StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Shameful Past of America - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of the following assignment attempts to provide commentary on several quotations and notes from pieces of literature regarding the foundation and the history of the United States of America. The writer will focus on the past social epidemic of racism…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
The Shameful Past of America
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Shameful Past of America"

Commentary on Quotes It would seem, from reading the content of most history books or the writings of early American settlers, that America was a country founded on principle and altruism. In reality, however, just beneath the proud surface of early America there lurks the same patriarchal and racist values that today still haunt this country. The first president of the United States, George Washington, of whom schools, monuments and states are named after, was in reality a slave holder and a chauvinist. An evolving society that is coming to terms with its shameful past cannot fully align itself with a true spirit of equality for all for present and future without first fully accepting the reality of its shameful beginnings. “Someone has to say it or we are never going to get out of this rut. I am sick and tired of the founding fathers and their intents” (Kurlansky, 2006). This quote from Mark Kurlasky, found in an L.A. Times article, reiterates the notion that we as a country seem compelled to glorify the intent or mission of our founding fathers when what we should really be doing is using them as examples of how treacherous a patriarchal, class based society really is. Additionally, we should remember them for who they who in reality, slave holders and misogynists. It is true that they were involved with establishing this country from meager beginnings but at great cost to humanity. The founding fathers of America built a country through slave labor and virtual genocide of the native American people. Today, if we watched overseas, as another group of settlers invaded a country and killed it’s inhabitants, we would most likely act repulsed and challenge that country to war. Incidentally, that is exactly what we did in Desert Storm in the 1990’s when Iraq invaded the small but wealthy country of Kuwait! “Whether the revolt was right or wrong, the way the city, state and government officials conducted themselves after the revolt ended, has left a lumo in the throats of American Negroes”(McKeller, 1967). This quote pretains to a revolt which took place in a specific city known as Watts. Watts is one of many examples of a city with less than adequate public schooling, not to mention low income and poor race relations. Thanks to the standards set by our founding fathers, we still have deeply routed racial issues today in America. Had our founding fathers not sat a precedence of racism, intolerance and inequality; we might actually live in a country where individuals were able to live harmoniously with one another despite the difference in their national origin, skin color, gender and so on. “My pursuit of American character, is basically a pursuit of difference”(Deavers, 2000). This author has set out to find the origin or core of American character but has done so with the understanding that America as a whole is comprised of difference. Certainly, this is a clear understanding of what one might find if truly seeking to find the center of American character as the truth is, that this country is entirely comprised of difference in many ways. To be an American, is to be one of many variations of human beings. In fact, the title of ‘American’ truly implies that one is an individual who lives among millions of other individuals, all with unique and varying elements of origin and character. “Allegations that Columbus was a miserable governor, a poor leader, an opportunist and an unfit navigator were gathering support”(McWilliams, 1943). Returning to the ideology that America’s founding fathers left a lot to be desired as far as humanity is concerned, Christopher Columbus is no different. We will find in any history book on America, the same old tale of Christopher Columbus and his discovery of the ‘new world’, which we know as America. What we easily forget however is that Christopher Columbus found a land occupied by Native Americans. In other words, the uncharted land that Christopher Columbus takes credit for discovering some 600 years later, was not really undiscovered nor uncharted. It was land inhabited by preexisting colonies composed of many tribes of natives, who until Columbus’s alleged discovery, lived relatively peacefully among one another as well as in peaceful harmony with the earth. Prior to Columbus’s ‘discovery’ of the new world, there were no congested cities and oil crisis’s. There were no concerns about a jeopardized ozone due to human induced global warming. There were no nuclear power plants or deepening concerns about a global energy crisis and there were certainly were no impending Native American genocides or growing institutions of slavery. One may argue that Columbus cannot be blamed for the mess which his ancestors created, but he is certainly to blame for the rape and pillage of pre-owned land. The 14th Amendment, adopted in that same year, said that naturalized Americans have the same rights as the native born Americans but, in 1870, the Nationality Act specified that only ‘free whites’ and ‘African Aliens’ were allowed to apply for naturalization”(Kington, 1997). This quote from a work entitled China man is just a reminder of the foundation of this countries principles and standards. America began its existence with settlers from Europe who essentially moved in, took over and cleaned house. The native American peoples living on this land who had called it home for generations, were essentially forced out of their homes and/or murdered. Some of the early Native American tribes are extinct because of the spirit of American “naturalization”. Further more, the early settlers who allegedly held fast to biblical morals, ventured to the other side of the world to rob a country (Africa) of its citizens, only to enslave them for generations. America has the blood od Native Americans and Africans on its hands such that its origin of character is permanently blemished. “That every man might have need of other, and from hence they might be all knit more nearly together in the bonds of brotherly affection”(Winthrop, 1630). The reference of human kind inequality discussed here by John Winthrop, implies a need instilled by God, for human inequality such that we all might need one another. This is a hugely misguided and archaic statement by someone who now a days, would probably be at the front lines of a KKK rally. There is no way to wrap racism or racial supremacy up in pretty package in order to deliver it as something other than what it is. Winthrop discusses his ideology that God has allegedly made men to be rich and others to be poor and so on. If this was a remote possibility of being anywhere near truth, than it would seem that God is a great puppet master and we are all here for his sadistic, childish amusement. Additionally, this ideology essentially conflicts with any rational description of a greater deity because no deity capable of such behavior would be wise enough to fashion the human genome, let alone the solar system from thin air. The point here is, that Winthrop was largely misguided in his thoughts on God and humankind, not so dissimilarly from the founding fathers of this country. “Living in the borderlands means you fight hard to resist the gold elixir beckoning from the bottle”(Anzaldva, 1981). The words by this author are poetic, modern and all too reminiscent of what many Americans have felt for centuries. Anzaldva is someone who is a mixture of several ethnicities therefore finding life a constant struggle of allegiance to each facet of her various ethnicities. One might like to think that in this the 21st century, and as late as the turning of the last century, race relations were highly evolved compared to the time of slavery. Sadly, we still are those people who limited rights of certain peoples or who neglected to recognize those peoples as ‘like us’ simply because of the fact that they are different. One hundred and fifty years ago, if one was black or native American, they were considered non-white and without the rights of a white man. In fact, no one had rights equivalent to a white man, even white women. Certainly, times have changed such that women can now vote along with anyone wo is a U.S. citizen and certainly, women may divorce their husbands and so on. Sadly though, the new racism is directed at sexual orientation these days. Granted an African American can finally vote, but a homosexual cannot marry their life partner. The cycle of Winthrop’s ideology of why people are stuck in class systems or a social hierarchy is a continuum of one human oppressing another. Not because God makes it so but because humans make it so. “In such a spirit on my part and on yours, we face our common difficulties. They concern, thank God, only material things”(Roosevelt, 1933). In his Inaugural address to the nation in 1933, Franklin D. Roosevelt openly admits a nation of difficulties but then blatantly writes them off to ‘material things’. From the beginning of the nation’s origins to this point in history and to present, the basis of American origin has been racism, capitalism, sexism and social exclusion. Roosevelt’s choice to feign blissful ignorance of these facts is just as common today in the U.S. government. We are at the finale of an 8 year republican administration which leaves the U.S. economy on the fringe of another great depression. An administration which fights for the right to life by depriving women of rights but fervently preaches the death penalty. Incidentally, the majority of individuals who have been given the death penalty are black men. For every 40 black men who are given the death penalty, one white man earns the same penalty for the same type of crime. We are a nation who preaches ‘Christian values of love and acceptance” but yet we only allow for those who fit social norms to enter into a publically acknowledged vow of marriage. We are a nation with healthcare ranked number 37 globally, right behind miniature Eastern European countries. “When I think over this rumor, I cannot adequately express the emotions which seize me. Dead letters? Does it not sound like dead men?” (Melville, 1856). Melville’s story “Bartleby the Scrivener” is a story about a man who worked at a Dead Letters Office and became unable to live life in any sense. The man became so desolate that he “preferred not to eat” and died of starvation while in jail. This can be seen as a commentary on society in general. With such inequality and distress that is so ubiquitous throughout society, there are bound to be people that are unable to mentally cope with all of the difficulties that are faced. The Dead Letters Office is also another commentary on society. So much effort goes into communication between people, but when one considers the Dead Letters Office, it is impossible to realize the degree to which messages back and forth do not reach the intended audience. The Dead Letters Office can be viewed as the futility of communication, and one cannot help but think that if all of this miscommunication did not exist, then there would not be the same degree of injustice and racial discrimination that takes place. In order for empathy to exist, people must be able to communicate their stories, and if the messages aren’t reaching the intended audiences, then the empathy cannot exist. “Our freedom of speech is freedom or death/ We got to fight the powers that be/ Lemme hear you say/ Fight the Power” (Carlton Douglas Ridenhour, 1989). These lyrics from the Public Enemy song “Fight the Power” are indicative the frustration that is felt by those that have been discriminated against for their whole lives. It is not a hopeless feeling, though, as the lyrics state that one should “Fight the power.” In the command to fight the power, there remains the possibility of changing the injustices that people face on a daily basis. This is an important attitude to keep when people are being discriminated against; it says that these people will not tolerate this sort of behavior towards them, and that they feel that they can positively affect change in their own lives. “If the laws be continually disposed and disregarded, if their rights to be secure in their persons and property are held by no better tenure than the caprice of the mob, the alienation of their affections from the government is the natural consequence” (Lincoln, 1838). Lincoln was referring to the many violent acts that were taking place against black people and people who were perceived as being in league or sympathizers of black people. He is stating that this kind of violence can be the only thing that could destroy America as a nation considering that America was basically impervious to the attacks of foreign nations. He knew that the issues of the subjugation and enslavement of black people would be the one issue that could tear the country apart, which it almost did in the Civil War. “Sometimes perhaps you don’t want to be a part of me. / Nor do I often want to be a part of you. / But we are, that’s true! / As I learn from you,/ I guess you learn from me— / although you’re older—and white— / and somewhat more free” (Hughes, 1959). Langston Hughes is commenting on the impossibility of separating the black identity completely from the white identity and the other way around. They both inform each other as Hughes explores in his poem “Theme for English B.” Because of the way that white people have subjugated black people and have racially discriminated against them for so long, this is ingrained into the identity of what it is like to be black, but at the same time the long history is inescapable for white people as well because the country would not be in the state that it is in today without the everything that was done to black people. There is no way to consider what one identity is like without considering the other identity. On the brink of a new millennium and perhaps a new administration, our country still battles its demons of deeply rooted racism and a horribly destructive class system. For those who would argue that racism is no longer an American social epidemic, perhaps an interview with presidential candidate, Sen. Barack Obama could shed some light on the reality of America today. If an interview could not be procured, it is most likely that Sen. Obama’s staff has had to ensure the most secret service detail, then has been required by any other presidential candidate in American history. Then again, every other presidential candidate has been a white man. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Shameful Past of America Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words, n.d.)
The Shameful Past of America Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1716994-commentary-on-quotations
(The Shameful Past of America Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
The Shameful Past of America Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1716994-commentary-on-quotations.
“The Shameful Past of America Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/history/1716994-commentary-on-quotations.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Shameful Past of America

Man and Masculinity: the Velvet Rage and Manhood in America

They dare to avoid the shameful feeling, when they are adults, by being in rage secretly to their bitter memories and extremely working to excel in arts, fashion and success.... (Name) (Professor) (Subject) (Date) Man and Masculinity: The Velvet Rage and Manhood in america The issue of sexuality has been in the hot seat for decades as several topics engage in controversies and heated debates on what should be done and how to perceive people.... The books entitled “The Velvet Rage” and “Manhood in america” are the two works to be compared and contrasted in the succeeding paragraphs regarding the gays and the masculinity standards....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Meaning of a Word Nigger

It has been an essential part of all cultures since ancient past and has contained significant place in all the human societies for centuries in respect of… It is nearly impossible to apprehend the meanings only through expressions or symbols without the help of words.... John Zerzan has defined the importance of language in these words: “Language may properly considered the fundamental ideology, perhaps as deep a separation from the natural world as self-existent time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Why United States Flag Burning is Wrong

They relish the flag because of what it represents; the freedoms and other principals that has become part of america's brand.... They relish the flag because of what it represents; the freedoms and other principals that has become part of america's brand.... Nevertheless, the flag is a part of america and an attack on it should be viewed as an attack on the country.... The motives of Protect the American Flag: Cases of Flag Burning Protect the American Flag In america, the flag is something that has been held sacred by many dedicated patriots....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

John Hancock, Boston Massacre Oration, March 5, 1774

Hancock characterized the events of March 5, 1770 as an exercise of British arrogance over her loyal subjects in america and to trample their rights and liberties.... This is contained in Hancock's speech that said “the troops of George III have crossed the wide Atlantic, not… He used agitating language to sow discontent among the public by narrating the how inappropriate the British are to be in america quoting “what Teacher How does Hancock characterize the events of March 5, 1770?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

RHETORIC AND LITERATURE

On the same Martin Luther King Junior stood to Rhetoric and Literature Rhetoric and Literature Martin Luther King Junior speech implication This was a speech to make a history for demonstration for freedom in the history of america.... They were fighting this freedom for the past years.... They were fighting this freedom for the past years.... On the same Martin Luther King Junior stood to dramatize the condition as shameful (American History, 1983)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Founding Brothers by Joseph J Ellis

It elaborately covers the history of america and the men behind its beginnings.... Aaron Burr was driven to western america where he tried to side with the British to become a governor in their colonies Ellis takes us further back in time with his next episode, The Dinner.... He had written a letter stating he will not take a third term of presidency and his vision of future america.... The stories that we weren't told in school as children are learned with much enthusiasm and intimacy, thus revealing them to be more human than a symbolic figure from the past....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Sex and Gender and how Society Views Them

hellip; The reason for the shame that would be felt by the parents of gay children is the result of the views on masculinity as prevalent in the society that can be rooted in the history of america.... Kimmel said that the formation of america was dominated by men as they played key roles in American independence and the development of its constitution.... They dare to avoid the shameful feeling, when they are adults, by being in rage secretly to their bitter memories and extremely working to excel in arts, fashion, and success....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

American Teen Cancer Society

My Health Occupation Students of america experience has been an opportunity to serve the community and to have fun at the same time.... My initial fear and even a shameful revulsion at his involuntary moans of pain and physical deterioration gave way to a deep admiration for his courage and a melting tenderness towards this man who found the strength to greet me with a cheery “Good morning, Angel!...
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us