StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The concept of universality in administration of human rights emerged in the 20th century, following signage of the UN Declaration of Human Rights by compliant member states. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity"

College: Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity The concept of universality in administration of humanrights emerged in the 20th century, following signage of the UN Declaration of Human Rights by compliant member states. This conception is founded upon the idea that fundamental principles that govern people’s rights are universal in nature. Some of the values provided for within the aforementioned declaration include the notion of individual freedom, democratic and political right for all, as well as, economic and social rights among others.

The applicability of the universality of human rights has, however, sparked significant debate. While proponents support the concept’s ideology, opponents argue against it on the basis of cultural relativism and the apolitical nature of the campaign adopted in its advocacy. Perhaps the most pervasive argument against the universal nature of human rights is that of cultural diversity. This assertion is hinged on the assertion that since every nation or society has its distinctive cultural values, a universal approach to rights cannot be applied all around the world.

A key issue in the cultural disparity argument stems from the perception that the West differs significantly from other nations, on which it attempts to impose the idea of universal human rights. This notion is perpetuated by the fact that the UN Declaration of Human Rights was adopted when majority of Third World nations had not gained independence from the principally Western colonialists. Universality of rights is therefore perceived as cover for the West to intervene in developing countries’ affairs, while spreading its individualistic socio-cultural values in otherwise community-oriented societies.

In further argument against universality, others posit that ongoing nation-building in developing countries cannot sustain individual-oriented human rights since it is a communal task. This implies that communal compliance with cultural norms is deemed viable, as opposed to upholding universal rights at the expense of an entire society’s cultural structure and stability. Although the culture relativism argument puts forth a significant consideration on the need to tailor rights to valuable societal norms, it overlooks the numerous violations of rights justified by such practices.

Upholding local or religious principles over rights may pave way for dictatorships or fundamentally religious regimes that enslave people in various ways, as an excuse for cultural adherence. An excellent example is the fundamentalist Islamic government of Saudi Arabia, which like many Middle Eastern nations defends an ideology of human rights based on the Koran, yet fails to reflect basic human rights. Saudi Arabia declined to be a signatory to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, arguing that provisions of this declaration went contrary to Islam based law.

Of particular concern was equality within the institution of marriage, which is deemed impossible in the primarily patriarchal society and the freedom of belief, among others. As a result, women are predisposed to domestic abuse and oppression and there is little to no tolerance for non-Muslims. Overall, it is unquestionable that culture plays an integral role in any society including the process of defining and upholding human rights. This implies that universal rights advocates and other stakeholders in this ongoing debate should be sensitive to disparities embedded in culture.

However, involved parties including governments and human rights campaigners should not allow cultural differences to supersede widely acknowledged civil liberties. Such fundamental universal rights include people’s right to be protected from harm, freedom to life, and freedom of existence, among others.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity Essay”, n.d.)
Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1662409-universality-of-human-rights-and-cultural-disparity
(Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity Essay)
Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1662409-universality-of-human-rights-and-cultural-disparity.
“Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1662409-universality-of-human-rights-and-cultural-disparity.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Universality of Human Rights and Cultural Disparity

Racial Disparity

Racial Disparity Nichole Olson Rasmussen College Author Note This research is being submitted on May 22, 2011, for Callie Lacy J350/CCJ3678 Section 03 Cultural Diversity and Justice course at Rasmussen College Racial Disparity The last decades, significant efforts have been made for securing human rights in the international community.... Racial disparity is just an aspect of the above phenomenon.... Racial disparity, or else racial discrimination, is a term included two elements: ‘a) differential treatment on the basis of race that disadvantages a racial group and b) treatment on the basis of inadequately justified factors other than race that disadvantages a racial group' (Blank, Dabady & Citro 2004, p....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

A REPORT ON GENDER SECURITY AND EDUCATION FOR ALL

Education empowers women and girls to be familiar with their rights and claim them confidently.... Gender security is one of the most complicated issues, where this report found out that there are various ways of understanding planning concepts of learning resources in order to address gender disparity.... To ensure that there is no disparity in accessing education for both genders; teachers should ensure that there is proper planning for learning resources....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Concept of Cosmopolitanism

The history of the relationships between local and regional conceptions is old as a human race.... This paper ''Cosmopolitanism'' tells that Cosmopolitanism is said to be the concept of where humanity belongs to a single community perhaps based on a shared morality.... This may simply refer to an inclusive morality, shared economic relationships of nations, and/or political structures that cover different nations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

One Mans Terrorist Is Another Mans Freedom Fighter

This paper will discuss the conflict between Western perspective and Eastern perspective with regard to the crucial issue of human rights.... We in the West take human rights for granted; we believe these are cherished ideals to be fought for, as they are the foundation of a robust democracy.... Indeed, we have been quick to label those who advocate measures that to our minds are repressive, as dictators or terrorists or right wing conservatives, when in fact, they are merely acting in accordance with the cultural norms of their community....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Relations between Cultural Claims, Power and Universal Human Rights

This paper "The Relations between Cultural Claims, Power and Universal Human Rights" attempts to elicit the relationship between cultural claims, power, and universal human rights and their relevance in a world that is marching toward economic globalization.... While traditionally, notions of cultural identity held sway over other abstract categorizations, the world of neo-liberal economic globalization has given precedence to universal human rights and justice....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Are human rights truly universal Give reasons for your answer

Protection of human rights has been the sole mandate of the United Nations (UN).... Besides, they have developed instruments that have been able to counter the effect of human rights violations.... In other areas, the concept of human rights is foreign; in fact, it is seen as a western issue (Brown and Ainsley 2009, pg 5).... This helps cast doubt of the universal nature of human rights.... The fact that there are individuals that are not aware of their rights makes it impossible to think of human rights from a universal perspective....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Usefulness of the Heritage Kit

It has also played the biggest role in the implementation of cultural competency during health education.... hellip; According to the study cultural awareness- cultural awareness is the knowledge of the predominant culture in a community and how such cultures affect the perception in various health issues.... nbsp; As the discussion highlights cltural imposition- cultural imposition is the tendency by a nurse to apply the majority culture on every individual without any further probing....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Effects of Ethics on Pursuit of Security

They deserve to compromise human rights and civil liberties for them to be sure of being safe (Closs, et al.... human rights are political privileges that are enjoyed at the time of stability.... Ethics are aligned with the preservation of the rights of an individual....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us