adults. The criminal records of young offender are temporary compared to those of an adult, which are permanent (Hess, 2009).

Similarities In addition to the dissimilarities, there also exist a number of similarities between these two justice systems. This has prompted a number of states to refer some of the juvenile cases to the adult courts. One of the noted Similarities occurs during the arrest. Offenders, in both cases, must be notified of the rights before being apprehended. In both systems, the offenders may be kept in custody before the judicial ruling, if considered a threat to society. Offenders, in both cases, are entitled to a legal counsel especially in the critical stage of the case.

In case the offender pleads guilty to the offenses, the penalty induced on him is reduced or is negotiable in both systems. The evidence presented before the court in both cases should be proved beyond any logical doubt. Decisions made by the judge in both cases are based on social and legal facts. The juveniles and adults can appeal in case they feel that the ruling made was not fair. In both cases, the offenders can be punished by serving the community depending on the magnitude of their offence (Siegel, 2011).

During the period of service, they are monitored and report to their supervisor at given times. My opinion I believe there are enough significant dissimilarity between the juvenile justice and the adult criminal justice system. The function of the criminal court is to punish, contrary to juveniles, which rehabilitates. For instance, the adult criminal court cannot provide a harsh sentence to a child for disobedience to the parents. The adult criminal court would term that as not being an offense, as it is against the legal provisions.

In that case, the child will correct his or her deviant behavior and will grow with an understanding that disobedience is acceptable in the society. Despite the tremendous similarities in the two systems, it would be unethical to subject a child to the trauma of being judged in public for a minor act. Social needs for a separate juvenile system Though there are so many similarities between the two systems, there exists a need for the juvenile system to be separate from the criminal justice system.

The aim of the juvenile system is to cater for the moral development of children. Juveniles are growing individuals and hence every step in correcting them should instill some relevant knowledge to them (Junger-Tas & Decker, 2006). Most offences committed by juveniles are not criminal and thus cannot be effectively handled by a criminal court. Therefore, correcting the offenses committed by a minor can only be done effectively by juvenile justice system. To establish the moral development of a child, correction of mistakes through rehabilitation has to be encouraged.

This can only be achieved by ensuring that the juvenile system is separated from the adult criminal justice system. Conclusion In conclusion, it is clear that there exist some considerable similarities and differences between the juvenile and criminal justice systems. However, despite the differences being limited, I still hold my thought that the differences in the two systems are significant thus worth mentioning. Several social aspects such as the nature of juvenile offenses render juvenile justice system significant thus the need for its separate existence.

References Hess, M. (2009). Juvenile Justice. United Kingdom, UK: Cengage Learning. Junger-Tas, J., & Decker, H. S. (2006). International handbook of juvenile justice. New York, NY: Springer. Siegel, J. L. (2011). Criminology. United Kingdom, UK: Cengage Learning.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1433699-criminal-and-juvenile-justice-systems
(Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1433699-criminal-and-juvenile-justice-systems.
“Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1433699-criminal-and-juvenile-justice-systems.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminal and Juvenile Justice Systems

Take two states and compare their juvenile justice systems

Running Head: juvenile justice systems juvenile justice systems of California and Florida Juvenile justice is applicable basically on those persons who are not old enough subjected to the breach of laws on criminal ground.... In this contrast author Muncie, 2008, said, “juvenile justice systems throughout America now give greater weight to punishment as an end in itself” (Muncie, 2008, pp.... hellip; juvenile justice works under the vigilance of the state law and each state has its own juvenile code....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Juvenile Probation system

Juvenile Probation System Creation The juvenile probation system is an evolution of the court and juvenile justice system, as a means of differentiating the adult criminals from the young lawbreakers.... Juvenile Probation System Name: Institution: Juvenile Probation System Probation is part of the juvenile justice system.... In juvenile justice system, the judge, and the probation officer are supposed to act as wise parents or guardians to the underage child (Del Carmen & Trulson, 2005)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Juvenile and Adult Courts

hellip; In a reflective analysis of the history of the evolvement of both the justice systems, it becomes lucid that the juvenile court system has been historically distinct from adult courts and the Progressives, by the early twentieth century, started to perceive children in a new manner.... The juvenile justice system and the adult criminal justice system are two dissimilar systems of justice and they are founded on different philosophies, although both the systems have close resemblance in many states currently....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Research Proposal for Juvenile Justice

juvenile justice and prevention have long been and continue to be intimately related.... Historically and presently, juvenile justice has placed great emphasis on diverting youths from future problems and on working with those youths who, as Justice Mack put it in 1909, are "treading the path that leads to criminality" (p.... If it is thought f in this way, juvenile justice can be considered the most massive institutional, secondary prevention effort ever mounted to deal with adolescents' antisocial activity. Obviously, though, juvenile justice is more than just benevolent guidance f youths during adolescent development or family crisis....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Law Enforcement in the Juvenile System

This paper intends to look at the juvenile justice system in relation to law enforcement.... In today's society, juvenile justice is a world wide concern of law enforcement.... … The juvenile justice system involves a network of agencies that normally deals with juveniles whose conducts are normally in conflict with the law (Myer, 2008).... Page Law enforcement In today's society, juvenile justice is a world wide concern of law enforcement....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Latino studies. Latino Youth in Juvenile / Criminal Justice

The experience of Latino youth in the present American context is exposed with a high intensity of criminal image by the policing and… Native as well as migrant groups of the community have been overwhelmingly looked down upon by the racist authorities in the country's bureaucratic line of law and order and criminal justice management.... A largely significant proportion of the y of the violence and criminal activities in the country projects the Latino youth in the socially arrogant side; however, an analysis of the actual situations of cumulative disadvantage, youth control complex and social ambush will clearly reveal that the Latino youth are haunted by the domineering approach of the upper class of the society in education, media, policing and law in the country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Female Adolescents Who Are Abused Who Later in Life Become Sex Offenders

nbsp; In the United States sex crimes are "fairly common" and "it is estimated that one in every five girls and one in every seven boys" are sexually abused before they become adults (United States Department of justice, p.... There are no "typical" sex offenders and they can be any race, male or female, wealthy or poor and come from all different types of families (United States Department of justice, p.... According to the United States Department of justice (2007) females only make up one percent of all sexual offenders but juvenile females make up "3% of forcible rape cases, 5% of violent sex offenses, and 19% of non-violent sex offenses" (p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Future of the Juvenile Justice System

It has been argued that teenagers below the age of seventeen are breaking the existing laws more often because of the existence of the juvenile justice system The juvenile justice System of the United States has a long history having been established in 1899.... The juvenile justice system's existence has been threatened, with its operations and legality being challenged every day.... Before its establishment, minors under the age of seventeen who committed crimes had to undergo the same justice system as adults....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us