StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Poverty and Pollution - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper will examine the ethical implications of pollution in the third world, pollution as the price for progress, moral right to human beings of a livable environment, and global pollution standards. The number of profits in a given year determined the success of any business. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Poverty and Pollution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Poverty and Pollution"

Until 1960s, businesses aimed at making profits, accumulating wealth, and offering job opportunities to the community around it. The number of jobs produced and the amount of profits in a given year determined success of any business. This view of businesses has changed in the 21st century after establishment of a better relationship between organisations and the society. Businesses have taken up social responsibility role and have to consider environmental implications before running a production process. However, poverty seems to challenge government efforts of eliminating environmental pollution. For instance, Cubatao in Brazil, which maybe the most polluted area in the whole world, has about 100,000 people living in the valley. Inhabitants have refused to sell their land and resettle elsewhere because of the readily available jobs from the industries and the cheap life around. This paper will examine the ethical implications of pollution in the third world, pollution as the price for progress, moral right to human beings of a liveable environment, and global pollution standards. Additionally, the paper will examine whether the wealthy nations have an obligation to provide poorer nations with resources to develop greener industries. Determine the ethical implications of businesses polluting in a third world country. Explain your rationale. Ethical implications of businesses polluting in a third world countries are common. First, every animal, plant, and other living things have a right to a better environment. It is unfortunate that pollution destroys their habitat shortens their lives. Additionally, pollution causes extinction of some animals resulting in an incomplete life cycle of such animals. Living things depends on one another for survival and human beings depend on them. It is unethical that a human decision can result to death and loss of livelihood. Although human beings are superior to other beings, they have an obligation to other human beings and nonhuman beings. Secondly, right to bodily security supersedes all other human right including right to property. The health of the environment is more important than all other rights because they protect human life. Therefore, pollution is unethical as it undermines a basic human right. Suggest the reasons a business may conduct operations in a third world country and disregard any standards of pollution control Some businesses may conduct operations in a third world country and disregard any standards of pollution control. To reap the benefit of cheap labour and circumvent the strict conditions of working, many companies have moved their factories to third world countries. Third world countries are in the process of development and a move by any international company to open its factories in such countries will go a long way to reduce the level of unemployment. Third world countries provide readily available cheap labour that enables overseas companies to lower their cost of production. On the other hand, the host government rejoices over the lower unemployment levels, classic products in their markets, and some taxes on profits made by such companies. Therefore, it is possible for the government to ignore some of the policies it has passed to curb pollution on such companies. Due to the significant contribution such a company makes on the economy, the government may allow loopholes on compliance of pollution policies. For instance, after Nike moved its factories in China, it continued to enjoy cheap labour without any regard to standards of pollution control until the year 1997. One of the recommendations made to Nike to improve its standards was to undertake a healthy and safety review of its factories with regard to dust, noise pollution, heat, fumes, and congestion. Additionally, Nike was to make public a list of accidents and work related illnesses that have affected workers in the past three years, determine any compensation to workers, and how the company can prevent illnesses in future (Lichtig & Wilsey, N.d). For so many years, Nike operated without paying regard to pollution policies in China because its government was silent about it. Multinationals companies establish their companies in countries whose politics can allow it. According to international and comparative law quarterly journal, politics and political risk factor is an important restraint on the flow of investment to natural resources in the third world countries (Brown, 1984). Take for instance the companies that engage in mining of oils, gold, and other natural resources. Third world countries do not have machinery to invest in the extraction of these naturally occurring resources. Therefore, they engage the services of multinationals, or sell such lands to the multinationals. Most of these mines produce harmful gases, which pollutes the atmosphere. In other cases, miners abandon mining areas after depleting the minerals without closing up the trenches they had dug. Poor politics cause such multinationals to pollute and degrade lands without the government questioning it. It has been said that pollution is the price of progress. Assess the connections between economic progress and development, on the one hand, and pollution controls and environmental protection, on the other. Some scholars suggest that pollution is the price of progress. Development determines the level of progress of any nation. It is possible to measure the level of development through income per person or through economic growth. Therefore, economic development is the process of expanding, attracting jobs, income, and wealth to improve quality of human life. Each community differs in the social, economic, and political dimensions of wealth but encourages equality in the opportunities for wealth creation. According to Cypher and Dietz, “development requires a fundamental structural change in an economy and society, which necessitates new markets, institutions, new values, and new products” (Cypher & Dietz, 2004). A nation will attract more jobs through opening up of more factories engaged in production for exports. Government fiscal and monetary policies foster activities that result in economic progress and development. In the United States, there is a body called EPA that formulates laws and procedures that ensure protection of health and environment at large. Different acts including atomic energy act, chemical safety information act, national environmental policy act, and noise control act. Each act requires the industries concerned to comply and produce effective products using the least noise and causing no harm on the environment. However, economic progress goes with establishment of many industries that emit toxic gases and add noise to the environment. Even in the countries with strict policies against pollution, it is inevitable to experience some degradation. Moreover, some economic development goes with increased pollution. For instance, building of roads opens up places and allow establishment of investments in such areas. Consequently, increased cars on the roads lead to increased levels of carbon monoxide. Therefore, pollution is the price of progress. However, improved technology with higher levels of innovation can help establish pollution free production lines, cars, and other pollution agents. Support the argument that human beings have a moral right to a livable environment regardless of the country they live in. Human beings have a moral right to a liveable environment regardless of the country they live in. I disagree with Lawrence Summers, director of national economic council and former president of Harvard University. He argues that industries currently in the developed countries should be moved to the third world countries because pollution caused would justify the forgone earnings from injuries and death. Additionally, he argues that an American life is more worth than an African one because of the lower life expectancy (Shaw, 2010). This means that some human beings are more human that others and should receive a lesser treatment. A principle from Aristotle suggests that all human beings are equal and that they share a number of similarities. These include ability to experience pleasure or pain, have sophisticated intellectual abilities, have a moral ability to distinguish right and wrong, and share an implicit social contact with each other. It is a government obligation to see to it that each of its individuals regardless of the part of the country they hail from lives in liveable environment. Therefore, all human beings deserve a liveable environment. Take a position on whether wealthy nations have an obligation to provide poorer nations with, or help them develop, greener industries and sources of energy. Explain your rationale. Developed nations have an obligation to provide poorer nations with necessary resources to greener industries and better sources of energy. Developed nations should note that planet earth is volatile, temporally, and unsustainable. Therefore, it is important that every nation strive to achieve a permanent and sustainable state. According to economist Schumacher as quoted in world health journal, technocratic individuals advocate for non-equal distribution of costs, benefits, and risks ignoring the fact that existing resources may not be sustainable or equitable in the long-run. Developed nations continue to deplete non-renewable resources, distributing them inequitably (Shrader-Frechette, 1991). Therefore, in helping developing countries, developed countries help themselves for many reasons. First, they will avoid the heavy burden they have to bear every year in support of developed countries. For instance, changes in environment and increased emission of carbon monoxide in the atmosphere have affected seasons in developing countries. This has caused less rainfall, which has led to long periods of drought and death of animals and people. Developed countries have to come in every year in support of such countries. Secondly, a polluted environment gradually affects developed countries. For instance, developed countries visit third world countries as tourists interested in watching animals in the extinction list. They also depend on third world to produce some crops like coffee and tea. Therefore, for developed countries to continue enjoying products of the third world countries and avoid huge budgets for them, they have an obligation to take part in developing greener industries. Propose a plan for uniform global pollution control standards and how you would enforce them. It is possible to formulate uniform global pollution control standards through a non-governmental organisation. The first step will require public awareness of the current situation and where the world is headed at if we do not control human activity. The second step will require support and funding of the NGO by various governments who will also accept to adhere to its policies. Thirdly, the NGO will work concurrently with the government to formulate laws and procedure to be followed by every company with the environment and health in mind. Fourthly, to ensure that each company follows these rules the NGO will agree with consumers of different products that they will not consume them if they are depleting resources and polluting the environment. Informed consumers have the power to change the normal operations of businesses and enforce a sustainable one with a liveable environment (Shrader-Frechette, 1991). References Brown, R. (1984). “The relationship between the state and the multinational corporation in the exploitation of resources,” International and Comparative Law Quarterly Journal, 33(1), 218-229 Cypher, J. & Dietz, J. (2004). The process of economic development, USA, Routledge Lichtig, S. & Wilsey, M. (N.d) “The Nike Controversy,” Retrieved from, http://www.stanford.edu/class/e297c/trade_environment/wheeling/hnike.html Shaw, W. (2010). Business Ethics: Text Book with Cases, USA, Cengage Learning Shrader-Frechette, K. (1991). “Ethics and the environment,” World Health Forum Journal, 12, 311-320 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Poverty and Pollution Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1601376-poverty-and-pollution-case-study
(Poverty and Pollution Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1601376-poverty-and-pollution-case-study.
“Poverty and Pollution Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1601376-poverty-and-pollution-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Poverty and Pollution

Poverty and Pollution in Japan, Europe and North America

An inter-relation of Poverty and Pollution will be highlighted through a case presentation and the ethical implications of the business owners towards the society, basic rights of the humans for a cleaner environment and the reasons for industrial development in Third World countries will be discussed in relation to the case study.... Environmental problems including air pollution and water pollution are some of the major health and environmental issues faced by many countries around the world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The effects of poverty and pollution on economy

Running Head: SUBURBAN poverty and THE COST OF LIVING INDEX 1 Suburban poverty and the Cost of Living Index Name Class Date Suburban poverty and the Cost of Living Index Introduction Poverty is rising in communities that have up until this point been considered the paragon of success in the framework of the American identity.... poverty rates have not only climbed because of the current economic downturn.... McGirr (2012) reports that in the previous eight years to 2008, poverty rates in suburbs had been climbing to 25% with 51 million households reporting incomes at less than 50% above the poverty line....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Poverty and Pollution: Human Right to a Clean and Safe Environment

The authors of Poverty and Pollution case 7.... This document discusses the human right to a clean and safe environment, justifies the moral obligations of developed countries towards third world countries for their incurred costs, and finally, recommends civil liability and taxations as pollution standards that are fair for global enforcement.... nbsp;… pollution has been shifting from the rich countries to the third world countries due to the cheaper means of production associated with lower costs and regulations against pollution measures....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Poverty and Pollution and Business

The present paper "Poverty and Pollution and Business" dwells on the ethical implications of businesses which pollute a third world country as a result of the operations they have set up there, the reasons that a business may conduct operations in a third world country.... Lastly, it will attempt to propose a plan for uniform global pollution control standards and the enforcement of those standards itself.... There are many different moral and ethical considerations that must be addressed when looking at the issue of the pollution of third world countries by businesses who have set up shop in those countries, including but not limited to the implications of the companies who are participating in these actions, the reasons for doing what they are doing, the moral right of human beings to a livable environment, as well as who should be responsible for these actions, and what must be done to improve the quality of life of those who are affected by these practices....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Businesses Polluting In a Third World Country

This research is being carried out to determine the ethical implications of businesses polluting in a third world country and suggest the reasons a business may conduct operations in a third world country and disregard any standards of pollution control.... This paper illustrates that businesses might choose to obey the rules that regulate pollution or risk the chance of being penalized for not obeying the pollution rules.... As governments strive to address the most basic of their fundamental needs (food, clean water, and healthcare), pollution and other countless environmental problems are neglected; with pollution primarily remaining unrestricted....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Social Demography of Health

The main focus of the study is to be able to present the possible effects of variables such as population, Poverty and Pollution on the… The effects of social issues that are not related to health such as the presented factors can be considered important since all factors in the society are interrelated.... The main focus of the study is to be able to present the possible effects of variables such as population, Poverty and Pollution on the global health....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Superman and the Misunderstanding of the Message

Superman will work to reduce the Poverty and Pollution of the society's spirit and soul and justify the happiness of its existence.... In the paper “The Superman and the Misunderstanding of the Message” the author discusses one of the most complex and most ambiguous writings in contemporary philosophy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Business Ethics dealing with Poverty and Pollution in the Environment

The paper "Business Ethics dealing with Poverty and Pollution in the Environment" will observe the reasons why businesses ignore pollution related regulations in the developing world.... This paper will discuss environmental pollution with the reference of businesses and third world countries.... nbsp;… Environmental pollution is turning out to be one of the biggest problems in the world in the 21st century.... The ethical implications of environmental pollution in the developing world are also significant....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us