StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales" focuses on the differences between youth and adult custody in England and Wales and tries to determine whether youth custody can be said to be effective. The system experiences huge pressure and there are huge demands…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales"

Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales Introduction: Considering the criminal justice system in England and Wales, it has been observedthat the system experiences huge pressure and there are huge demands that the system has to encounter. The population in prisons also reflects significant increase over the years. The criminal justice system in England and Wales has their focus on four major objectives that include: conviction of individuals who commit crimes; acquittal of individuals who are not guilty; safety of the common public from crime; and prerequisite of certain kind of compensation to the sufferers of crime (Stephens 2000). However, in the recent times youth crimes have increased significantly thus bringing out a focus on youth custody comparing it to the adult custody. The present study focuses on the differences between youth and adult custody in England and Wales and tries to determine whether youth custody can be said to be effective. Adult and Youth Custody in England and Wales: One of the major differences that have been obtained in the adult and youth custody in England and Wales involve the availability of an appropriate adult for the criminals. An appropriate adult has the responsibility to work as a defender or protector for the defenseless individuals involved in a crime and hence put under custody. The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 have created this role for the criminals under custody and an appropriate adult is supposed to be called for any vulnerable youth or adult. For the youth, local authorities or the youth offending teams have been given the statutory responsibilities by the Act to ensure for the availability of the appropriate adults for the youths under custody. Contrary to this, for the adults, there are no particular responsibilities for statutory authorities to provide the appropriate adults to the adults under custody. Hence different services are made available in different countries (The provision of appropriate adult services in England and Wales 2013). It has been found through recent studies that young offenders are reoffended more than the adult offenders. Records reflect 73 percent of young offenders being reoffended as against the 47 percent of the adult offenders being reoffended. Although education is supposed to be provided to the youths under custody, but in most cases the youth custodies have failed to be successful in providing such needed education to the offenders. The costs in some of the youth custodies are around ?200,000 which in many cases can be said to be higher than the costs of sending a child to a school. Still the custodies are unable to provide the youths with the proper education and hence they end up being reoffended. The facility for education is a major concern for the youth custodies and not for the adult custodies with an intention to send the youths back to normal lives or schooling and training (Travis 2013). The sentences for the adult prisoners are much severe as against the youth offenders. Population in the adult custody has been rising increasingly over the years with their sentences being for longer periods of time. In case of the adults the custody, in severe cases, is meant as the last resort for the offenders. While on the other hand, the youth custody is meant for correcting the young offenders such that they can live their normal lives when they are released in the society. Thus the differences lie with the concerns in regard to the adult and youth custody (Hough, Jacobson and Millie 2003). In case of the adult custody it can be said that the crime committed needs to be judged and accordingly the custody is determines keeping in focus the rising population in the prisons. In case of the youths, however, the concern is more to correct them, which in many cases have proved to be failures in England and Wales. Thus the problems encountered by the justice system in regard to the adult and the youth custodies are significantly different. This also takes into consideration the difference in the expenditures of the custodies. The Youth Custody in England and Wales: It’s Effectiveness: In England and Wales, young individuals can be detained and put in custody if they have been found to be suspicious of committing any crime or in cases where they have already committed some crimes. Considering the juvenile custodies, there are three kinds of custodial settings that are available in England. These include: Secure Children’s Home, Secure Training Centers, and Young Offender Institutes. Local authorities are responsible for the secure children’s homes and individuals between 10 and 17 years of ages are put into these custodies. In secure training centers, individuals of 12-17 years of ages are detained and this center is the responsible of the private companies. Young offender institutes are under the charge of the prison authorities and private contractors and detain people between 15 and 17 years of ages (Children’s Rights Alliance for England 2010). The growth of the youth justice system in England and Wales has been exemplified by the pressure involving control of crimes and the welfare of children throughout the initial years of the twentieth century. This scenario continued throughout the entire century. One of the major concerns was with the condition of the children and their necessity for particular conduct and concern and security when these were not available from their families. For appearance in courts for the young offenders, there are special courts called the Youth Courts that are specifically represented magistrates’ courts. These courts function in an adversarial method (Caputo and Vallee 2010). Apart from the Youth Courts, there are adult Crown Courts as well where the children and young offenders may appear for their charges and hearing of their sentences. Sentences are charged for the young individuals involved with homicide, indecent assault or other acts of crimes depending on which the imprisonment may vary up to 14 years of time. It can be said that the Crime and Disorder Act have a significant impact on the justice system in England and Wales for young offenders. “The increased use of custody provides evidence that its law and order provisions have been enacted. Its record on child welfare, on the other hand, is equivocal at best. There is little doubt, however, that for England and Wales, the Crime and Disorder Act represents the most radical overhaul of the youth justice system in fifty years” (Caputo and Vallee 2010). In England and Wales the minimum age for setting custody punishments for young offenders is 10 years of age. The rates of crimes by the youth are particularly in high in England and Wales in comparison to other countries across the world. The Youth Justice Board is responsible for prevention of the young offenders from offending and reoffending, thereby taking care of the accommodation and settlement of the young offenders, trying to determine alternatives to custody sentences, custody, diversity, education, training and employment, their health care, monitoring and practice of improving, prevention, research, and working with the victims (Williams 2012). It has been observed that the youth justice system has proved to be effective in “reducing the number of criminal offences committed by young people over the last ten years, an achievement in which the Youth Justice Board has played a central role” (The youth justice system in England and Wales: Reducing offending by young people 2011). The young offenders remaining in custodies for certain periods of time are expected not to reoffend. However there are certain negative aspects that have also been observed. For instance, 70 percent of the offenders have encountered difficulties of communication but not much concern is taken on this issue. The Board does not have enough information on the interventions that are being decided in the youth justice system or about their outcomes. Rather their focus is more on the processes than on the outcomes. There has been a plan of abolishing the Youth Justice Board which again raises question in regard to decisions of policies as well as the national focus of reduction of young offenders from committing crimes (The youth justice system in England and Wales: Reducing offending by young people 2011). Conclusion: From the above study, it can be said that with young offenders increasing in numbers over the years in England and Wales, the youth justice system has taken certain sincere measures for the justice and sentences of these individuals along with a focus on trying to correct them such that they do not reoffend and can live their normal lives when they are released in the society. Considering the causes of the crimes that are committed and the impacts of the punishment, there are differences among the adult and youth custody in the country. However, although the concerns and treatment of the youth custody have been different, yet the effectiveness of the system still remains questionable. While on one hand there are records of reduction of young offenders reoffending, there are other negative aspects that need to be taken particular concern of such that the youth custody can be said to be completely effective on prevention of young offenders. References Caputo, T. and M. Vallee (2010) A Report Prepared for the Review of the Roots of Youth Violence. Children. [Online]. Available at: http://www.children.gov.on.ca/htdocs/English/topics/youthandthelaw/roots/volume4/comparative_analysis.aspx [Accessed 7 May 2013]. Children’s Rights Alliance for England (2010) Violencefreecustody. [Online]. Available at: http://www.violencefreecustody.org.uk/about-child-custody/ [Accessed 7 May 2013]. Hough, M., Jacobson, J. and A. Millie (2003) The Decision to Imprison: Sentencing and the Prison Population. Prisonreformtrust. [Online]. Available at: http://www.prisonreformtrust.org.uk/Portals/0/Documents/decisiontoimprison.pdf [Accessed 7 May 2013]. Stephens, M. (2000) Crime and Social Policy: The Police and Criminal Justice System. London: Routledge. The provision of appropriate adult services in England and Wales (2013) RCN. [Online]. Available at: http://www.rcn.org.uk/development/communities/rcn_forum_communities/prison_nurses/news/?a=513087 [Accessed 6 May 2013]. The youth justice system in England and Wales: Reducing offending by young people (2011) Publications. [Online]. Available at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmpubacc/721/721.pdf [Accessed 8 May 2013]. Travis, A. (2013) Young offenders: government plans to put education ‘at heart of detention’. Guardian. [Online]. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/feb/14/young-offenders-education-detention-academies [Accessed 6 May 2013]. Williams, N. (2012) Youth Crime in England and Wales. Civitas. [Online]. Available at: http://www.civitas.org.uk/crime/factsheet-youthoffending.pdf [Accessed 8 May 2013]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Discuss the differences between youth and adult custody in England and Essay”, n.d.)
Discuss the differences between youth and adult custody in England and Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1476860-discuss-the-differences-between-youth-and-adult
(Discuss the Differences Between Youth and Adult Custody in England and Essay)
Discuss the Differences Between Youth and Adult Custody in England and Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1476860-discuss-the-differences-between-youth-and-adult.
“Discuss the Differences Between Youth and Adult Custody in England and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1476860-discuss-the-differences-between-youth-and-adult.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Youth and Adult Custody in England and Wales

Why do Youth Commit Offence

Youth crime has become a significant problem in england especially in the socio-economically backward areas.... in england, Wales and Northern Ireland the minimum age of criminal responsibility is set at 10 years while the boys and girls aged between 14 and 18 years are considered young adults.... in england the offending youth have a love-hate relationship with the public.... In early england, the young offenders were awarded the same punishment for petty offences as an adult....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Over Representation of Ethnic Minorities

For instance, in england and wales, the socioeconomically deprived and socially exclude ethnic minority youths have been found to be at higher risks of being crime victims or offenders are given their propensity towards committing crimes (CRC, 2008a).... This paper thus explores the reasons youths from ethnic minority groups are over-represented in the criminal justice system of Wales and england and the possible approaches with which this trend may be addressed....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Youth Justice System in England and Wales in Comparison with another Country

Title: Youth Justice System in england and wales in Comparison with another Country ... Title: Youth Justice System in england and wales in Comparison with another Country Introduction: Youth justice system or juvenile justice system is considered for the youth who commit crimes and thus contribute to severe criminal offences.... However, in england and wales, the youth justice system was more strictly taken concern of after the incident of a murder of a young child by another two 10 years' old boys....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Juvenile Justice in the United Kingdom

he notion that youth in trouble with the law may just be misguided, has the youth courts not treating these matters strictly as criminal issues, but helping to divert the juvenile from a potential adult life of crime.... They caught onto this notion through the determination that adolescent development is critical to the mental, cognitive, social and moral/ethical well being of the young adult (The World of Psychology, 1999).... The preceding Act was based on the notion that adolescent offenders were just miniature adults that were "slow" (youth in Conflict with the Law, 2000) and could not form the intent (mens rea) to commit a crime....
16 Pages (4000 words) Case Study

The Criminal Justice System of England and Wales

he World Factbook of Criminal Justice Systems also said that the legal system in england and wales is "adversarial" in all courts, including the juvenile courts.... ust like in most countries, crime in england and wales is classified and distinguished mostly on the basis of its seriousness.... riminal responsibility in england and wales is 10, so those between ages 10 and 17 are forced to face a youth court if they are charged with a criminal offense....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Punishment and Welfare in the Youth Justice System

While the retributive nature of the past has paled away and the adult-involved, rehabilitative approach has become predominant in juvenile justice, many call for increased punishment methods intertwined with the system of reprimands and warnings.... The balance of punishment and welfare methods within the warnings and reprimands system is an ever adjusting scale of offering support, assistance, education and assuming that this will bring about more commitment to social values and norms, versus controlling and punishing, while still safeguarding elementary legal rights and common sense involving youth....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Childcare Law and Policy: Risks, Rights, and Justice

Furthermore, the paper covers the problem of the early crimes among youth and how it can be controlled.... Despite the fact that risk has been considered as something directly linked to the youth and crime, it has become an important issue in response to crime, especially in youth crime.... In this study "Childcare Law and Policy: Risks, Rights, and Justice" the author concerns the contemporary policies regarding the youth care facilities in the society....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Discuss why and in what ways young people have been treated differently in the criminal justice system

It also institutes restorative justice measures as opposed to retributive ones used by the main criminal justice system, administers proper punishment and provides the necessary support to aid the youth and children in their rehabilitation process (Smith, 2013).... The adult offenders are taken through the main criminal justice system while children and youths are taken through the Youth Justice System.... Cavalion, Dignan and Mair (2013) observed that the main criminal justice system is geared towards retribution whereas the youth Justice System is geared towards rehabilitation and restoration....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us